Might as well buy a GT72 at this time.
NOPE, Alienware and MSI are neck and neck, Asus is a distant third, after Clevo. Having the worst speakers of any gaming notebook drops them off the chart.
The day I buy a gaming laptop based on the speakers feels like the day I am doing it wrong. Not that someone can't place a high premium on it, but honestly in a laptop format, the best audio is always headphones/headset. The speakers on my alienware are admittedly pretty good, but I didn't consider the speakers into the purchase at all.
There are really 3 huge things I look at when you start judging premium grade laptops:
- THe hardware (4k screens, 980m/970m/970m sli), high grade i7 4th gen processors, and then really good HDD/SD). For me, the graphics amplifier was a nice bonus that pushed alienware ahead of the pack.
- Cooling. This is vital. You can have the beefiest of the beefiest hardware, but it doesn't matter if you have average to poor cooling. You don't want to risk overheating. You don't want to risk part burnout after a year or two. If you are investing in a high end laptop, cooling should be an important factor. Asus and Alienware lead in this department by a pretty big margin.
- Quality of the build. You don't want flimsy keyboards, or the case built out of cheap materials. You want something that is durable and comfortable. Style is mostly just a bonus, not a requirement.
MSI does throw in mechanical keyboards on some models which is a huge bonus for some and adds into the quality of the build, but they aren't on par with cooling. Last but not least of course is getting all of that for the best price point.
I've read many reviews and have tried out several different brands in person. Sager gives you most the beef for the cheapest price, but the build quality isn't up there and they sacrifice in cooling. My friend had one with the 880m back when that was the top of hte line mobile card and he had his parts start malfunctioning due to constantly high temps after a year.
MSI gives you the mechanical keyboard and an alright, very basic, build. Cooling is better than the sager, but not as good as Asus and Alienware.
MSI tends to be a bit cheaper than Asus for what you can get for the hardware.
Asus, has a very, very good build quality. I'd argue it might be the best build quality for laptops period. It might not always look sexy, but they don't cheap out on the build. No mechanical keyboards here, but top notch cooling and superior build. Bit pricier.
Alienware is right around the Asus - pretty much matching in cooling and maybe a small step back in build quality. Of course, Alineware also goes for style with all the lights and a unique design - which some certianly will enjoy. Not really important of course. However, surprisingly, alienware is a bit more affordable in some instances with the hardware compared to the Asus. though, it does suck you can';t get a 4k screen without it being a touch screen. Just never been into the whole touch thing on a laptop. I guess artists might really like it?
The differentiator to me in the 2015 models was the graphics amplifier. It's designed right into the build. It's the primary reason I went with them, even though there was a refurbished asus with a 980m for just $20 more I could have gotten.
But, that amplifier isn't going to matter for some, especially in the laptop department when your someone who travels a lot and doesn't get to use their rig at home on a desk.
So, I'd say it's more so: Alienware/Asus, MSi right on their tales, and then everyone else duking it out for 4th, with different companies coming ahead in different areas.
But I think a lot of this may have to do with what we truly value in laptop design. I just don't view speakers as something that valuable, though I would be kidding myself if the higher end model of the alienware with the built in subwoofer didn't seem like a cool concept. Just not something that was worth the extra money really. My only disappointment is that my RPM's on this HD are only 5400, but it hasn't been much of an issue since it's a storage drive that occasionally runs games I don't put on the SSD there.
I also noticed I have a nice expandable bay in my rig, so I will be looking to add a 2nd SSD drive down the road.