Just put a few hours into this game again tonight. I've really not long left the Grand Plateau, I have a horse and I'm slowly but surely making my way on my first main mission I was given... doing lots of off the beaten path exploring and wow, this game...
It must be, easily, the most exquisitely pieced together game I've ever played. There's so much to see and to do, the pacing of enemy encounters is perfection, the sense of achievement and gaining reward every few minutes is just staggering. I'm honestly just amazed at how well put together this all is. Every gameplay mechanic is simple and they all merge together so nicely. Having a brief glance through this thread and it's clear I've not even begun in this game either. It just seems absolutely chock full of content and not just "here's a million waypoints directing you straight to some pointless collectible", but honest to god "I feel like I'm on a proper organic adventure" sort of content.
This is truly the RPG of my dreams. This is exactly what I've been after but no one has been giving me. No overly complex and abstract turn based fighting. No repetitive-to-the-point-of-insanity spawning enemies every 5 steps. No overly written Tolkien wannabe fanboy trash that goes on and on yet is as dull as dishwater. A world that geographically basically never repeats. Even the forested areas I've seen all have their own unique layout and feel to them. The whole map feels unique and not just something copy/pasted together just to fill up some space. It's all so meticulously designed.
I love for instance trying to climb a steep hill/mountain in the rain and not being able to do it, until I realise there's some places where I have just enough of a slope to rest and regain my stamina. I feel, for as simple as it is, that I've actually had to think about climbing this mountain to achieve my aim, size it up and make a plan of action. The game is just full of that, really rewarding common sense logical based puzzling, much of it environmentally so.
AHHH
I could keep going on but I'm just stunned. This is perhaps the first game in years, perhaps of my entire life, where putting the hours in is endlessly rewarding. I truly don't think I've been bored once, or if so for maybe 30 seconds and that was it. I'm guessing I've played maybe 10-15 hours so far which is more time than I spend with most games before giving up. This game has just begun for me.
The short and restrained music does just enough, the art design of course is just sublime (though please Nintendo patch out/reduce the amount of really light haze in the immediate foreground that does take away some of the saturation from the colour palette of the game). It's basically just enchanting. It's how I imagine other people have felt playing similar games in the past but where perhaps my expectations were too high to ever be satisfied and my imagination not creative enough to fill in the blanks. This meets my expectations. This is what gaming can be, and shows the levels it can reach, from pure gameplay alone.
What an achievement.