Support NeoGAF

[FourMyle]

That page 27...

Anyhow;

Kill: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
Kill: Pinky and the Brain
Save: Hey Arnold

TMNT= glorified commercial to sell kids crap, as so many other shows from its time.

And like everyone else said, Pinky and the Brain worked much better as part of the Animaniacs whole. This standalone show was unnecessary.

 

[tkscz]

Kill: TMNT - Seriously, this show did not age well at all.
Kill: Pinky and The Brain - again, terrible on it's own.

Save: Darkwing Duck - best of all the disney afternoon, even beating Gargoyles.

 

[Skid 4 Dead]

Oh man, I missed allot.
Hopefully that's as messy as it's going to get...

 

[AniHawk]

Kill: TMNT - Seriously, this show did not age well at all.
Kill: Pinky and The Brain - again, terrible on it's own.

Save: Darkwing Duck - best of all the disney afternoon, even beating Gargoyles.

i agree. let's kill gargoyles next and save darkwing duck

 

[Skid 4 Dead]

Kill : Freakazoid!
Kill : Freakazoid!
Save : Hey Arnold!

Freakazoid was a solid show, I liked it as a child. However, I believe it's the worst superhero show left on this list. Also, I can't bring myself to vote out the turtles, you guys will have to do it for me...

 

[MikeHattsu]

Kill: Superman The Animated Series - Way to many superhero shows left, lets get rid of one
Kill: Superman The Animated Series
Save: TBD

And wow at the last 2 pages

 

[AniHawk]

i like the crew behind the animated series, but i never really cared much for supes. braniac and darkseid were pretty cool though.

 

[Oblivion]

so we're all in agreement that 90s turtles has to go right.

look at this crap.

i mean look.

seriously.

That'll die in due time, but I have priorities at the moment.


Kill: Dexter's Lab
Kill: South Park

Save: Freakazoid


I've already commented on why Dexter should go. South Park was atrocious in the 90s. It was very rough, and kind of a pain to watch. Didn't really hit its stride until the early 00s.

As for Freakazoid, seriously what the hell is wrong with you people?

 

[ЯAW]

Kill: Superman The Animated Series - Way to many superhero shows left, lets get rid of one
Kill: Superman The Animated Series
Save: TBD

And wow at the last 2 pages

I'm with you next round. Lets make this voting interesting!

 

[SonicMegaDrive]

Kill: Hey Arnold. Either this, Doug, or Spongebob. They're the only shows left I don't care much for.
Kill: Hey Arnold

Save: Freakazoid. Because hugbees, that's why.

 

[barrbarr]

Kill: X-men: I know this show isn't going to leave us just yet, but it is worse than you guys remember
Kill: Teenage: Mutant Ninja Turtles This show was good, but the rest of the shows on this list are better
Save: SuperMan

Edit: Needed to change my save, have to help out supes

 

[RumblingRosco]

Ren & Stimpy's out? hehehehehehehehe

Well done team "Ren-&-Stimpy-isn't-really-as-good-as-the-rest-of-you-seem-to-think"!

Kill: Freakazoid
Kill: Freakazoid
Save: Dexter's Laboratory

Freakazoid isn't horrible, but the main character annoyed me to some extent as a kid. I can't say I hate the show, just that it is more or less at the bottom of the remaining list in my personal experience.

Dexter's Lab, on the other hand, was perhaps one of my favorite shows as a kid. I've rewatched it recently and I don't think it held up as well, but nostalgia still is a powerful thing.

 

[RepairmanJack]

Kill: Freakazoid
Kill: Pinky and The Brain

I've voted for both in the past and given reasons, they both received a lot of votes but hung around. It's time for them to go.

Save: Superman


GOD DAMN YOU PEOPLE for all the Ren and Stimpy hate. I just can't even understand the hate.

 

[massoluk]

Kill: Rugrats
Kill: Freakazoid

Save... fuck if i know, I guess I'll cockblock that one dude that hate Superman
Save Superman TAS.

 

[SmithnCo]

Kill: TMNT
Kill: TMNT
Save: Hey Arnold

Changed kill votes to TMNT because it should probably go soon and P&B has enough heat already.

 

[Deleted member 74300]

Kill: Hey Arnold
Kill: Hey Arnold
Save: Freakazoid

 

[MikeHattsu]

Save... fuck if i know, I guess I'll cockblock that one dude that hate Superman
Save Superman TAS.

 

[Camwi]

Kill: Freakazoid
Kill: Freakazoid
Save: Beavis and Butthead

Freakazoid is awful, and Beavis and Butthead is the ultimate in stupid humor. It's a shame Mike Judge got screwed with that show's original run.

 

[Witchfinder General]

Kill: Reboot
Kill: Beast Wars
Save: X-Men

 

[RepairmanJack]

Kill: Reboot
Kill: Beast Wars
Save: X-Men

 

[Markster]

Wow, that tally-time drama!

As for my votes:

Kill: Superman The Animated Series
Kill: Spongebob
Save: TMNT

Gotta knock one off one of the superheores!
TMNT, I will always have a place for you in my heart

 

[vikki]

Kill: Superman
Kill: Superman

I'm Lex Luthor

Save: Dexter's Lab

This is damn near #1, it shouldn't even be mentioned until at least the top 5.

 

[A Human Becoming]

Holy drama, Batman!

Kill: Pinky and the Brain - Never was much of a fan.
Kill: Freakazoid - Barely watched it.

Save: TMNT

I don't care if it sucked later. Show was a huge part of my childhood.

 

[Spectral Glider]

Kill: Doug
Kill: Reboot
Save: TMNT

 

[Divvy]

Kill: Freakazoid
Kill: Freakazoid

Save: Pinky and the Brain

I don't really care about Freakazoid or anything, but I think a superhero show should go first

 

[Camwi]

Kill: Superman
Kill: Superman

Save: Freakazoid

I don't really care about Freakazoid or anything, but I think a superhero show should go first

But Freakazoid is a superhero show?

 

[CorporateClown]

Kill: Doug
Kill: Doug
Save: Freakazoid

 

[massoluk]

Kill: Superman
Kill: Superman

Save: Freakazoid

I don't really care about Freakazoid or anything, but I think a superhero show should go first

I don't think there can be peace between us. First V2 Gundam diss at Gundam thread and now this Superman diss. This means war, sir.

 

[LordCanti]

Ren and Stimpy died and people went fucking crazy.

 

[Dicer]

Kill: Hey Arnold
Kill: Hey Arnold
Save: TMNT

 

[RepairmanJack]

Ren and Stimpy died and people went fucking crazy.

I don't even understand what's going on this round. Hey Arnold, TMNT, Reboot, Superman, Beast Wars? Did people forget about Freakazoid and Pinky and the Brain? Both of which were close to going already?

It's like as soon as a show becomes close to getting out people forget completely about them.

 

[TheAbsolution]

Ren and Stimpy died and people went fucking crazy.

Yeah. Holy fuck is the spreadsheet for this one gonna be long.
I bet you someone is gonna snipe a really good show this round too.

 

[Gintoki313]

Kill: Pinky and the Brain
Kill: Pinky and the Brain
Save: Hey Arnold

I never really thought Pinky & The Brain was funny, I always turned the channel when it came one. I just never got the comedy I guess.

I stated my reasons why I want to save Hey Arnold before. I like it.

 

[Spectral Glider]

I don't even understand what's going on this round. Hey Arnold, TMNT, Reboot, Superman, Beast Wars? Did people forget about Freakazoid and Pinky and the Brain? Both of which were close to going already?

It's like as soon as a show becomes close to getting out people forget completely about them.

Unlike a lot of people or so it seems, I've only been voting for shows I've actually watched or seen more than one episode of. I have no idea in the world what the hell Freakazoid is and I think I watched all of 5 minutes of Pinky and the Brain once.

 

[LordCanti]

I don't even understand what's going on this round. Hey Arnold, TMNT, Reboot, Superman, Beast Wars? Did people forget about Freakazoid and Pinky and the Brain? Both of which were close to going already?

It's like as soon as a show becomes close to getting out people forget completely about them.

TMNT really isn't a good show (I was sad to find out), but yeah, all bets seem to be off now.

Yeah. Holy fuck is the spreadsheet for this one gonna be long.
I bet you someone is gonna snipe a really good show this round too.

Anything could go now for sure.

 

[ЯAW]

Kill: Superman
Kill: Superman

Save: Freakazoid

I don't really care about Freakazoid or anything, but I think a superhero show should go first

Kill: Superman
Kill: Superman

I'm Lex Luthor

Save: Dexter's Lab

This is damn near #1, it shouldn't even be mentioned until at least the top 5.

Wow, that tally-time drama!

As for my votes:

Kill: Superman The Animated Series
Kill: Spongebob
Save: TMNT

Gotta knock one off one of the superheores!
TMNT, I will always have a place for you in my heart

Uuh, things are getting interesting!

 

[RepairmanJack]

If any superhero show should go I was thinking it'd be The Tick. I remember liking the live action show but I don't really remember ever liking the cartoon, though I do remember seeing it at least.

 

[LordCanti]

The Tick or Freakazoid. Having two comedic superheroes is a bit much.

 

[Frustrated_Grunt]

The kill votes are starting to get painful, but I guess I have to start sticking with my top 10
Kill: Reboot
Kill: TMNT
Saveinky and the Brain

I actually loved the standalone show as a kid.

 

[Markster]

I don't even understand what's going on this round. Hey Arnold, TMNT, Reboot, Superman, Beast Wars? Did people forget about Freakazoid and Pinky and the Brain? Both of which were close to going already?

It's like as soon as a show becomes close to getting out people forget completely about them.

This is when the thread is at its best!

The rounds where everyone dogpiles on the runners-up from the last round are pretty boring. Also, now that R&S doesn't need constant killing/saving, there are a lot of freelance votes freed up, and clearly they don't mind keeping P&tB and Freakazoid.

There seem to be cycles:
1) Free for all round, where there is no obvious choice
2) Round ends in tragedy as a beloved show is sniped
3) Next 2 rounds have a dogpile on the runners-up
4) Tensions run high as "the obvious choice" all along is finally brought down.
5) Everyone is exhausted, and just votes for whatever: go to step 1

 

[KalBalboa]

Kill Pinky and the Brain
Kill TMNT
Save Superman TAS

Superman is simply to damn good of a show. The writing, animation, music, and finale... too good to cut now with so much else that could go. Cutting it would be a real shame at this stage.

 

[FourMyle]

TMNT was straight up trash, my hate for TMNT as a whole notwithstanding. The show was simply not good, man. Look inside yourself and realize that this is true!

The show had less writing integrity than god damn Ren & Stimpy. It was a giant, prolonged dead horse of a commercial that they beat for almost a decade.

 

[ЯAW]

C'mon people! We have nice momentum going on, let's snuff Superman!

 

[Markster]

Save Superman TAS

Superman is simply to damn good of a show. The writing, animation, music, and finale... too good to cut now with so much else that could go.

I never could have guessed your allegiance!

Superman was interesting, as it really set the groundwork for the modern JLA-universe shows, but I just can't choose it over the other superheroes (except Batman Beyond), and I really think they need thinning out.
I do have fond memories of the Batman/Superman crossover.

Spoiler

Supes is such a douche, using his x-ray vision to reveal Bruce.

 

[barrbarr]

I don't see how superman is even an option yet. I love Freakazoid, but it isn't in the same level as superman, and neither is The Tick or X-men.

 

[KalBalboa]

C'mon people! We have nice momentum going on, let's snuff Superman!

Tsk tsk, Raw. I hardly knew ye.

It's a great show.

 

[LordCanti]

I don't see how superman is even an option yet. I love Freakazoid, but it isn't in the same level as superman, and neither is The Tick or X-men.

It's an option because a ton of Ren and Stimpy votes are free now and those people are out for blood.

 

[ЯAW]

Tsk tsk, Raw. I hardly knew ye.

It's a great show.

I'm a Batman man myself. I can't take the risk Batman losing to Superman towards the end. I take my shots when they are offered :b

 

[KalBalboa]

I don't see how superman is even an option yet. I love Freakazoid, but it isn't in the same level as superman, and neither is The Tick or X-men.

Yeah, I agree. Superman TAS outclasses a lot on the list remaining.

 

[KalBalboa]

I'm a Batman man myself. I can't take the risk Batman losing to Superman towards the end. I take my shots when they are offered :b

That Batman show is definitely superior, but Superman should at least be top twenty.

You know that in your heart!