Clinton has pneumonia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Her getting pneumonia literally right after this health craze against her is oddly coincidental. Its actually good reason to suspect trump was on to something. Thats actually a serious illness that people can die from

I just can't figure out the brain that works this way. I really can't.
 
They are handling this right. Walking pneumonia really does exist and I commend her for even campaigning whike sick.

From an optics perspective, if Trump and his ilk push this and push too far, it might even backfire for them and I hope it does.
 
Trump wasn't on to anything. Most of the alt-right concern trolling about her health was fixated on baseless speculation about completely unrelated conditions without any evidence.

The fact that she developed pneumonia was coincidental to this health concern trolling by Trump supporters. They'll claim they were right all along, but this is coincidental to their witch hunt.

Maybe he was? He did predict 9/11 after all...now this other prediction of Hillary's sickness landing on the memorial of 9/11? It can't be a coincidence.
 
I wonder if anyone in her entourage or press pool have come down? It wouldn't be her fault especially if she didn't know before fri

Obviously neither the Secret Service nor her aids are worried. She's being treated for it and, from the looks of it, isn't that serious until she combined it with dehydration today.
 
I just can't figure out the brain that works this way. I really can't.

His followers give him credit for predicting acts of terrorism. He is a god to them.

Welp, if we can't have a serious discussion, I'm out.

Because the concern is so ridiculous and petty. The contagiousness of pneumonia is pretty low to begin with but she's already gotten antibiotics so it's a virtual non-issue going forward.
 
I think that if I was elderly, young, or immune compromised I would appreciate that people with contagious pneumonia stay home or at least disclose so I could keep my distance.

You're missing the part where the outbreaks occur because of prolonged contact. Because pneumonia is transmitted through water droplets (remember, Hillary doesn't sweat!) unless she picked her nose, didn't wash her hands, and then vigorously rubbed and sneezed on a bunch of doorknobs afterwards everyone is fine.

And this is all merely hypothetical, because she's been on a course of antibiotics! Which means this theoretical minimal risk we've been discussing isn't even applicable, because the antibiotic course means she isn't contagious even in the slightest.

And I know that if she did take some time for bed rest I'd be admonishing you for crying about how it was proof she can't handle the presidency because of her failing health. Your option select won't work on me!
 
Look guys I once read a thread about a bunch of people who knew people who had pneumonia. It's no joke.

Meh, I had it once as a kid. Ain't no big deal, hurts like a motherfucker though. And I had to be medicated for 2 months or something iirc. Okay it's kinda serious. But with rich-person care it shouldn't be *all* too serious.
 
OK, how on earth is this an excuse? Most doesn't mean all. She actually risked the health of other people by hugging them.

I must be missing something here, this looks either like a lie or ridiculous levels of irresponsibility.

You are. Which is the medical context that you can't really get from a CDC page. And given the context the risk of transmission is probably even lower.
 
You're missing the part where the outbreaks occur because of prolonged contact. Because pneumonia is transmitted through water droplets (remember, Hillary doesn't sweat!) unless she picked her nose, didn't wash her hands, and then vigorously rubbed and sneezed on a bunch of doorknobs afterwards everyone is fine.

And this is all merely hypothetical, because she's been on a course of antibiotics! Which means this theoretical minimal risk we've been discussing isn't even applicable, because the antibiotic course means she isn't contagious even in the slightest.

And I know that if she did take some time for bed rest I'd be admonishing you for crying about how it was proof she can't handle the presidency because of her failing health. Your option select won't work on me!

We know she coughs a whole lot that's one way to spread it.
 
Tim Kaine really needs to step up to the plate now. Doesn't matter if Hillary's health is a legit concern, the perception is definitely going to be there now.

Hillary would probably already be finished with this news if she had someone like Palin as VP. Thankfully Kaine is no Palin, but the better he can do the less of an issue this will be.

The VP debate's probably going to be like the most important VP debate ever, with Trump wanting his VP to do most of the job of being president for him.
 
The vitriol from the right on this is absolutely disgusting. Holy shit, I cannot wait for Clinton to straight up eviscerate in the fall.

What a joke of a political party.
 
It's good that they came out and said what the illness is. The extreme defensiveness in the other thread is hilarious though. Any idea that just happens to align with something Trump has said, such as Hillary being ill, automatically gets you branded as an evil Trump supporter. Get a grip people.
 
Her getting pneumonia literally right after this health craze against her is oddly coincidental. Its actually good reason to suspect trump was on to something. Thats actually a serious illness that people can die from

No, it does not. The right-wing conspiracy theories involved months of trying to find visual evidence of some serious chronic condition that would seriously affect her ability to lead. All of that has so far led nowhere. Pneumonia is an acute, serious, but temporary condition, and HRC having it does not validate the right's chronic case of confirmation bias.
 
