Winter 2012 Anime Thread of Roundcats Up in This

Status
Not open for further replies.
You gave both seasons of Code Geass a perfect 10...
ibd7Iv5R6GdazR.gif


Anime rankings/ratings on My Anime List and Anime News Network have taught me that Sturgeon's law applies to anime fans too. Stop this world, I want off.

YOU DONT HAVE A HEART
 
Putting Chihayafuru on there after only 5 out of 25 episodes is a little premature, but otherwise I can't criticize your list since I haven't seen much of what's on there.

It made a huge impression on me. I'm not sure why but I really love it. Its exactly the kind of anime I like the most. I might squeeze Usagi Drop on that list eventually.
 
It made a huge impression on me. I'm not sure why but I really love it. Its exactly the kind of anime I like the most. I might squeeze Usagi Drop on that list eventually.

Liking cute but not having Usagi Drop on there is akin to liking sweets but hating sugar!

Also, mentioning Endless Eight on there warms firehawk's cold black heart, be careful.
 
I haven't even heard of Sexy Commando.

It's an old Akitaro Daichi comedy, but it's pretty much got the limiter taken off in terms of how stupid they allowed it to be. It's pretty spectacular, in it's own way.

Actually, is Akitaro Daichi still working? Seems like I've not seen anything from him in forever...
 
It's an old Akitaro Daichi comedy, but it's pretty much got the limiter taken off in terms of how stupid they allowed it to be. It's pretty spectacular, in it's own way.

Actually, is Akitaro Daichi still working? Seems like I've not seen anything from him in forever...

Akitaro Daichi is directing Poyopoyo Kansatsu Nikki this season.

Now I remember why I will never have a MAL account.

Nothing better than assigning anime arbitrary numbers and arguing over them!
 
Liking cute but not having Usagi Drop on there is akin to liking sweets but hating sugar!

Also, mentioning Endless Eight on there warms firehawk's cold black heart, be careful.

I like Usagi Drop a lot. the problem is I like all the shows on that list a lot.
I have seen hundreds of these fucking things. At this point it is impossible to classify shows.
I guess maybe I could knock off Nuku Nuku or Fruits Basket and stick it there, but I love those too.
HNNNNNNNG.

As for MAL, just wait until I start grading stuff.
Youre gonna love that.
 
I am pretty sure my top five is

#1 CCS
#2 Code Geass
#3 Haruhi
#4 Evangelion
#5 Yu Yu Hakusho or Penguindrum

Code Geass: most entertaining thing ever.
 
Now I remember why I will never have a MAL account.
Most of my MAL scores are probably bullshit, but I still find it useful to keep track of what I've watched/am currently watching/plan to watch/etc.

Haibane Renmei 6-9

Well that was a pretty abrupt change of pace. Didn't realize it was about to get so depressing/psychological in here.
 
I just cannot accurately do a top any of all time when I haven't watched a lot of anime pre-eighties. I also skipped on a lot of stuff during my teenage years; I didn't get back into anime until relatively recently.

edit:
I think Google Ads is trying to tell me something.
 
You're only supposed to like stuff that I like. :<



You asked for criticism. I criticized.

And I retorted. GRRRRRROAAAARRRR.


I just cannot accurately do a top any of all time when I haven't watched a lot of anime pre-eighties. I also skipped on a lot of stuff during my teenage years; I didn't get back into anime until relatively recently.

edit:

I think Google Ads is telling me something.

I just bought that. Along with God Only Knows and Akikan.
 
Okay, trying to give it some more thought:

1. Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann
2. One Piece
3. Dragonball Z
4. Sexy Commando
5. Dead Leaves
6. FLCL
7. Yu Yu Hakusho
8. Elfen Lied
9. S-Cry-ed
10. Death Note
11. Law of Ueki
12. Rune Soldier Louie
13. Samurai Champloo
14. Saikano
15. Code Geass
16. Excel Saga
17. Needless
18. Higurashi no Naku Koro Ni
19. Bokusatsu Tenshi Dokuro Chan
20. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood
21. Bobobobo
22. Toriko
23. Great Teacher Onizuka
24. 2x2 Shinobuden
25. Tiger & Bunny
26. Cromartie High School
27. Naruto (not Shippuden)
28. Panty & Stocking with Garterbelt
29. E's Otherwise
30. Garzey's Wing

Still only a tentative list, but that's about right.
 
Okay, trying to give it some more thought:

1. Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann
2. One Piece
3. Dragonball Z
4. Sexy Commando
5. Dead Leaves
6. FLCL
7. Yu Yu Hakusho
8. Elfen Lied
9. S-Cry-ed
10. Death Note
11. Law of Ueki
12. Rune Soldier Louie
13. Samurai Champloo
14. Saikano
15. Code Geass
16. Excel Saga
17. Needless
18. Higurashi no Naku Koro Ni
19. Bokusatsu Tenshi Dokuro Chan
20. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood
21. Bobobobo
22. Toriko
23. Great Teacher Onizuka
24. 2x2 Shinobuden
25. Tiger & Bunny
26. Cromartie High School
27. Naruto (not Shippuden)
28. Panty & Stocking with Garterbelt
29. E's Otherwise
30. Garzey's Wing

Still only a tentative list, but that's about right.

Oh nice. you listed Saikano. I would have, but its so fucking depressing.
You also listed Dokuro Chan. are you familiar with Magical Witch Punie chan? Same insane director. HIlarious.
 
It's an old Akitaro Daichi comedy, but it's pretty much got the limiter taken off in terms of how stupid they allowed it to be. It's pretty spectacular, in it's own way.

Actually, is Akitaro Daichi still working? Seems like I've not seen anything from him in forever...

It's a frame for frame adaptation, so I would attribute the craziness to the manga author more than the director. Just read Pyu to Fuku! Jaguar.

Oh nice. you listed Saikano. I would have, but its so fucking depressing.
You also listed Dokuro Chan. are you familiar with Magical Witch Punie chan? Same insane director. HIlarious.

Yes, I love Punie too, but not as much.
 
1. Yami to Boushi to Hon no Tabibito
2. Garzey's Wing
3. Black Lion
4. Mad Bull 34
5. Earth Girl Arjuna
6. Blood-C
7. Code Geass
8. Death Note
9. Sukeban Deka
10. Super Atragon
 
  1. Seifuku Shoujo
  2. Sora no Iro Mizu no Iro
  3. Kanojo ga Mimai (dat ntr)
  4. Taimanin Asagi
  5. TSF Monogatari
  6. Dark Love
  7. Hatsu Inu: The Animation
  8. Another Lady Innocent
  9. Bible Black
  10. Urotsukidoji
  11. Kiss X Sis
    they are basically hentai ffs
No Street Fighter II V?
Street Fighter II V was the bee's knees.
 
  1. Seifuku Shoujo
  2. Sora no Iro Mizu no Iro
  3. Kanojo ga Mimai (dat ntr)
  4. Taimanin Asagi
  5. TSF Monogatari
  6. Dark Love
  7. Hatsu Inu: The Animation
  8. Another Lady Innocent
  9. Bible Black
  10. Urotsukidoji
  11. Kiss X Sis
    they are basically hentai ffs

I've seen everything on that list too. Should I be proud or ashamed?

Also, you need more 15 Bishoujo Hyouryuuki, KxKxK, Fukubiki! Triangle (because Futaba is great), Fault!, and Resort Boin.
 
Top 10

1. Akira
2. Ghost in the Shell
3. Heidi
4. Ganbare Kickers
5. Georgie
6. Little Princess
7. Mawaru-Penguindrum
8. Vision of Escaclowne
9. Anne of Green Gables
10. Cat's Eye

classy list is classy
 
There is one hentai I will admit to watching and that was Magical Twilight. It was low budget and almost not a hentai at all. but it was cute.


Top 10

1. Akira
2. Ghost in the Shell
3. Heidi
4. Ganbare Kickers
5. Georgie
6. Little Princess
7. Mawaru Penguin Drum
8. Vision of Escaclowne
9. Anne of Green Gables
10. Cat's Eye

classy list is classy

Akira and Penguin Drum are classy?
 
I've seen everything on that list too. Should I be proud or ashamed?

Also, you need more 15 Bishoujo Hyouryuuki, KxKxK, Fukubiki! Triangle (because Futaba is great), and Resort Boin.
Resort Boin is lame. All the girls have are big boobs, otherwise they are all carbon copies of each other. Except for the token incest sister, but she's just boring.
 
Hey, as long as you are all making lists (jokingly or otherwise), I guess now would be a good time for a reminder that there's just under 48 hours left if you want to choose/modify your votes for the anime of the year topic. If there's any shows you have under consideration and need to finish them up, find a few hours over the weekend so they can get the right spot on your list.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom