LazyParrot
Member
Anachronox is amazing and Daikatana is objectively worse, but it's not the worst Ion Storm Dallas game. That honor will forever belong to Dominion: Storm over Gift 3.
-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
Best Game and the Worst Game of a Franchise
- Thread starter Plague Doctor
- Start date
Gamer_By_Proxy
About to beat off
Best: Zelda 1
Worst: Zelda 2
Worst: Zelda 2
![L*][*N*K](/data/avatars/m/842/842515.jpg?1756724107){kind=avatar}
RaidenJTr7
Member
Killzone 2
Killzone 3
Killzone shadow fall
Crysis
Crysis 2
Crysis 3
Killzone 3
Killzone shadow fall
Crysis
Crysis 2
Crysis 3
Plague Doctor
Member
Fallout 2 - Best
Fallout 76 - Worst
Fallout 76 - Worst
Codes 208
Member
Oooh i got a couple.
Halo
Best: Halo 3
Worst: Halo 5
TLoZ:
Best: Majora's Mask (specifically N64 version)
Worst: Phantom Hourglass
Mario:
Best: Super Mario 64
Worst: NSMB (any of them. Played one, youve played them all)
Souls-Like:
Best: Bloodborne
Worst: Dark Souls 2: SotFS
Pokemon:
Best: R/S/E
Worst: SP/BD
Halo
Best: Halo 3
Worst: Halo 5
TLoZ:
Best: Majora's Mask (specifically N64 version)
Worst: Phantom Hourglass
Mario:
Best: Super Mario 64
Worst: NSMB (any of them. Played one, youve played them all)
Souls-Like:
Best: Bloodborne
Worst: Dark Souls 2: SotFS
Pokemon:
Best: R/S/E
Worst: SP/BD
VGA-Games
Member
Metroid:
Metroid Prime Remastered (BEST)
Metroid Other M (WORST)
The Legend of Zelda:
Zelda: A Link to the Past (BEST)
Zelda: Skyward Sword HD (WORST)
Super Mario:
Super Mario Odyssey (BEST)
Super Mario Bros. 2 (WORST)
Resident Evil:
Resident Evil HD Remake (BEST)
Resident Evil 6 (WORST)
Castlevania:
Super Castlevania IV (BEST)
Castlevania II: Simon's Quest (WORST)
Metroid Prime Remastered (BEST)
Metroid Other M (WORST)
The Legend of Zelda:
Zelda: A Link to the Past (BEST)
Zelda: Skyward Sword HD (WORST)
Super Mario:
Super Mario Odyssey (BEST)
Super Mario Bros. 2 (WORST)
Resident Evil:
Resident Evil HD Remake (BEST)
Resident Evil 6 (WORST)
Castlevania:
Super Castlevania IV (BEST)
Castlevania II: Simon's Quest (WORST)
Last edited:
TintoConCasera
I bought a sex doll, but I keep it inflated 100% of the time and use it like a regular wife
Dude, Young Blood. Or is your brain protecting you from that cursed memory.
L'Empereur Hadrien
Neo Member
Castlevania*
Best: Castlevania 3
Worst: Portrait of Ruin (hate that game despite loving every other Castletroid)
*not counting the Western-developed titles
Best: Castlevania 3
Worst: Portrait of Ruin (hate that game despite loving every other Castletroid)
*not counting the Western-developed titles
Plague Doctor
Member
Dude, Young Blood. Or is your brain protecting you from that cursed memory.
Barely played it. I did play New Collusus from start to finish.
Gunplay was fine. Everything else was not.
Last edited:
Hohenheim
Member
Mortal combat 4 !
Love it!
Neff
Member
Resident Evil/Operation Raccoon City
Super Mario 64/Super Mario DS
A Link to the Past/Wand of Gamelon
Super Metroid/Federation Force
Final Fantasy VII/Final Fantasy XVI
Sonic The Hedgehog/Sonic '06
MGSV/Portable Ops
Devil May Cry/Devil May Cry 2
Street Fighter III Third Strike/Street Fighter II The Interactive Movie
Dark Souls II/Demon's Souls
Tekken Tag Tournament 2/Tekken Advance
Virtua Fighter 5 Final Showdown/Virtua Quest
Kingdom Hearts/Kingdom Hearts II
Symphony of the Night/Haunted Castle
Bayonetta/Bayonetta 3
Super Mario 64/Super Mario DS
A Link to the Past/Wand of Gamelon
Super Metroid/Federation Force
Final Fantasy VII/Final Fantasy XVI
Sonic The Hedgehog/Sonic '06
MGSV/Portable Ops
Devil May Cry/Devil May Cry 2
Street Fighter III Third Strike/Street Fighter II The Interactive Movie
Dark Souls II/Demon's Souls
Tekken Tag Tournament 2/Tekken Advance
Virtua Fighter 5 Final Showdown/Virtua Quest
Kingdom Hearts/Kingdom Hearts II
Symphony of the Night/Haunted Castle
Bayonetta/Bayonetta 3
Halo2redvsblue
Member
Best: Half Life 2
Worst: Half Life 3
Best: Portal 2
Worst: Portal 3
Best: Left 4 Dead 2
Worst: Left 4 Dead 3
Valve just sucks at making a third game.
Worst: Half Life 3
Best: Portal 2
Worst: Portal 3
Best: Left 4 Dead 2
Worst: Left 4 Dead 3
Valve just sucks at making a third game.
JohnnyFootball
GerAlt-Right. Ciriously.
Best: Mass Effect 3
Worst: Mass Effect 3
Yes it's true
Worst: Mass Effect 3
Yes it's true
cartman414
Member
Zelda 1 was far less replayable.
Team Andromeda
Member
Best - Ninja Gaiden 2
Worst -Ninja Gaiden 3
Best - Mario Galaxy
Worst - Mario Odyssey
Best - Halo Infinite
Worst - Halo 2
Best - Forza Horzion 3
Worst - Forza Horzion 5
Best - GOW
Worst- GOD: Ragnarok
Best - Sonic Adv
Worst - Sonic 06
Best - Castlevania IV
Worst - Castlevania Bloodlines
Worst -Ninja Gaiden 3
Best - Mario Galaxy
Worst - Mario Odyssey
Best - Halo Infinite
Worst - Halo 2
Best - Forza Horzion 3
Worst - Forza Horzion 5
Best - GOW
Worst- GOD: Ragnarok
Best - Sonic Adv
Worst - Sonic 06
Best - Castlevania IV
Worst - Castlevania Bloodlines
Last edited:
Major Insano
Member
Mario Galaxy> Mario bros 2
Halo 3> Halo 2
Baldurs Gate 2> Baldurs Gate
Fallout 4> 76
SF3 3rd Strike> SF
Zelda OOT> Zelda 2
Farcry 2> Farcry
Witcher 3> Gwent
COD4 MW> BLOPs 4
Halo 3> Halo 2
Baldurs Gate 2> Baldurs Gate
Fallout 4> 76
SF3 3rd Strike> SF
Zelda OOT> Zelda 2
Farcry 2> Farcry
Witcher 3> Gwent
COD4 MW> BLOPs 4