OK, how on earth is this an excuse? Most doesn't mean all. She actually risked the health of other people by hugging them.

I must be missing something here, this looks either like a lie or ridiculous levels of irresponsibility.

No one knows what's the causative agent of her specific pneumonia so no one knows how contagious or not it really is. And she's certainly being treated since diagnosed which considerably decreases the possibility of it being contagious if at all.
 
OK, how on earth is this an excuse? Most doesn't mean all. She actually risked the health of other people by hugging them.

I must be missing something here, this looks either like a lie or ridiculous levels of irresponsibility.

When you get a cold, or other viral or bacterial infection, do you lock yourself in a hermetically sealed room or something?

Millions, if not billions of people around the world are going to work while sick as we speak.

The risks involved for any specific transmission are so mindbogglingly small, you might as well criticise Hillary for risking all of these people getting struck by lightning by being outside with her.
 
His followers give him credit for predicting acts of terrorism. He is a god to them.

But even if you aren't a Trump follower, there are people who really think this way. It's bizarre to me. They strike me as marks; the type of people PT Barnum would have a field day with. They read the horoscope every day and believe every word. So I guess it's a shit ton of people, then? I don't know. That mentality just raises a red flag to me, every single time. It strikes me as weakness.
 
eh, wait for the next Rupert Murdoch thread to see liberals to act the same way.

Neither side is willing to take a stand and show some decency. It's like we're all racing towards destroying every bit of humanity and empathy we have.

Most of the posters here are saying stuff like that sucks, hope she gets better. Which is the response most people should have even if it was Ted Cruz or Trump getting sick. But then you have these people who just instantly want to take it into the mud.
 
It's good that they came out and said what the illness is. The extreme defensiveness in the other thread is hilarious though. Any idea that just happens to align with something Trump has said, such as Hillary being ill, automatically gets you branded as an evil Trump supporter. Get a grip people.
I think it's something akin to crying wolf, except if some jackass outside your pen kept shouting it and you're going "dude, shut the fuck up what are you doing" and then no one takes you seriously at first when YOU are the one crying wolf because they're eating the sheep and chasing you up a tree.
 
Both candidates are very old. Their health should be a major issue for this election. Especially if they are looking to run for two terms.

A sane person would rest. But for Mrs Clinton, winning the presidency is much more important than her health.
 
We know she coughs a whole lot that's one way to spread it.

you have to actually cough on the people, and not just a dry cough but a deep wet cough that spews mucus and phlegm particles everywhere

has this argument devolved so far that we are now arguing over whether hillary theoretically does the vampire cough or not

with the context being that she's been on antibiotics and the minimal risk of being contagious is nullified anyways

and i'm just going to let you know that you better be in favor of universal national healthcare and an end to our culture of dragging ourselves to work after coming down with the sickness, or else you're going to come off as pretty foolish
 
Trump doesn't need to attack Hillary here. The Alt-Right and conventional conservatives news sources are already doing it. Look at Drudge, Fox, etc.

This stuff then bleeds into the mainstream press with concern trolling.

To be fair, I do think Hillary's health is a concern. It can swing the polls. You'd be blind if you didn't think this is the case.
 
...I don't understand a lot of the comments on the first couple of pages. The whole point people were talking about her health was that clearly there was something more to the situation than fainting due to the "insanely hot" wheather yall tried to claim caused this. Thus if anything those questioning her health are vindicated by this news, and the reactionary responses seem out of place.

Either way I hope she feels better.
 
You are. Which is the medical context that you can't really get from a CDC page. And given the context the risk of transmission is probably even lower.

So let me get this straight, pneumonia is a very dangerous condition which sometimes becomes fatal especially for the elder and kids. And you're telling me that it's A-OK to hug children and older people if you have it because the risk of transmission is low?

Are you seriously telling me that if you had pneumonia you'd hug your daughter for example because it's not that contagious? Seriously?
 
you have to actually cough on the people, and not just a dry cough but a deep wet cough that spews mucus and phlegm particles everywhere

has this argument devolved so far that we are now arguing over whether hillary theoretically does the vampire cough or not

with the context being that she's been on antibiotics and the minimal risk of being contagious is nullified anyways

and i'm just going to let you know that you better be in favor of universal national healthcare and an end to our culture of dragging ourselves to work after coming down with the sickness, or else you're going to come off as pretty foolish

You bet your ass we need single payer healthcare and for workplaces to allow employees to stay home when they are contagious.

This is where Bernie was a fantastic candidate.
 
Tim Kaine really needs to step up to the plate now. Doesn't matter if Hillary's health is a legit concern, the perception is definitely going to be there now.

