• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Manga Discussion/News Thread |OT4| New Ch/Vols! - SEE FIRST POST FOR RULES!

Status
Not open for further replies.
I agree with most of what you said. I just dislike hyperbolic statements. I did not have problem with people criticizing the almost no one noticing part. I did too. Saying the greatest wizards alive is a dumb thing to say since the tournament is only for Fiore.

Fairy tail is not even in my top 10 manga. It´s way too corny for that, but i still like it for what it is.

Okay that's fine then, glad we agree!
 
Moving goal post all the time did not win you anything. Next time you should make less hyperbolic statement. It makes look less stupid. Besides Yajima is a commentator not a judge.

You know the moving goal post analogy only works if the goal posts I'm moving have any bearing on my main point at all. Which they don't.

I seriously can't believe you are so ridiculous that you made such a big deal about a statement that was completely beside the point, and are now trying to make yourself out to be the winner of the argument because I used a bit of hyperbole to illustrate my point.

You know why it's difficult to argue with people like you? Because you actually don't have a position to argue from, you started the argument simply for the need to have an argument with me, you didn't actually oppose my opinion since you apparently agree with Neoriceisgood so the whole argument was against me calling the participating Wizards the greatest wizards alive? Even though you tried in your previous posts to justify the same thing you are now agreeing was bad?

The one moving goalposts is you, not me.

Your initial problem with my post was that the magic council are not the most powerful wizards alive, when I didn't even mention the Magic Council.

Do you honestly deny that this magic tournament has some of the strongest wizards, both participating and organising it? Everything in the manga has suggested that incredibly powerful wizards are participating, no where does it indicate this is a collection of weaklings.

Maybe if Yajima is a commentator he should have done his job and commented on the interference and cheating. Or do you have a stupid tangential argument against that too?
 
Bakuman 168:

Except for the fact that they've constantly said that Miho is one of the best VAs out there

Right, and I'd prefer her to get the role for that reason vs people wanting to support her dream. At the end of the day we (the readers) know she's going to get the role, but let the dream just be the "prize at the end".
 
What manga is this?

RRrsU.jpg
 
Hey, what do you guys think is the best platform to read scanlations on? I generally hate them 'coz my eyes kill me after a while, but I'm tired of waiting for Yokohama Kaidashi Kikō to get published over here... so yeah... tablet is the way to go, right?
 
Hey, what do you guys think is the best platform to read scanlations on? I generally hate them 'coz my eyes kill me after a while, but I'm tired of waiting for Yokohama Kaidashi Kikō to get published over here... so yeah... tablet is the way to go, right?
HDTV4lyfe
 
TWGOK 178-2: The Good, the Bad, and the Shiori

(appropriate listening music for this chapter)
Best bonus chapter meant for merchandise advertising ever.

Liar Game 149

Akiyama is the best.

Bakuman 168

On one hand, I'm glad they're still making fun of all the crazy otaku. On the other, can we please get back to the actual manga writing as the focus instead of this stupid romance plot?

Kimi no Iru Machi 171

7fsln.jpg


I've got nothing. Kouji Seo is out of his damn mind.
 
Hey, what do you guys think is the best platform to read scanlations on? I generally hate them 'coz my eyes kill me after a while, but I'm tired of waiting for Yokohama Kaidashi Kikō to get published over here... so yeah... tablet is the way to go, right?
Ipad
it was pretty crazy when i heard that you did that lol
You have to get used to the idea that Stat Flow and I are evolved beings.
Google image image search is useful for situations like this.
Dresden image search worked perfectly fine. Stop hating.
 
Magi in Review

Overall a solid manga, but has a few problems.

Pros:
  • Fantastic setting/world
  • Lots of solid humor
  • Great characters and character development
  • Great storyline
  • Awesome action scenes
Cons:
  • *Art is meh and lazy for a good portion of scenes (as in, scribbles and character design, especially a lot of the faces)
  • The series is getting really off track from the main goal
  • The Balbadd arc has some of the worst pacing in the entire manga yet and should just end already. No, I do not give a fuck about Kashim whining
  • The action scenes are awesome, but sometimes blend in as being very similar to other action scenes we've seen already
* However I should note that the art does get a lot better as the series progresses
 
You haven't seen anything yet.

