Support NeoGAF

[LazyParrot]

*Bonus:

Ion Storm Dallas Games

• Best: Anachronox
• Worst: Daikatana

Anachronox is amazing and Daikatana is objectively worse, but it's not the worst Ion Storm Dallas game. That honor will forever belong to Dominion: Storm over Gift 3.

 

[Gamer_By_Proxy]

Best: Zelda 1

Worst: Zelda 2

 

[L*][*N*K]

Best: Ocarina of Time
Worst: Skyward Sword.

 

[RaidenJTr7]

Killzone 2
Killzone 3

Killzone shadow fall

Crysis
Crysis 2

Crysis 3

 

[Plague Doctor]

Fallout 2 - Best
Fallout 76 - Worst

 

[Codes 208]

Oooh i got a couple.

Halo
Best: Halo 3
Worst: Halo 5

TLoZ:
Best: Majora's Mask (specifically N64 version)
Worst: Phantom Hourglass

Mario:
Best: Super Mario 64
Worst: NSMB (any of them. Played one, youve played them all)

Souls-Like:
Best: Bloodborne
Worst: Dark Souls 2: SotFS

Pokemon:
Best: R/S/E
Worst: SP/BD

 

[VGA-Games]

Metroid:
Metroid Prime Remastered (BEST)
Metroid Other M (WORST)

The Legend of Zelda:
Zelda: A Link to the Past (BEST)
Zelda: Skyward Sword HD (WORST)

Super Mario:
Super Mario Odyssey (BEST)
Super Mario Bros. 2 (WORST)

Resident Evil:
Resident Evil HD Remake (BEST)
Resident Evil 6 (WORST)

Castlevania:
Super Castlevania IV (BEST)
Castlevania II: Simon's Quest (WORST)

 

[TintoConCasera]

Return to Castle Wolfenstein - Best

Wolfenstein new colossus - Worst

Dude, Young Blood. Or is your brain protecting you from that cursed memory.

 

[L'Empereur Hadrien]

Castlevania*
Best: Castlevania 3
Worst: Portrait of Ruin (hate that game despite loving every other Castletroid)

*not counting the Western-developed titles

 

[Plague Doctor]

Dude, Young Blood. Or is your brain protecting you from that cursed memory.

Barely played it. I did play New Collusus from start to finish.

Gunplay was fine. Everything else was not.

 

[Baemono]

Bayonetta 3
Bayonetta 1

Super Mario Odyssey
Super Mario Sunshine

Uncharted 4
Uncharted 1

God of War 2018
God of War 1

GTA V
GTA IV

Super Mario Bros 3
New Super Mario Bros Wii

 

[TheKratos]

Borderlands 2 > Borderlands 3
MGS2 > MGS5
Saints Row 2 > Saints Row remake
BO3 > BO7
Army of two 2 > Army of two 3

 

[Hohenheim]

Mortal combat 4 ! Love it!

 

[Neff]

Resident Evil/Operation Raccoon City
Super Mario 64/Super Mario DS
A Link to the Past/Wand of Gamelon
Super Metroid/Federation Force
Final Fantasy VII/Final Fantasy XVI
Sonic The Hedgehog/Sonic '06
MGSV/Portable Ops
Devil May Cry/Devil May Cry 2
Street Fighter III Third Strike/Street Fighter II The Interactive Movie
Dark Souls II/Demon's Souls
Tekken Tag Tournament 2/Tekken Advance
Virtua Fighter 5 Final Showdown/Virtua Quest
Kingdom Hearts/Kingdom Hearts II
Symphony of the Night/Haunted Castle
Bayonetta/Bayonetta 3

 

[Halo2redvsblue]

Best: Half Life 2
Worst: Half Life 3

Best: Portal 2
Worst: Portal 3

Best: Left 4 Dead 2
Worst: Left 4 Dead 3

Valve just sucks at making a third game.

 

[JohnnyFootball]

Best: Mass Effect 3
Worst: Mass Effect 3

Yes it's true

 

[Lukin1978]

Best Uncharted 2
Worst Uncharted 1
Best Gears of War 2
Worst Gears of War 4

 

[Ziglax]

Baldur's Gate 2

Baldur's Gate 3

 

[Korso]

Shenmue 1 - best

Shenmue 3 - worst

 

[cartman414]

Best: Zelda 1

Worst: Zelda 2

Zelda 1 was far less replayable.

 

[Team Andromeda]

Best - Ninja Gaiden 2
Worst -Ninja Gaiden 3

Best - Mario Galaxy
Worst - Mario Odyssey

Best - Halo Infinite
Worst - Halo 2

Best - Forza Horzion 3
Worst - Forza Horzion 5

Best - GOW
Worst- GOD: Ragnarok

Best - Sonic Adv
Worst - Sonic 06

Best - Castlevania IV
Worst - Castlevania Bloodlines

 

[Major Insano]

Mario Galaxy> Mario bros 2

Halo 3> Halo 2

Baldurs Gate 2> Baldurs Gate

Fallout 4> 76

SF3 3rd Strike> SF

Zelda OOT> Zelda 2

Farcry 2> Farcry

Witcher 3> Gwent

COD4 MW> BLOPs 4

 

[Uncle Moe]

I will never overlook an opportunity to praise the underrated Super Mario 3D World while taking Super Mario Odyssey down a peg.

 

[cartman414]

Mario Galaxy> Mario bros 2

Halo 3> Halo 2

Baldurs Gate 2> Baldurs Gate

Fallout 4> 76

SF3 3rd Strike> SF

Zelda OOT> Zelda 2

Farcry 2> Farcry

Witcher 3> Gwent

COD4 MW> BLOPs 4

Other way around for me comparatively. Zelda 2 has far better combat.

Best - Ninja Gaiden 2
Worst -Ninja Gaiden 3

Best - Mario Galaxy
Worst - Mario Odyssey

Best - Halo Infinite
Worst - Halo 2

Best - Forza Horzion 3
Worst - Forza Horzion 5

Best - GOW
Worst- GOD: Ragnarok

Best - Sonic Adv
Worst - Sonic 06

Best - Castlevania IV
Worst - Castlevania Bloodlines

Boo. Neither were bad, but I prefer Bloodlines to the slower, frictionless SCV4.

 

[Aressa]

Best: Debatable
Worst: DMC2

 

[uncreativename]

it's kinda tough cus the worst game for the big franchises is usually some mobile/portable garbage that no one, including me, played

worst: Kingdom Hearts Re-Coded
best: Kingdom Hearts Birth By Sleep Final Mix

worst: Fallout 76
best: Fallout 1

worst that i've played: MGS Portable Ops
best: MGS Peace Walker ps3 port

 

[RAIDEN1]

it's kinda tough cus the worst game for the big franchises is usually some mobile/portable garbage that no one, including me, played

worst: Kingdom Hearts Re-Coded
best: Kingdom Hearts Birth By Sleep Final Mix

worst: Fallout 76
best: Fallout 1

worst that i've played: MGS Portable Ops
best: MGS Peace Walker ps3 port

What was so bad about Portable Ops? May not have had the freedom of Part 5, but was a hell of a lot more immersive and more atmospheric

 

[Mondai]

Worst Ones:

Dead Space 3
MGSV
Starcraft 2
DMC2
FF2
Breath of Fire 6 (if it counts)
Ragnarok Online 2

 

[uncreativename]

What was so bad about Portable Ops? May not have had the freedom of Part 5, but was a hell of a lot more immersive and more atmospheric

it's still a pretty dece game, but i like all the others more. mostly i don't like the controls and it was limited by being a portable game, as opposed to Peace Walker, which is incredibly ambitious. Peace Walker on ps3 is basically MGS5 but finished, and with worse (but totally fine) controls.

oh, got some more:

worst: Yakuza Dead Souls
best: Yakuza 2

worst that i've played: Total War: Warhammer III
best: Medieval II Total War

worst that i've played: Assassins Creed III
best: Assassins Creed II

worst that i've played: call of duty 3
best: call of duty 4: modern warfare

 

[captainpat]

best: Doom Eternal
worst: Doom dark ages

best: uncharted 2
worst: uncharted 3

best: infamous 2
worst: infamous Second son

best: Mass effect 2
worst: Mass effect 1

best: Fire emblem three houses
worst: Fire emblem fates

best: xenoblade 2
worst: xenoblade 3

best: bayonetta 2
worst: bayonetta 1

best: persona 5
worst: persona 4

All of the installments I've put as the worst are actually all very good. It's just the bar is high in these franchises.

 

[Puscifer]

=

God Of War Ragnarok

God Of War III

 

[bender]

Sonic Series:

Worst Game: all of them
Best Game: none of them

 

[Pimpbaa]

Best - Halo Infinite
Worst - Halo 2

I mean I agree with most of your list (although I would argue Mario Sunshine is worse then Odyssey), but Halo Infinite? Anything by 343 is worse than halo games by bungie. Although I think my best and worst will ruffle more feathers.

Best: MGSV
Worst: MGS2

 

[amigastar]

Metroid Prime

Metroid Prime 4 Beyond

Who would have thought that, right? It's almost funny in a painful way.