Comic Book Girl 19: Why Being Honest about Ghostbusters is Important
Well, just watched through this -- I like the work this lady does.
I didn't agree with her, which I found pretty surprising after realizing where she was coming from. I felt that she carried her examination with a pretty heavy dose of cynicism (and I do consider myself something of a cynic) and, quite uncharacteristically of her, completely dismissive of any reason that this film might be seen favorably. She felt largely the same way about The Force Awakens, but didn't seem to outright dismiss contrary opinions there.
I mean, I did personally enjoy the movie. I don't feel like I loved it, and I do agree with her statement that I'll most likely forget most of it in a couple of weeks, but I had a decent time seeing it last night. I did not leave my screening believing I had lost out on my money or my time. I went in with reservation and it pretty easily satisfied my "please be good" disposition.
Ghostbusters pre-dated me, I was born a few years after the film's original release. My parents were fans, though, so they showed me the movie and I loved it. It, for seemingly all my life, has been reliable source of entertainment. I have a lifelong rapport that has never been broken with the original Ghostbusters film. This new film very, very obviously loses out on that long trust, but I still liked it.
I genuinely felt that the movie was funny. I don't possess a personality type that really participates in laugh-out-loud behavior when I think something is "funny," and that held true when I watched the new Ghostbusters, but I found it to be charmingly quirky and tactfully respectful of its predecessors. Sure, it had derivative elements from the plot structure of the original, but it felt far less derivative than The Force Awakens AND I loved The Force Awakens (I in fact liked Force Awakens more than I liked this movie).
I'm having a hard time wrapping my mind around what makes Ghostbusters in particular that one film that has a trailer that becomes the most disliked film trailer of all time on YouTube, and the one film that makes venerated YouTube personalities like Comic Book Girl 19 and James Rolfe get extremely up in arms about the quality and integrity of it even existing, etc... I mean, I totally loved Force Awakens but I totally understood where CBG19 stood on that film, but she never presented that opinion in a way that made it feel dismissive of people that liked it. I'm not being dishonest as CBG19 seems to assert and I certainly don't feel like I'm stupid or have been manipulated by a cheap cash-in business scheme when I say that I liked the movie.