Support NeoGAF

[Cyberpunkd]

Ok, let's hear from everyone that played RPGs for many years, curious to see if there is something I missed in the last 30 years (ranked at random):

Main Quest:
1. Morrowind - "come take this thing from the hand of god". Perfection, don't remember any side quest. Now that I think about it probably my most favorite game of all time.
2. Witcher 3
3. Planescape Torment - perfection, don't remember a single side quest
4. FF VII
5. Witcher 1
6. Vampire: Bloodlines 1
7. Summoner - don't remember a single thing but you become a god at the end, GG WP

Side Quests:
1. Witcher 3
2. Rogue Trader
3. TES: Oblivion - although mechanically it's very meh

I would prefer cRPGs over jRPGs.

 

[TintoConCasera]

Play Kingdom Come dude.

 

[Cyberpunkd]

Play Kingdom Come dude.

I have it on GOG bruh, need to finish Oblivion and Hogwart's Legacy, and then we are jumping right in. Can I hit on the court ladies?

 

[NotMyProblemAnymoreCunt]

The Witcher Trilogy

 

[ShaiKhulud1989]

Trails as a whole is surprisingly decent with combining main and side content so far (CS III).

Really love that some quests are hidden too.

 

[TintoConCasera]

I have it on GOG bruh, need to finish Oblivion and Hogwart's Legacy, and then we are jumping right in.

Fucking nice. I'm not too savvy when it comes to RPGs as I still have to play some classics like Planescape, VTMB or Gothic, but imho KCD has a real good main quest (story is real good and very well written, with a great set of characters) and at least the sequel has some of the best sidequests I've seen in a game.

Can I hit on the court ladies?

From lowly prostitutes to court ladies, the answer is yes.

 

[Arsic]

For a wrpg? The best is CP2077 if you include the phantom liberty expansion.

Best side quests though I would go with Baldurs Gate 3.

 

[Cyberpunkd]

For a wrpg? The best is CP2077 if you include the phantom liberty expansion.

Best side quests though I would go with Baldurs Gate 3.

Yeah, CP2077 has a really good main quest. Don't remember much of side quests except that one on the human harvest farm.

 

[kremiso]

liked a lot the Last Remnant side quests back then, but you need to like the particular battle system, as the game is 99% that

i would like to try Witcher 1 in future, never had the pleasure until now

EDIT just remembered another one, Kingdoms of Amalur

 

[TintoConCasera]

Yeah, CP2077 has a really good main quest. Don't remember much of side quests except that one on the human harvest farm.

The sidequest about the mayor and his wife having their minds controlled or some shit like that was super cool imo.

In fact I wish more sidequests were into that kind of cyberpunk shit. Some others felt like they could fit in any GTA game.

 

[Cyberpunkd]

i would like to try Witcher 1 in future, never had the pleasure until now

The end game revelation is really good.

 

[Arsic]

Yeah, CP2077 has a really good main quest. Don't remember much of side quests except that one on the human harvest farm.

Help save a guy who's dick implant is about to blow up.

 

[Denton]

Aside from those you mentioned:

KCD
KCD2
Fallout 1/2/New Vegas
Enderal: Forgotten Stories
Archolos: Chronicles of Myrtana
Disco Elysium
Mass Effect Trilogy
KOTOR 1&2
Baldur's Gate 2&3
Wasteland 3
Alpha Protocol

All of these have great handcrafted main and side content without checklist and shitty Ubisoft school of design.

 

[KyoZz]

Fable II is still really good for both main and side quest.

 

[Nocty]

Fable II is still really good for both main and side quest.

agree with this, even if it's a bit generic fantasy vibe.

 

[TintoConCasera]

Fable II is still really good for both main and side quest.

agree with this, even if it's a bit generic fantasy vibe.

I need to check out that game. Is it better than the first game? It was fun but I wasn't a big fan of it.

 

[Fabieter]

Bg3 and kdc 2 are the wrpg games ever.

 

[Cyberpunkd]

Aside from those you mentioned:

KCD
KCD2
Fallout 1/2/New Vegas
Enderal: Forgotten Stories
Archolos: Chronicles of Myrtana
Disco Elysium
Mass Effect Trilogy
KOTOR 1&2
Baldur's Gate 2&3
Wasteland 3
Alpha Protocol

All of these have great handcrafted main and side content without checklist and shitty Ubisoft school of design.