That's all I have to say right now.

Yesssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss.

I'm going to enjoy your reactions to it way too much.

Your jaw is going to be on the floor in how this will keep on topping itself. You will start to wonder how it hasn't been cancelled.

I really doubt anything can live up to the amount of hype you've thrown at us.
 
Gantz

i dont know what these alien mechas plan to do, if they're the same as the ones on earth they should only be 3-4x the size of a combat suit alien, the gantz mechs look to be about 50x bigger.

I liked how they buried Reika just to make it clear she's a doornail.
 
Magi in Review

Overall a solid manga, but has a few problems.

Pros:
  • Fantastic setting/world
  • Lots of solid humor
  • Great characters and character development
  • Great storyline
  • Awesome action scenes
Cons:
  • *Art is meh and lazy for a good portion of scenes (as in, scribbles and character design, especially a lot of the faces)
    [*]The series is getting really off track from the main goal
    [*]The Balbadd arc has some of the worst pacing in the entire manga yet and should just end already. No, I do not give a fuck about Kashim whining
  • The action scenes are awesome, but sometimes blend in as being very similar to other action scenes we've seen already
* However I should note that the art does get a lot better as the series progresses

I think this wouldn't be so apparent if we had 1 or 2 dungeons more before going to Balbadd. It reminds me a bit of the Skypiae arc in One Piece.
 
I think this wouldn't be so apparent if we had 1 or 2 dungeons more before going to Balbadd. It reminds me a bit of the Skypiae arc in One Piece.
Well wiki mentions a dungeon called Zangan, which I don't remember ever being showed up to the current point in scanlations, so maybe the next arc will be about that.
 
Come on, lets not fall victim to overexaggeration here, implying that Naruto isnt a good manga.
Naruto is not only not a good manga, it's a terrible manga. When the worst parts of it are still worse than Wolf Guy, then there's a problem!

Detective Conan sucks too so shut the fuck up survivor. It was only good when we thought it only had like 20+ episodes when it aired on Adult Swim.
 
Naruto is not only not a good manga, it's a terrible manga. When the worst parts of it are still worse than Wolf Guy, then there's a problem!

Detective Conan sucks too so shut the fuck up survivor. It was only good when we thought it only had like 20+ episodes when it aired on Adult Swim.

You really need to stop this. It was funny the first time, but now...
 
Naruto is not only not a good manga, it's a terrible manga. When the worst parts of it are still worse than Wolf Guy, then there's a problem!

Detective Conan sucks too so shut the fuck up survivor. It was only good when we thought it only had like 20+ episodes when it aired on Adult Swim.

Funny how that's the same exact reason why One Piece sucks as well
 
Naruto is not only not a good manga, it's a terrible manga. When the worst parts of it are still worse than Wolf Guy, then there's a problem!

Detective Conan sucks too so shut the fuck up survivor. It was only good when we thought it only had like 20+ episodes when it aired on Adult Swim.

wow. youre dissing conan too? nope. that was one of the best things on adult swim.
 
Naruto is not only not a good manga, it's a terrible manga. When the worst parts of it are still worse than Wolf Guy, then there's a problem!

What ?
The worst parts of Naruto are still funny , there is nothing good about wolf guy at all .
The MC is worst than the Sasuke can ever hope to be.
 
What ?
The worst parts of Naruto are still funny , there is nothing good about wolf guy at all .
The MC is worst than the Sasuke can ever hope to be.

I disagree but different strokes for different folks I suppose.

Sasuke and MC of Wolf Guy are equally shitty, only we've had to deal with Sasuke more cause of the length of the manga. To be, that makes him worse.

Actually maybe we should have a vote on this. I believe the MC is called "Wolf Guy" correct?
 
Naruto is not only not a good manga, it's a terrible manga. When the worst parts of it are still worse than Wolf Guy, then there's a problem!

Detective Conan sucks too so shut the fuck up survivor. It was only good when we thought it only had like 20+ episodes when it aired on Adult Swim.
This post is fucking awesome.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom