Again, GAF memories are really short sometimes. Dark Souls 2 was not being slammed for its gameplay or world design before release. It was being slammed because of the graphics. Once it was actually released it was "OMG this is so great!" "OMG it's better than Dark Souls!" and anyone that disagreed was spat upon. That same cycle continued with Bloodborne too.
happens with almost every game...people want the game to be good so when its first released everyone goes crazy and claims how amazing it is...after a few weeks you see more people start to criticize and point out flaws...a few months down the road the game goes from amazing to average or worse...I'm hoping DS3 really lives up to the hype in this thread and others and really delivers the goods