• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

COMICS! l OT l October Marvel NOW is almost now edition

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why isn't cool title art more common? I was looking through Uncanny covers and these are the only ones that didn't have shitty word art titles.

Great choices, although my favorite would be this one.

61lut.jpg
 
People are probably going to scorf at me but whatever.

So i decided to get back into the Ultimate Comics Universe, as such i got all the recent Ultimate Comics The Ultimate comics.

Honestly it was fun at first, i really liked all the build up and everything....heck when they brought in Zorn and Xorn I was like shit this is going to be an awesome story.
Then it falls flat.....i mean seriously
Tony Starks techno-telepathic tumor convinces The City to turn against Reed???
......then theres the fact that they barely (read as didnt) use Zorn and Xorn for anything substantial considering how awesome both of them could have been (they could still be used later for something more interesting).....at the end of the day it was
Tony Stark here to save the day again in the most boring way possible
....I understand homicidal maniacs arent allowed to last long in the ultimate universe but come on.....lets get serious
Reed should have been atleast able to counter for this shit, but then no, he fucking loses it....if his insanity

Also, was i supposed to empathize with Hulk or not.....cuz i wanted him to beat the shit out of the "good guys".
 
I think hating the current Ultimates universe is not unpopular. I really can't imagine going back to it. All shock value, no substance is what it looks like.
 
People are probably going to scorf at me but whatever.

So i decided to get back into the Ultimate Comics Universe, as such i got all the recent Ultimate Comics The Ultimate comics.

Honestly it was fun at first, i really liked all the build up and everything....heck when they brought in Zorn and Xorn I was like shit this is going to be an awesome story.
Then it falls flat.....i mean seriously
Tony Starks techno-telepathic tumor convinces The City to turn against Reed???
......then theres the fact that they barely (read as didnt) use Zorn and Xorn for anything substantial considering how awesome both of them could have been (they could still be used later for something more interesting).....at the end of the day it was
Tony Stark here to save the day again in the most boring way possible
....I understand homicidal maniacs arent allowed to last long in the ultimate universe but come on.....lets get serious
Reed should have been atleast able to counter for this shit, but then no, he fucking loses it....if his insanity

Also, was i supposed to empathize with Hulk or not.....cuz i wanted him to beat the shit out of the "good guys".
I really liked that recent Ultimates arc, but the finale was a massive, massive anti-climax.
 
How did trauma turn out? Initiative pretty much ruined all the other characters.

The hood told him Nightmare is his biological father. He ends up leaving the initiative and was reported to either be training under Doctor Strange or he is looking for a man named Carl in New Orleans. So no one knows where he is, basically.

no one gets shafted more than the magic bros, it seems
 
Is Superman: Earth One worth reading? I just finished Batman: Earth One and loved it. I hope the next volume of it comes out next year at least. I want the Birthday Boy to return.

Also, can you guys recommend me some Elseworlds stories? The new edition of Gotham by Gaslight doesn't come out until March and I want to read something under that imprint now.
 
I'm going to check out more of his prose. I've been on a huge reading kick lately, and I need more mind fuel.

Well, he doesn't write prose exclusively, ever. I mean his writing in his comics, the text, is lyrical and moving in ways that most cartoonists can't pull off. I mean, the last page of the World's Fair bit in Jimmy Corrigan I mean seriously.
 
Is Superman: Earth One worth reading?

Fuck no. It's truly a bad, boring comic. I don't know much about JMS as a writer, as I've steered clear of his non-Superman work, but dude cannot write Supes worth a dick. Try Superman Red Son if you haven't already read that.
 
Is Superman: Earth One worth reading? I just finished Batman: Earth One and loved it. I hope the next volume of it comes out next year at least. I want the Birthday Boy to return.


Not really.

Also, can you guys recommend me some Elseworlds stories? The new edition of Gotham by Gaslight doesn't come out until March and I want to read something under that imprint now.


Batmite. The Nail. JLA/Planetary.
 
I'm catching up on Daredevil now, liked issues 9 and 10, but this Omega Effect Avenging Spidey first issue of the 3 issue crossover isn't working for me. I blame it all on the whiny " NO ONE DIES " Spidey take and Punisher not really fitting in. The whole thing just seems contrived. Punisher kills people and Spider-man doesn't! And they are working together! :O

518lofJiTiL._SL500_SS500_.jpg


One of my favorite Elseworlds along with Superman Red Son.
 
I'm catching up on Daredevil now, liked issues 9 and 10, but this Omega Effect Avenging Spidey first issue of the 3 issue crossover isn't working for me. I blame it all on the whiny " NO ONE DIES " Spidey take and Punisher not really fitting in. The whole thing just seems contrived. Punisher kills people and Spider-man doesn't! And they are working together! :O.

Have you been reading Rucka's Punisher as well? 'Cause I came to the crossover from that comic and loved it due to the levity it brought. I actually really liked the juxtaposition of Frank and Spidey this time around, 'cause Frank is so laconic and Spidey's chattiness is always entertaining, especially with Waid and Rucka writing him.
 
Have you been reading Rucka's Punisher as well? 'Cause I came to the crossover from that comic and loved it due to the levity it brought. I actually really liked the juxtaposition of Frank and Spidey this time around, 'cause Frank is so laconic and Spidey's chattiness is always entertaining, especially with Waid and Rucka writing him.

Speaking of Punisher, i read the second issue of Omega Effect, Punisher #10, and liked it a lot more than the first Avenging issue. I thought it was funnier and just in general worked better with the interacting characters. I've only read issues #1 and #2 of Punisher from Rucka prior, i liked it somewhat but it was a little too gloomy and didn't really hook me, but with all these great reviews lately for Punisher i'd probably buy an Ultimate Collection TPB if/when/if it comes out, or read it if the rest of the issues come to MDCU ( in their awesome way, MDCU has issues 1-2 and 4-9, issue 3 i guess is for suckers).
 
I guess I am the only here that liked Superman earth 1

It was....okay. I'm not a huge fan of the whole "Superman is just like you cause he's lonely" angle, but the story worked, and the ending did leave me interested in what happened next.
 
I thought Superman Earth One was okay too, mostly unremarkable and didn't really change enough to stand out and in that i can't recommend it.
 
New pet theory about DC's continuity : Amanda Waller's mom is the Amanda Waller from Ostrander's Suicide Squad.
tEzl8.jpg


Just fucking look at her dropping a ninja and NOT GIVING A FUCK.
 
New pet theory about DC's continuity : Amanda Waller's mom is the Amanda Waller from Ostrander's Suicide Squad.
tEzl8.jpg


Just fucking look at her dropping a ninja and NOT GIVING A FUCK.

Amanda Waller is one of my favorite characters in DC, and I only know her from Batman Beyond. Even so, she was so cool in that.
 
What's Rachel up to these days? Last time I read anything about her she'd marched off with Zack from FF7 to fight the Shi'ar/Shin-ra and avenger her family's death. Why did nobody think the Phoenix was coming for her?

The Phoenix left her in space and she was like "no mama!" Now she's back on Earth teaching at the JG School. Thankfully she dumped that loser Korvus. You need to be reading Wolverine and the XMen.
 
I did it guys. I'm finally reading Morrison's New X-Men. Feels good to finally be filling one of the biggest gaps in my X-Men knowledge. Gotta say though, I really do not dig Quitely. I respect the guy and recognize that he's got a lot of talent, but I just don't really like his style at all. Not enough straight lines. What's even weirder though is EVS, whose Green Lantern stuff I really liked, isn't really appealing to me much here either. Seems like he's trying to match FQ's style maybe? I dunno, I just don't really like the look of the run at all but I'm only a few issues in, maybe it'll grow on me.
 
Gotta say though, I really do not dig Quitely. I respect the guy and recognize that he's got a lot of talent, but I just don't really like his style at all. Not enough straight lines. What's even weirder though is EVS, whose Green Lantern stuff I really liked, isn't really appealing to me much here either. Seems like he's trying to match FQ's style maybe? I dunno, I just don't really like the look of the run at all but I'm only a few issues in, maybe it'll grow on me.

You have come to the light too late.

There is no redemption for you. Only hellfire.

Quietly is a poor Darrow clone.

EVS is a shitty 90's George Perez freak of nature. EVS is to Perez, as Finch is to Silvestri/Lee.

At least Quietly doesn't have the weird asymmetry that appears all so often in EVS work. I can't read a Flash comic where Flash's god damned head is deformed brah! And not because it's stylistic like Quietly. :P
 
Amanda Waller is one of my favorite characters in DC, and I only know her from Batman Beyond. Even so, she was so cool in that.

then you havent seen the jlu episodes where her and bruce play mental chess?
 
You have come to the light too late.

There is no redemption for you. Only hellfire.

Quietly is a poor Darrow clone.

EVS is a shitty 90's George Perez freak of nature. EVS is to Perez, as Finch is to Silvestri/Lee.

At least Quietly doesn't have the weird asymmetry that appears all so often in EVS work. I can't read a Flash comic where Flash's god damned head is deformed brah! And not because it's stylistic like Quietly. :P

You're a comic hipster. A smelly comic book hipster that won't let anybody have any fun whatsoever.
 
You're a comic hipster. A smelly comic book hipster that won't let anybody have any fun whatsoever.

Wait, now I'm confused.

I thought hipsters liked Quietly because he eschewed traditional mainstream comic art conventions.

Or is it comic book hipsters that like Rob Liefeld comics ironically?

It's too much to handle! TOO MUCH!
 
I did it guys. I'm finally reading Morrison's New X-Men. Feels good to finally be filling one of the biggest gaps in my X-Men knowledge. Gotta say though, I really do not dig Quitely. I respect the guy and recognize that he's got a lot of talent, but I just don't really like his style at all. Not enough straight lines. What's even weirder though is EVS, whose Green Lantern stuff I really liked, isn't really appealing to me much here either. Seems like he's trying to match FQ's style maybe? I dunno, I just don't really like the look of the run at all but I'm only a few issues in, maybe it'll grow on me.

I'm usually a fan of Quitely, but I didn't like his work on New X-Men at all. All-Star Superman is his best stuff, imo.
 
I'm usually a fan of Quitely, but I didn't like his work on New X-Men at all. All-Star Superman is his best stuff, imo.

His first storyline is inked, but he switches to digital inks in the second of his Riot At Xaviers issues. (As everyone I'm sure noticed immediately.)

Funny story, he likes Dan Green's work inking his stuff (E is For Extinction Part 3!!!) (I KNOW!!) the most.
 
I did it guys. I'm finally reading Morrison's New X-Men. Feels good to finally be filling one of the biggest gaps in my X-Men knowledge. Gotta say though, I really do not dig Quitely. I respect the guy and recognize that he's got a lot of talent, but I just don't really like his style at all. Not enough straight lines. What's even weirder though is EVS, whose Green Lantern stuff I really liked, isn't really appealing to me much here either. Seems like he's trying to match FQ's style maybe? I dunno, I just don't reaylly like the look of the run at all but I'm only a few issues in, maybe it'll grow on me.

You are finally reading one of the best comics stories ever told. The silent "nuff said" issue is in my top 3 single comics ever.
 
You are finally reading one of the best comics stories ever told. The silent "nuff said" issue is in my top 3 single comics ever.

Currently Morrison's Animal Man is already one of my favs. I think that's why I was putting off reading NXM so long is because I didn't want to risk liking it enough to have to label myself a Morrison fan since his newer stuff is all literal nonsense to me.
 
Currently Morrison's Animal Man is already one of my favs. I think that's why I was putting off reading NXM so long is because I didn't want to risk liking it enough to have to label myself a Morrison fan since his newer stuff is all literal nonsense to me.

I can't get past Truog in the OG Animal Man. I'm sure it's wonderful, fine, but that...I mean...it's just...

I'll probably never read that comic.
 
Talk about P.E.N.I.S....

New X-Men got there years earlier.

Sex is hidden everywhere!

Currently Morrison's Animal Man is already one of my favs. I think that's why I was putting off reading NXM so long is because I didn't want to risk liking it enough to have to label myself a Morrison fan since his newer stuff is all literal nonsense to me.

I know what you mean. Dude has a lot of misses, but not according to his legion of followers. I find diehard Morrison fans to be obnoxious as hell.
 
Currently Morrison's Animal Man is already one of my favs. I think that's why I was putting off reading NXM so long is because I didn't want to risk liking it enough to have to label myself a Morrison fan since his newer stuff is all literal nonsense to me.

The fuck? His Action Comics run isn't always on point but when it's good, it's some of the best cape stuff out there. His Batman work is stellar and Joe the Barbarian is a hell of a miniseries. I'll happily call myself a Morrison fan--old and new.
 
I can't get past Truog in the OG Animal Man. I'm sure it's wonderful, fine, but that...I mean...it's just...

I'll probably never read that comic.

Man... You should. Art was at worst serviceable. I didn't ever find it offensive, but I think my taste in comic artist is already notoriously suspect here.
 
I know what you mean. Dude has a lot of misses, but not according to his legion of followers. I find diehard Morrison fans to be obnoxious as hell.

Hm. I dunno man - even the most die hard Morrison fans would probably admit that a lot of his work is compromised by his collaborators, especially on longer runs. It's definitely there in New X-Men, which is so much worse without Quitely or Bachalo and JLA, which I found nearly unreadable and like 75% of his Batman stuff.

Morrison's big problem (aside from the tweeness that often plagues his cape stuff) is that, unlike Alan Moore* or Frank Miller, he doesn't seem to care who draws his shit.

*aside from the Image-slumming years
 
The only art that I just can't deal with is Eric Canete and Larry Stroman. They could be paired with Milligan, writing a new X-statix story and I would still not buy it.
 
Morrison's big problem (aside from the tweeness that often plagues his cape stuff) is that, unlike Alan Moore* or Frank Miller, he doesn't seem to care who draws his shit.

*aside from the Image-slumming years

I agree with what you said about bad art afflicting some of his stories but it's hard to imagine that he doesn't give a shit. I mean, the dude grew up drawing and has at least a fundamental knowledge of comic art , but as somebody trying to bring out a story on a timely basis, on some sort of schedule, he probably had to take those hits on New X-Men and Invisibles and whatever else just to get the issues out. I can't really think of any long-form runs that have impeccable art all the way through. Even Uncanny X-Force had a jarringly atrocious arc, in terms of art, that many people decided to drop and come back to once it finished.
 
Morrison's big problem (aside from the tweeness that often plagues his cape stuff) is that, unlike Alan Moore* or Frank Miller, he doesn't seem to care who draws his shit.

*aside from the Image-slumming years

The problem isn't what Morisson thinks. He's doing company owned work. I'm sure he's a big enough name to have some say in who draws his books, but in most cases - especially now with accelerated release schedules - the mandate is for Marvel/DC to get the books out.

Moore's Image slumming years were still pretty great, even if he was just rehashing his 80's DC work.

The only art that I just can't deal with is Eric Canete and Larry Stroman. They could be paired with Milligan, writing a new X-statix story and I would still not buy it.

Canete is like Quietly in a way. Both are fantastic artists, but they're not cut out for mainstream superhero comics. They just don't have that slick Michael Bay / Jim Lee look people expect from mainstream superhero comics.
 
I never got the feeling that alan moore really cared that strongly who was drawing his books. He worked with great artists in his later years because he was alan moore and dave gibbons asked to be on watchmen
 
I agree with what you said about bad art afflicting some of his stories but it's hard to imagine that he doesn't give a shit. I mean, the dude grew up drawing and has at least a fundamental knowledge of comic art , but as somebody trying to bring out a story on a timely basis, on some sort of schedule, he probably had to take those hits on New X-Men and Invisibles and whatever else just to get the issues out. I can't really think of any long-form runs that have impeccable art all the way through. Even Uncanny X-Force had a jarringly atrocious arc, in terms of art, that many people decided to drop and come back to once it finished.

The problem isn't what Morisson thinks. He's doing company owned work. I'm sure he's a big enough name to have some say in who draws his books, but in most cases - especially now with accelerated release schedules - the mandate is for Marvel/DC to get the books out.

Yeah, a huge part of Morrison x bad art is the format he's decided to work in - monthly comics are poison for good, consistent art. Maybe "doesn't give a shit" is a bit harsh but I think he's definitely resigned himself to the pitfalls of getting a book out every month if he wants to write some ~ Batman comics ~.
 
You have come to the light too late.

There is no redemption for you. Only hellfire.

Quietly is a poor Darrow clone.

EVS is a shitty 90's George Perez freak of nature. EVS is to Perez, as Finch is to Silvestri/Lee.

At least Quietly doesn't have the weird asymmetry that appears all so often in EVS work. I can't read a Flash comic where Flash's god damned head is deformed brah! And not because it's stylistic like Quietly. :P

If EVS is a shitty Perez, then what does that make Jimenez? Good Perez?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom