My impressions:
Halo 5 looks okay, squad commands don't seem to amount to much. Plus having a squad isn't what I want in Halo, I always loved the fact you were a one-man army against insurmountable forces.
CGI trailer for Recore, new IP is good, a nothing CGI trailer, bad
Backwards compatibility is a megaton, good move
Forza 6 looks brilliant, as to be expected really. Turn 10 are so consistent.
Odd Fallout 4 segment, literally the same demo as at Bethesda. Took up way too much time for a mods announcement, while obviously cool.
The Division looks nowhere near as good as when it was unveiled, predictable I guess
Rainbow 6 Siege, need to see more at Ubisoft's conference specifically the campaign
Nothing trailers for a bunch of indies, Cuphead looks brilliant though
Early Access - Fuck off
Good showing of Rise of the Tomb Raider, nice get for Microsoft this year
Rare Collection is amazing value but I personally would have wanted a lavish remaster of a single property instead
No Banjo Threeie - Fuck
Sea of Thieves is a fucking MMO
Valve VR partnership outta nowhere
Magical tech on show by Hololens for Minecraft, is it legit though?
Gears of War Ultimate. No gameplay, why? Should have showed it off since people can play the vanilla version due to backwards compatibility.
Gears 4 - what a weak demo, incredible how much they fucked this one up. Dark as fuck, couldn't see anything, tedious gameplay that only got half-interesting in the last 30 seconds. Trying to recapture the horror vibe of the original is most welcome, but they did a horrible job showing it off to the world.
It wasn't a bad show, but I really thought Microsoft would go all out this year and they didn't. The presentation seemed disjointed with the momentum and atmosphere of the room being sucked out of the room with the Fallout 4 demo and indie segments. A lack of gameplay for many titles was conspicuous too.
It needed something more.
Not bad but deeply underwhelming. 6/10