• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

LTTP: Alan Wake 2 (Xbox Series X) 2023

EverydayBeast

ChatShitGPT Alpha 0.001
For anyone interested in a solid third person poltergeist game this might be the one for you.

Nothing is as beautiful as this world of terror, world of shadow people, Bright Falls, Washington, with its on going "Deer Fest", the nature, every street has something like coffee world, or the sheriffs office and there's all kinds of things like the Cauldron Lake, and the camping grounds or the super natural hidden dimension "Dark Place" it's all powered by the north light engine.

6544bf00d880ecdd52ccc46e_image-2023-11-3_11-17-22.webp


I remember how advanced the FBI aspects of Alan Wake 2 felt, and so what happened with Alan Wake 2 is you're split into two characters, you play as special agent Saga, and you're dealing with using evidence to pin point your next objective.

6544c372589da1e2a2285809_luau_weather_system.webp


VFX team used Luau to implement a weather system - The different weather conditions can be quickly tested through a debug panel.

6544d4dc52652337e5f1e521_meshlet_visualization1.webp


Half of the game you play as "Saga" but you can switch "realities" by entering a puddle through a janitors closet. Wow.

So going into Alan Wake 2's story I knew I was getting into a super natural nightmare scenario but I grew up watching horror, playing horror and reading it you know what I'm saying, but you get into these part of the games early on about trying to solve a murder mystery, what happens is Robert Nightinagle was murdered by a "Cult of the Tree" group who's plan is to basically kill Alan Wake, but these shadow people "Takens" come after you, so now you are fighting cult members, and shadow taken people.

OIP.HJm566qRxUm6HgtXWhhngQHaEK


The combat is really straight forward, its you know shoot and kill, there's weapon upgrades, and inventory, I thought it was a solid quick set up. I imagine they could improve some aspects of it but a lot of the time you're using your flash light of all things. You can also backhand enemies.

screenshot-2023-10-27-11-14-38.jpg


Items you discover to prepare for future enemies, weapons you find are the shotgun, sewed off shotgun and a rifle.

This game has 19 episodes, 10 for saga and 9 legit missions for Alan. It's easy to switch between them through the janitors room.

You get these "rituals" of murder scenes that has you multiple times going to your "Mind Place" on a plot board to change scenes like for example in the subway it involves a collapsed tunnel but going to your "Mind Place" and changing the site to a regular tunnel you see these new environments playing a world that you know isn't true, but you're seeing it through the eyes of a cult member, or police officer, it's a real pleasure to play but to keep moving forward you can actually get lost and you got to go through different sites, it can be a lot for the casual gamer.

Cult-Stash-Location-8-at-Watery-in-Alan-Wake-2.jpg

One of the areas, Watery, WA has you going to coffee world, the lighthouse trailer park and has you controlling Saga doing so.



They did a lot of in human scenes, a combination of movie and game this was some crazy stuff.

alan-wake-2-alan-wake.gif


A 90 on Metacritic

Alan-Wake-2-Cast-All-Voice-Actors-and-Characters.png


One of the best casts in a video games,



Building relationships with your coworkers was really fun, imagine profiling someone mid game so you build something towards an objective, this person is telling the truth.

OIP.ezNfIKBWmxJcSOoCv0iIyQHaDt


It doesn't matter if the game is perfect, but the mind place, things like going into the overlap are game changers, that adds a chaotic nature it probably the craziest stuff ever, the dark vs light and if you aren't willing to hang out in a section of a game for more than 10 mins this game isn't for you and just how this game is constructed is a game changer. I swear Scratch was the best villain, what's truth, what's reality. Without having this aspect I think you'd just have Resident Evil 2, Alan Wake 2 to Alan Wake 1 but when you mention Alan Wake 2 you know it keeps going forward and isn't considered DLC like you know some say games sequels today are just DLC to the original. I was sitting in my room playing this and was struct by it's profound sense of horror because I know you're navigating this complex, world and trying to solve murder. So rich in collecting, you're always having a moment with a puzzle or case and everything feels chaotic in a good game. Pausing from Alan Wake 2 just leaves you wanting to play it more.

What did GAF think of Alan Wake 2?
 
I remember it looking amazing, with a solid story, and that it had great direction. I liked it a lot.

But I disliked the combat since shooting those shadow people felt like hitting a cloud, no weight or satisfaction to it.

I disliked how slow the characters run, even in combat they half-ass it.

I disliked the dancing scene. It felt performative, like trying to force a viral video.
 
I have it on my wishlist but I've yet to buy/play it. It's pretty cheap on sale right now, but I'm still not very excited for it. I lost a lot of interest when I read the gemeplay is nothing special and the game is very story heavy.
I like the gameplay in most Remedy games but I'm not really into their storytelling, it always feels like all style over substance. Just a bunch random stuff that's weird just for the sake of it and never comes together into anything coherent or memorable. The fact they always want you to stop playing every 5 minutes and read 24.000 documents to at least make some sense of it all doesn't help.

At least Control and Quantum Break had pretty fun combat to carry the experience. If that's not the case here I'm not sure I'll like it.
 
I enjoyed it but it could've and should've been better. Incredible graphics. Incredible atmosphere. Great voice acting. The music video section was great and weird.

Combat stinks. Saga stinks. The whole vision board mechanic is boring.

Still love Remedy.
 
Game still has some technical jank on all platforms and Remedy was the biggest Nvidia shill for this game. Visually crippled on consoles and crippled on AMD and Intel GPUs. They literally announced on GDC they skipped implementation optimizations that would boost performance on AMD GPUs (so desktop and consoles) because it would somehow slow Nvidia GPUs. Raster is compromised in reflections and shadows, RT is fine, PT is again compromised due to terrible native denoiser than isn't ray reconstruction. Also no FSR updates, no XeSS, no FSR Frame Generation or Anti-Lag 2.

As for the game itself, might as well be 10/10. Great visuals, great art style, great level design, great story, great audio design, solid amount of content, great dual upgrade system, great gameplay loops, great atmosphere. And a great sequel to multiple games at ones.

Can't wait for Remedy's next story based game.
 
Last edited:
This is a complicated one...
While I love AW1 and play it every few month since release, I imagined something different with part 2.

The beginning with Saga is great and made lots fun (FBI agent murder mystery in rainy forest with supernatural elements) but I started to wonder when I get to play as Alan Wake in ALAN WAKE 2?!

There is just too little Alan in Alan Wake 2 for my taste. The levels that you finally have to play as him are boring and don't have much to do with the story of the first part. There were simply too many new facets built into the story.

Also, I like the crazy abstractness in Remedy games, but with Alan Wake 2 they overdid it a bit.

It's like expecting an episode of the X-Files (Part 1) but getting House of 1000 Corpses (Part 2) instead!

Edit: I still hope they port Quantum Break to PS5 someday. One of Remedys best and obviously part of the Remedyverse which they certainly want to establish on all platforms!
 
Last edited:
I didn't like the Saga part of the game. There wasn't anything bad about her part, but I waited 13 years for an Alan Wake sequel, and I feel like I only got half of one. Time Breaker DLC episode was awesome.
 
Last edited:
What did GAF think of Alan Wake 2?
As a fan of original (even American Nightmare) I keep trying to get further in it but I make it an hour and get stuck again.
I like the investigation room elements, but the actual game - less so.
Combat is a chore and decidedly not as engaging as the first game, visuals are awkwardly disappointing (the outdoor areas never feel like outdoors - and performance in them is particularly problematic), the maps overall feel a lot more claustrophobic despite the relatively open structure in Saga parts at least, and the horror elements just aren't very... compelling this time around.

I may eventually power through the whole game but at this rate it'll take me at least another year. 🤷‍♀️
 
Last edited:
likely the most narcissistic, self-indulgent game i've ever had the displeasure of playing (& i couldn't even trade it in cuz it was digital only!) the original alan wake was inspired & fun. this was just.. the complete opposite...
 
Loved Alan Wake 1, and American Nightmare. I was super hyped for Alan Wake 2 and then I started seeing previews where you play as a woman agent. No thanks. Is it too much to ask to want to play as Alan Wake in an Alan Wake game? Wouldn't play it even if it was free now.
 
Last edited:
Really an incredible game, probably Remedy's best.
Loved Alan Wake 1, and American Nightmare. I was super hyped for Alan Wake 2 and then I started seeing previews where you play as a woman agent. No thanks. Is it too much to ask to want to play as Alan Wake in an Alan Wake game? Wouldn't play it even if it was free now.
I was unsure at first too, but Saga is a great character. Her role in the story was very well thought out. A lot of time has passed between Alan Wake 1 and 2, having an outsider's perspective allows the player to unravel the mystery with the protagonist. And besides, half the game is still Alan. If you love the original you owe it to yourself to at least give it a shot. I 100%'d it along with the DLC and it's an all-timer in my opinion.
 
I just recently got this and was surprised. I didn't care for the first game because I didn't find the encounters fun. But this game has more of an adventure element to it and more of a detective type of game than action. I think it's great so far and such a beauty of a game playing on the deck. I like the new main character too and wouldn't have minded if the whole game was her.
 
I thought it was a bit crap compared to AW1 and Control, with barely any original idea or memorable moment on top of being short, full of backtracking and poorly optimized.

Also the shared universe thing with the FBC was done with the subtlety of a brick through a windshield.

What a disappointment after AW1.
 
I liked it but I did not like playing with that FBI agent. I wanted to play as Alan, not as some random woman. But its a good game and it has amazing moments like the musical
 
I have it on my wishlist but I've yet to buy/play it. It's pretty cheap on sale right now, but I'm still not very excited for it. I lost a lot of interest when I read the gemeplay is nothing special and the game is very story heavy.
I like the gameplay in most Remedy games but I'm not really into their storytelling, it always feels like all style over substance. Just a bunch random stuff that's weird just for the sake of it and never comes together into anything coherent or memorable. The fact they always want you to stop playing every 5 minutes and read 24.000 documents to at least make some sense of it all doesn't help.

At least Control and Quantum Break had pretty fun combat to carry the experience. If that's not the case here I'm not sure I'll like it.
I hated Max Payne for the exact opposite reason, I prefer other shooters if I want that but not from Remedy.
 
I quite liked it. I actually liked Saga's campaign for what it was. I found Alan's switching the portal mechanic cheap and frustrating at times. I wanted more Alan but not more of this Alan.

There were some genuinely creepy parts too. I still preferred Control though. Performance was also rough on the Series X and had those weird artifacts (can't remember if it was using FRS).

I think its greater than the sum of its parts ultimately.
 
Insane production values but the game itself just wasn't really great? Hard to pinpoint but it didn't keep me interested for long.

It also borders on pretentious, the game is very pleased with itself. Half the time you're playing the game basically goes "look at this thing we're doing, isn't this crazy? Doesn't this look spoopy? Isn't this weird?" and I'm thinking yeah sure this situation is kinda weird and freaky but I'm not really enjoying myself at all.
 
Insane production values but the game itself just wasn't really great? Hard to pinpoint but it didn't keep me interested for long.

It also borders on pretentious, the game is very pleased with itself. Half the time you're playing the game basically goes "look at this thing we're doing, isn't this crazy? Doesn't this look spoopy? Isn't this weird?" and I'm thinking yeah sure this situation is kinda weird and freaky but I'm not really enjoying myself at all.
I think the game needed a little bit of gameplay variety when destroying monsters. The way it goes is basically like if RE only had zombies all game with no upping of the ante from a threat perspective.
 
One of the games I've enjoyed most this generation. Incredible graphics, great story, and production values. I also loved the final story DLC.
 
I think they have made better games. I vastly prefer Control and Quantum Break is better. I made a mistake of trying to find all the collectibles and stuff thus totally ruining the pace of the game. I also hated those boss encounters, like the one of the earlier ones in the forest. It also really wants to be weird and is not all that weird or at least not in a natural way. But did I enjoy my time with it? I think so. Saga was a great character, Alan less so.
 
Last edited:
I only played this game recently and I must say I absolutely hated it. The mind space sections are beyond tedious and they just go on and on. I quite liked the first game but this game is absolute garbage. It boggles my mind how it got great reviews. I quit playing it, then decided I had to finish it and it just seemed to never stop being a torture to play and it just went on and on. I wish I had the option to buy a physical copy of the game just so I could smash it to pieces.
 
Good graphics but with awful final image (XSX).

Goes on way too long.

Way too many cheap jump scares (nearly killed me every time and I wished I could have turned them off).

Coffee World was great, and I loved the musical level too (just so out there).

I finished it, but wasn't sure if I enjoyed it or not - strange game.
 
I only played this game recently and I must say I absolutely hated it. The mind space sections are beyond tedious and they just go on and on. I quite liked the first game but this game is absolute garbage. It boggles my mind how it got great reviews. I quit playing it, then decided I had to finish it and it just seemed to never stop being a torture to play and it just went on and on. I wish I had the option to buy a physical copy of the game just so I could smash it to pieces.
Game has sure many flaws but totally garbage lol 😆 the thing you despise it, doesn't means automatically is just garbage I beg to say. Personally I found it one of the best survival horror experience of this generation, sure it's not perfect with some opinable gameplay choices (the mind palace for example it's pure gimmick and annoying to replay) but imo is a quite superior experience compared his prequel and surely is not a game for everyone, I give you that, (it's filled of weirdos stuff, but if you love David Lynch it's a must) but call it garbage it's quite unfair.
 
Last edited:
Beat it recently and wasn't really a fan.
The story is nothing special, I didn't like the dual protagonist approach, the mind palace mechanic seems kinda cool at first but ends up feeling gimmicky and pointless, and the visuals (on Ps5) look nice until you start moving and there's insane shimmering all around.

People complained about Saga but I found her sections to be by far the best part of the game, with better levels and a better mix of storytelling, exploration and combat. If the entire game had been more like Coffee World and its surrounding areas (with occasional returns back to the town) it would have been way better IMO.
 
Art is awesome and music as well, the whole presentation is very well done, my issue was the story somehow even liking the characters i could not get into the story and ended up not so much caring in the end.
 
I didn't like it and its not like I didn't give it a fair shake. I played some 10 ish hours. I think I stopped at Return 3. I hated the overall gameplay and backtracking. The constant profiling felt useless and like a waste of time. It only worked in one way and was about pushing the right photos. Despite that, Saga and the town were the best part so far.

And this Sam Lake, is he a narcissist or what?

AW1 is far, far better. Simpler gameplay and mediocre action sure, but perfect pacing that felt like binging a thriller series.
 
Last edited:
I recently played this a few months ago, and I was massively disappointed. It looked and sounded amazing, but other than that I felt very underwhelmed. Playing as Saga felt like a generic survival horror with very little actual scary things. I played Silent Hill 2 right before playing Alan Wake 2, and the former had a lot more genuine terror and horror. The parts with Alan had a better atmosphere and more unique vibe, but actually playing with him was terrible. His parts felt like a never ending stealth game where it has no stealth mechanics to accommodate that play style. I'd rather have the generic survival horror with Saga than the good-idea-bad-execution with Alan.

All in all I very much prefer the first Alan Wake to the second.
 
Did any of you honestly enjoy the mind room stuff? I thought it was awful. Just beyond tedious . And it went on forever. If you only had to do it once or twice, fine. It was just relentless. Have I mentioned how awful the map is? This game is a 1 and done. Never touching it again.
 
Good graphics but with awful final image (XSX).

Goes on way too long.

Way too many cheap jump scares (nearly killed me every time and I wished I could have turned them off).

Coffee World was great, and I loved the musical level too (just so out there).

I finished it, but wasn't sure if I enjoyed it or not - strange game.
Watery is the best area in the game and it's not even close. If not for the opening section and watery the game would have sucked but watery saved it for me. Coffee World and the surrounding woods was a great time. The ending was so rushed and the mind place sections towards the end...yeah, but the game hooked me early on exploring Watery. It never quite reached that level anywhere else. You could tell they REALLY worked to make the first few hours great but it did fall off pretty hard. The pacing was off there was filler, the game could have cut a few hours and spent that time working on the ending.
 
Last edited:
Did any of you honestly enjoy the mind room stuff? I thought it was awful. Just beyond tedious . And it went on forever. If you only had to do it once or twice, fine. It was just relentless. Have I mentioned how awful the map is? This game is a 1 and done. Never touching it again.
It wasn't too bad, however, it was in no way fun. The WORST part for me was changing scenes as Alan. What a stupid mechanic that REALLY wore out it's welcome by the end. I immediately uninstalled it once the credits were done...
 
I recently started playing this again and think I've got into some weird glitch that will stop me from going any further. One of my goals says to get the float mentioned on the page. But I completed this puzzle already. I visited the display again of this puzzle and I did do everything here, is this a big bug in the game or am I missing something…..
 
Did any of you honestly enjoy the mind room stuff? I thought it was awful. Just beyond tedious . And it went on forever. If you only had to do it once or twice, fine. It was just relentless. Have I mentioned how awful the map is? This game is a 1 and done. Never touching it again.
Enjoy it? A little bit to get more narrative it was kind of interesting but it wasn't like I was excited for it. I loved the game overall though and got the plat.
 
I just played alan wake remastered, American nightmare and Alan wake 2 in my 2 week Xmas break. The old games were pretty fun but dated. At first I loved Alan wake 2 but I feel it's just too confusing. The story is pretty straight forward really and they think they are far cleverer writers than they are. It all comes off as self indulgent and the live action stuff is just cringe. Sam Lake can't act for shit. plus the combat ain't great. The game does look great though ill give it that. I think will enjoy it more on a second playthrough, Knowing the main story arcs and picking up on little details I missed first time through.
 
Top Bottom