God, I decided to visit the GW2 Guru forums. Holy hell. It's nothing but doom and gloom in the WvW forum. That place is depressing, not to mention, ignorant.
Back to the consumables, I can't wait to find out info on it. Sounds like a waste of a profession if you can't use consumables in combat. I guess it all depends on duration.
Your best bet is to not go there.
They won't...but maybe they will. I bring up swapping tanks because that is the easiest way to channel behavior of the past. As long as you can maintain the aggro then it might be possible. That technically "breaks" the trinity but doesn't kill the same behavior. There may also be condition spamming or buffing loop holes. Using a specific team, that could make a durable tank, likely a guardian. So again, just a different take.
That's why I keep saying that the aggro AI is more important. I think people want the holy trinity behavior gone and not just it being 3 characters. Is it any better when you have your DPS ele's doing support spamming? That's just chopping up the mechanic. And it definitely isn't better if you are tank swapping. That just degenerates teams to 4 characters and the trinity is alive with a tag swap.
So yea...there's a bit more to it beyond developer claims.
The Guardian actually has one of the lowest HP counts in the game, though the many forms of control makes up for it. If you're looking at sheer HP, you'd want the Warrior or Necro. In the right hands, a Necro is going to be a bitch to kill IMO. Death Shroud and the Lich elite are 2 awesome oh shit buttons that prolong your life which is something that no other class can do in that sense.