Played everything except KCD and Archolos. Disco Elysium is thrash.

Fable II is still really good for both main and side quest.

Played it, it was good.

 

[Arsic]

I need to check out that game. Is it better than the first game? It was fun but I wasn't a big fan of it.

Fable games are a joke.

 

[TintoConCasera]

Fable games are a joke.

I've only played the first one and while it had a lot of charm, it sure felt quite average to me.

 

[MidGenRefresh]

An hour into the thread and the motherfuckers already named every banger. Nothing left to add.

 

[TintoConCasera]

An hour into the thread and the motherfuckers already named every banger. Nothing left to add.

Nobody had mentioned Deus Ex yet!

Well, up until now I guess.

 

[PurePlatinum]

Cyberpunk I feel is probably the strongest modern WRPG overall. Witcher 3 is right there with it.

 

[Fess]

Main:
Cyberpunk 2077 (Nothing can touch this)
Final Fantasy 7 (Still great)
Mass Effect trilogy (It's still fantastic)

Side:
Skyrim (How do you actually finish this game?)
Starfield (Especially faction quests are superb)
The Witcher 3 (Top 3 fleshed out side stuff)

 

[The Cockatrice]

Too many to name, so I'll just go with Cyberpunk 2077, both side quests and main quest.

 

[March Climber]

Mass Effect 2 is my number one for both. Not a single side quest felt like a waste of time and they were all treated like their own main stories. It didn't make you farm or grind unnecessarily either. It is the peak example of how to write and pace a story in an RPG.

 

[Denton]

Disco Elysium is thrash.

I thought so too, but then I played it. Its melancholic super distinct atmosphere is unlike anything else, its writing is generally great (at times a bit pretentious, but it's not too bad) and its quests are very, very good.

 

[geary]

MQ
--------------
Nier Automata
Metaphor
Divinity Original Sin 2
FF 14 - All expansions, except AAR (crazy good).

 

[KyoZz]

I need to check out that game. Is it better than the first game? It was fun but I wasn't a big fan of it.

Far better imo. As Nocty said, the world is a bit generic but the writing is top notch and it's a really fun game.

 

[marcincz]

Nobody mentioned crpg Pillars of Eternity?
Very decent main quest and side quests.

 

[LectureMaster]

Greedfall's main quests and companion quests were pretty engaging for me. It's an AA eurojank game, but it did reminisce some old school bioware style.

Also, we exhausted the WRPGs, just throw a few modern JRPGs.

YS 8
Judgment
Xenoblade 1

 

[RoboFu]

these days?

1. Falcom
2. Falcom
3. Falcom
4. Falcom
5. Falcom

 

[Cyberpunkd]

MQ
--------------
Nier Automata
Metaphor
Divinity Original Sin 2
FF 14 - All expansions, except AAR (crazy good).

Metaphor is really intriguing, I was thinking Persona 5 but I still have 4 Golden to finish. Is the Metaphor story really good?

 

[Arsic]

Metaphor is really intriguing, I was thinking Persona 5 but I still have 4 Golden to finish. Is the Metaphor story really good?

Fuck no. It's insanely predictable and the one part early on they introduced that could've made for a mind bender they did nothing with lol.

 

[I collect VHS tapes]

Witcher 3, by a lot

 

[TintoConCasera]

Is the Metaphor story really good?

Great villain and the writting is more mature than in the Persona games. I liked that aspect of the game for sure.

It's insanely predictable

My dude no way you predicted the stuff about the main character's origin. Shit was crazy.

 

[amigastar]

The Witcher Trilogy

Interesting you said Trilogy, usually people just mention Witcher 2 and 3.

 

[Arsic]

Great villain and the writting is more mature than in the Persona games. I liked that aspect of the game for sure.

My dude no way you predicted the stuff about the main character's origin. Shit was crazy.

I shit you not I did. It's why the game when we were all discussing it on release was a 6/10 for me.

I'd still recommend it for Atlus fans but it's the weakest offering from them I've ever had.

 

[adamsapple]

Mass Effect 2 is my number one for both. Not a single side quest felt like a waste of time and they were all treated like their own main stories. It didn't make you farm or grind unnecessarily either. It is the peak example of how to write and pace a story in an RPG.

The companion quests in ME2 are still better than the main quests in 99% modern games.

Such a good fucking structure that game had.

 

[NotMyProblemAnymoreCunt]

Interesting you said Trilogy, usually people just mention Witcher 2 and 3.

The first game is fantastic in regards to the sidequests too

 

[MagiusNecros]

I would prefer cRPGs

Neverwinter Nights. Main campaign, expansions, Player created content. 100s of hours on that alone.

 

[uncreativename]

In no order.

Main Quest
Fallout (The Fallout franchise at its best and most focused.)
Baldur's Gate II w/ Throne of Bhaal expansion (It might not be as cinematic and deeply plotted as JRPGs and some modern CRPGs, but by the end you're a demigod going around killing other demigods on a quest to become an actual god and you have your own private realm and butler. Also this was back when not every game had to be perfectly balanced, so magic is crazy overpowered by the end in a super fun way that makes it feel even more epic.)
Kingdom Come Deliverance (Over the course of the main quest, the sense of progression in this might be even more satisfying than in BG2. You start as the son of a blacksmith, who doesn't really know how to do much of anything, and you become basically an unlanded knight taking part in battles and sieges alongside lords. This is also maybe the only medieval European RPG that doesn't have any kind of fantasy elements? So you won't find anything quite like this anywhere else.)
Chrono Trigger (Of all the JRPGs I've played, this one might have the most epic main quest.)
Dragon Quest IV (The way that this game has you play a bunch of different characters introductions one after another is really effective, because they're all so different.)
Shin Megami Tensei 4 (Very creative game with a really interesting story and great atmosphere.)

Side Quests
Final Fantasy XIII-2 (The timeline system in this game makes it really fun to try to unlock hidden side-paths which can then in turn unlock other hidden paths that you didn't know about. Amazing, underrated game.)
The Witcher 3 (Some of the best side quests I've ever played.)
Darklands (This game is set in the late medieval Holy Roman Empire as superstitious people of the time might have believed it to be. It's basically 100% mostly repeatable side quests, and even though it feels like an unfinished game, the fact that it can keep your attention for so long despite the repetition speaks to how good these side quests are.)

 

[uncreativename]

I forgot The World Ends With You. Definitely belongs on the list for Main Quest .

Also MagiusNecros that's interesting. I hated the main quest of Neverwinter Nights. The player created content was amazing, but the story they included with the game felt super basic, in my opinion. Didn't help that that game has always run terribly.

 

[Hawk The Slayer]

Fallout and Elder Scroll games.

Vampire the Masquerade Bloodlines is great too. The gargoyle and wereshark are top tier side quests.

 

[Polaris]

Daggerfall.
Every other answer is wrong.

 

[Arsic]

TintoConCasera i should mention I still want a sequel to metaphor and hope we do get one.

It's the bones to something great if fleshed out.

 

[uncreativename]

I was gonna say Dark Souls or ps3 Demon's Souls, but those don't really have the quest structure of traditional rpgs . Kind of a different thing.

 

[TintoConCasera]

TintoConCasera i should mention I still want a sequel to metaphor and hope we do get one.

It's the bones to something great if fleshed out.

yeah 100%. To me the game was cool but some aspects could have been way better, like the visual presentation or the dungeon design.

 

[MagiusNecros]

Also MagiusNecros that's interesting. I hated the main quest of Neverwinter Nights. The player created content was amazing, but the story they included with the game felt super basic, in my opinion. Didn't help that that game has always run terribly.

Expansions are objectively better then main campaign. Game's longevity definitely is the player created stuff. Pretty hard to recommend many cRPGs.

TintoConCasera Metaphor's weakness unironically to me is the Visual Novel design it feels it needs to tack on to. If it focused on the daytime activities and avoided the Majora's Mask system(which if you know what you are doing is negligible) I feel it would be a much better game. I like Metaphor but it's kinda similar to FE Three Houses where parts of the game drag it down a lot. It's clearly a mashup of all of Atlus's games primarily SMT/Persona/Etrian Odyssey but to me their best game is still SMT4.

 

[Danjin44]

I really liked the side quests Trails 1st Chapter and I liked the fact it makes sense in context of the world.

I also really like side quests in Nier Replicant and Nier Automata.

Also some of the Blade quests in Xenoblade 2 its really well done but unfortunately its tide to RNG if you get the Blade soon enough in order invest on their quests.