Finished Abzu last night. I liked it. It didn't have the emotional impact that Journey did, but it's unfair of me to compare it to Journey, although the developers have used so much of the Journey template, it's hard not to.
I liked the art, the music, the swimming with the fishes. The way you and the fish moved together was graceful and sometimes brought a smile to my face. I liked how you could spin and they'd spin. You push forward and they'd move with you. I got to swim with the dolphins, which was a kick. Got to swim with a lot of types of fish.
There were a lot of times when I just enjoyed the immersion in the environment. Lots of moments like that.
The game caused me to appreciate the diversity of life in the oceans -- or just the variety of life on Earth in general. I don't normally spend much time thinking about that. About the huge variety of life down there, living, multiplying, eating each other, dying, going through it all. It just made me appreciate that.
The game held my interest, progressed well. It wrapped up in a satisfying way. If I had a criticism, I felt that all of the fish were a little much. It was like they thought more fish and more colors = more emotional response or something. I would've preferred something a bit more subtle. I got some clipping and weird effects sometimes, with that many fish. Minor niggle, though.
I am still not entirely sure what happened, but that's par for the course with games like these. Something about overcoming death and darkness and restoring life. I'm still puzzling over the robot angle, what the circular globe represents, and some other things.
If I stick a number on it, it's somewhere in the 8.5 to 9 range. 9 if I give a bonus because I appreciate that games like this get made, the artistic, experiential type, rather than the usual.
I'll play through it a second time at some point, I'm sure. It's a very relaxing ride.