Hillary would probably already be finished with this news if she had someone like Palin as VP. Thankfully Kaine is no Palin, but the better he can do the less of an issue this will be.

The VP debate's probably going to be like the most important VP debate ever, with Trump wanting his VP to do most of the job of being president for him.

Bring Bidem in to tutor Kaine?
 
When you get a cold, or other viral or bacterial infection, do you lock yourself in a hermetically sealed room or something?

Millions, if not billions of people around the world are going to work while sick as we speak.

The risks involved for any specific transmission are so mindbogglingly small, you might as well criticise Hillary for risking all of these people getting struck by lightning by being outside with her.

So its okay because other people do it? Speaking as someone who had Pneumonia where taking 10 steps from my bed made me have to take a minute just to catch my breath because it felt like I couldn't breath and took me a month to fully recover, stay the fuck home if you have pneumonia.
 
Both candidates are very old. Their health should be a major issue for this election. Especially if they are looking to run for two terms.

A sane person would rest. But for Mrs Clinton, winning the presidency is much more important than her health.

...because Hillary hasn't always been a workaholic. Only to win the presidency.

Also, a sane person would want to rest. A lot don't have that option. Millions of people around the world go to work while ill. Hopefully this isn't news.
 
Neither side is willing to take a stand and show some decency. It's like we're all racing towards destroying every bit of humanity and empathy we have.

Most of the posters here are saying stuff like that sucks, hope she gets better. Which is the response most people should have even if it was Ted Cruz or Trump getting sick. But then you have these people who just instantly want to take it into the mud.

I kind of stopped getting into it regarding politics when the death of political figures was met with flurries of "Great! Good! Fuck 'em! Burn in hell!" etc. It didn't used to be like that, or at least people kept it hidden more. Toxic attitudes, it's sad to see.
 
Man, it's almost like Trump's going to pretend pneumonia isn't temporary and milk this as the only point in his favor all campaign. Well, that and White Nationalism.

Hilary's far from my ideal candidate, but with everyone we have on the ballot... I hope she gets well soon (Also because pneumonia sucks and no one should have to deal with it. Yikes). She's at a safe point; I think she can slow her push for a minute to rest.
 
I was probably too brusque. Let me kind of elaborate.

Pneumonia is the condition of having inflammation in the lungs due to fluid. It is not itself contagious, but it can be dangerous.

Mostly you get pneumonia from an infection. Infections, obviously, can be contagious. But that doesn't mean they will necessarily give you pneumonia! Pneumonia just means the infection got really bad, not that it will make everybody who gets it as sick as you got. There are lots of factors that affect how an infection hits you including just plain bad luck.

So: the common cold is infectious. The common cold can develop into pneumonia. But if you have pneumonia from getting a cold, you're not going to give people pneumonia. You will just give them a cold.

Walking pneumonia, aka atypical pneumonia, is just pneumonia that has a different presentation than pneumonia normally has, generally including feeling better than most people with pneumonia feel. (Hence "walking" -- because you can walk around and do things without looking like you have pneumonia.)

If you got pneumonia from a virus then there's no particular treatment other than fluids and rest. If you got pneumonia from bacteria than you can take antibiotics. Once you take antibiotics you're generally not contagious any more.

So if Hillary took antibiotics, she probably had some kind of bacterial pneumonia, took antibiotics, and is probably not contagious, which is why she went out and did things, but still needs some rest.

Sorry for my overintensity!

Thank you for clearing it up. Obviously my doctors never explained it well or I just misunderstood.
 
Her getting pneumonia literally right after this health craze against her is oddly coincidental. Its actually good reason to suspect trump was on to something. Thats actually a serious illness that people can die from

...so what does getting pneumonia have to do with the bullshit health claims Trump and his ilk have been peddling for some time now, ranging from her being unstable as a result of a concussion, to her having a stroke during this or that interview, and whatever else?

This "health craze" is not some recent thing. The coincidence here is that she fell ill during the tail end of a tough presidential campaign, when the right's narrative about her health would become even louder and more distorted. That's all.

That she is a human being who is capable of getting sick was never in question, Trump is not a goddamn doctor, and nothing the right has ever said about her health pointed to the mere possibility of her coming down with pneumonia. For God's sake.
 
You bet your ass we need single payer healthcare and for workplaces to allow employees to stay home when they are contagious.

This is where Bernie was a fantastic candidate.

okay good, we agree :)

a bit odd that you support a candidate who is against universal healthcare and wants to repeal the affordable care act, but at least maybe after this election you'll support someone who better matches your stated views
 
Hopefully she has a speed recovery. I've seen people younger than her in the hospital with pneumonia. It can get pretty damn serious.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom