Figures.
Part of what made Halo in the eyes of the "Pros" a test of skill, was that from the beginning of the game (on several maps) you started with the game's best weapon -- the pistol. Sure, the rocket launcher, sniper rifle and power-ups had their uses (and all respawned on a timer -- check HBO for the times, there's a page there that has all of them). So Halo became a game of keep away, and ultimately you had the best weapon from the get go (levels like derelict/wizard started you with plasma junk, but the pistol was pretty available though in Wizard it was only on one of the elevated panels, so if you controlled that panel, and the powerup behind it -- game over).
Derelict, whoring sniper and rockets -- both up top, meant you controlled the map, along with all of the power-ups, a totally unbalanced map.
Now, CAL, MLG, et cetera are running the ruleset for their Halo 2 games with the emulation of Halo in mind. The Battle Rifle, by their estimation is the new pistol. It's a four shot kill. Add a plasma pistol and its essentially a one-shot kill. So the MLG guys are running the battle rifle as starting equipment.
Part of what makes Halo 2 good, are the limited resources a team/player has on any given map. Having the battle rifle and the sniper rifle on the top of Coag bases forces teams to decide if one guy should be carrying both of those weapons, et cetera. It makes the battle rifle somewhat important. Giving everyone a battle rifle, makes Halo 2 a mid-range game, and diminishes the importance (not substantially, but somewhat) of the Rocket Launcher and Sniper Rifle.
Sure, I'd love to start off with the battle rifle, but it makes the acquisition of weapons and map control a little bit less important with Halo 2. The *best* weapons (the sword is outlawed in MLG, not sure about CAL) respawn on a timer AFTER they've been exhausted, i.e., the Beam Rifle on Colossus, Rockets on Coag, Snipers on Coag, et cetera. I'm obviously not going to point out what weapons respawn on timers and how to get multipler sniper rifles on a map, here, you guys can figure that out for yourselves.
So starting with the battle rifle adds a different element of strategy, but also diminshes other aspects of the game.
I don't even want to talk about all of the glitching and cheating we've started to see.
Patches.
Banning of XBL accounts, plz.