Regarding the PS4 controller, I only have three requests: make it bigger, change the analog stick placement, and change the d-pad style. They need to make controllers for us bigger folks. =p
Yeah, let's alienate the old fans for the slight chance of gaining some new ones. That went well, when Insomniac did the same with Resistance 2, which resulted with poor R3 sales. I, for one, abhor asymmetrically placed sticks, and the same goes for concave sticks, which make my fingers hurt during longer playing sessions. The same can be said about the hard convex action buttons during longer plays.
I sometimes wonder if the placement of the left stick is a problem for those who prefer the Xbox pad, why doesn't the same apply to the right one? After all, you're using it far more in modern games, than the action buttons.
I dunno how they could make the D-pad better? The one in Xbox pad is awful. I'd be satisfied if they just improved the L2/R2 triggers, but kept their placement the same, as all four shoulder buttons need to be easily accessed simultaneously.
However, I might not have a problem with making the controller
slightly bigger, although the current size is perfect for me. Just keep its shape similar, and don't make it noticeably more heavy to hold. The lightness of DualShock is one of its strengths, especially for people like me who sometimes play 5-9 hours in a row.