• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Android Hardware Thread - 2009 Edition

Status
Not open for further replies.
Damn, I've had my Motorola Q for over 3 years now, never went to shit on me nor did I feel like I wanted to upgrade. I love the phone and I'm having trouble parting. It runs Windows Mobile 5 and is pretty bare bones if you compare it to some of the phones out now. I'm gonna check out this Droid and only if I absolutely adore it will I get rid of my Q.
 
Damn that is impressive, wish it had a faster clock speed for the cpu, but other than that it looks great. Not since the bb storm, has verizon had a show case phone until now.

Anyone know if it will ship with a 8 - 16 gig hardrive? If google had a lot too say for this phone, I'd only make sense since you can't save apps on your sd card with android.
 
Totakeke said:
Droid looks sexy... in a old-fashioned way with its muted colors.

And tying in with that is the new color scheme the icons in Android 2.0 are featuring. It seems Google's going for a more relaxed, "light blue+light green" approach with the occasional dark yellow highlight. Very good choice of a color scheme.

gimmmick said:
Damn that is impressive, wish it had a faster clock speed for the cpu, but other than that it looks great. Not since the bb storm, has verizon had a show case phone until now.

Anyone know if it will ship with a 8 - 16 gig hardrive? If google had a lot too say for this phone, I'd only make sense since you can't save apps on your sd card with android.

We don't know for sure if 2.0 allows running apps from the SD card, (though I do believe you've always been able to save them there.)

The internal memory was confirmed by BGR to be 512 MB, with a 16 GB MicroSDHC card included in the retail box. I've forced myself to come up with a list of things I don't like about the Droid:

  1. For me, the d-pad is on the wrong side, but I'm sure I can adjust.
  2. The battery life needs to last at least a whole day with quite a fair bit of usage. With only a 1390 mAh powering it, I'm unsure of this.
  3. The internal memory, as mentioned, though it will be world's more tolerable if/when it can run apps from the SD card.

I think that's it... The rest is all gravy.

masud said:
So does the Droid have multi touch or not I keep hearing diffrent things.

It has multitouch, but not pinch-to-zoom.
 
Well, the Droid commercial piqued the interested of folks at the office. Showed them the new pics of the Droid, more interest.

I have a Verizon store downstairs, with a Sprint store across the street. Android is taking over!
 
Apparently Sony Ericsson thought the Rachael was so awesome and renamed it X10, that's a 8 generation leap folks!


Phandroid said:
You know the Sony Ericsson Xperia X3 that has been so fondly admired from afar? Name change. According to Tweakers.net (translated to English) a forum member with access to the phone and inside information from a Sony Ericsson employee says the phone will actually be called the Sony Ericsson Xperia X10 when it is launched the first 8 weeks in 2010.

http://phandroid.com/2009/10/19/sony-ericsson-xperia-x10-x3-renamed/
http://tweakers.net/nieuws/63164/sony-ericsson-xperia-x10-met-android-komt-begin-2010-uit.html


For this I can wait.
 
One thing i keep seeing is people complaining about the cpu speed on existing android devices. I am not saying I am a master in hardware or anything but I am currently doind my phd in the field of embedded systems security and have had a runin with quite a few cpus.


A 500 mhz processor is more than beefy enough to do amazing things. Its really about the software.

Also, we have not gotten battery tech good enough to support amazing procs. Yes we are now getting faster mobile procs but there are a lot of hardware tricks you can pull to make the battery stretch.

Knowing this, i had no problem jumping in for the htc hero. If you are on sprint and you want a nice phone that runs android, has an improved ui over base install android, and works very well then i say pick it up.
 
MThanded said:
One thing i keep seeing is people complaining about the cpu speed on existing android devices. I am not saying I am a master in hardware or anything but I am currently doind my phd in the field of embedded systems.

A 500 mhz processor is more than beefy enough to do amazing things. Its really about the software.

Also, we have not gotten battery tech good enough to support amazing procs. Yes we are now getting faster mobile procs but there are a lot of hardware tricks you can pull to make the battery stretch.

Knowing this, i had no problem jumping in for the htc hero.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ybs_MBhzrQ&feature=player_embedded

Also, look for videos of HD2, that thing runs on the very same windows mobile you love to hate, but that thing is ridiculously smooth in comparison.

Edit: Actually here you go. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WbZwURt7Gy0&feature=player_embedded#t=29m05s
 
Totakeke said:
like i said software. People have not been using pareto optimization and true embedded development on these devices. half of the programs are not designed correctly i know because i have seen some of the code lol.

You can get a faster processor so you can stream hd video and your battery will be destroyed fairly quickly.

I like the snapdragon though. Quallcom put some good hardware design knowledge into it.

Its also impossible to benchmark two phones with two different oses and two different applications. You cannot normalize anything.


Note: I am sort of a hypocrite because i am contemplating switching to the samsung moment for that 800 mhz processor. I am a sucker for faster stuff lol . not gonna lie man :lol :lol :lol


WHERE IS MY SAMSUNG MOMENT REVIEW???????
 
Andrex said:
  1. For me, the d-pad is on the wrong side, but I'm sure I can adjust.

I guess you'll be using the touchscreen most of the time, so that's not really a problem. Same goes for not ahving a number row.
 
i just looked at Verizon's plan. They charge you $10 a month to use the GPS. WTF. seriously? Don't other companies include GPS usage into their data plan, but verizon you gotta pay for it separately?

Anyone know if we'd need to purcahse vz navigator if we want to use the droid's GPS?
 
Hi guys, I'm really new to this Android stuff, and I have a couple of questions...
What is the best device that supports Android and has a qwerty keyboard? The one I like the most is the HTC G1, but I don't really know many other devices that have Android. Or are they better off without qwerty keyboards?

Also, is Windows Mobile better than Android? I once tried a WM phone (Moto Q, i think), and I hated it. It looks a hundred times better now, though.

EDIT: Just in case, I did read the OP.
 
Totakeke said:
Apparently Sony Ericsson thought the Rachael was so awesome and renamed it X10, that's a 8 generation leap folks!




http://phandroid.com/2009/10/19/sony-ericsson-xperia-x10-x3-renamed/
http://tweakers.net/nieuws/63164/sony-ericsson-xperia-x10-met-android-komt-begin-2010-uit.html


For this I can wait.

Maybe even sooner according to Engadgetmobile!

http://www.engadgetmobile.com/2009/10/18/curious-xperia-x3-tweet-by-ericsson-labs-makes-you-wonder/

SHE WILL BE MINE!
 
BlueMagic said:
Hi guys, I'm really new to this Android stuff, and I have a couple of questions...
What is the best device that supports Android and has a qwerty keyboard? The one I like the most is the HTC G1, but I don't really know many other devices that have Android. Or are they better off without qwerty keyboards?

Also, is Windows Mobile better than Android? I once tried a WM phone (Moto Q, i think), and I hated it. It looks a hundred times better now, though.

EDIT: Just in case, I did read the OP.

Qwerty keyboards are really based on your preference, if you intend to type a lot of stuffs, then definitely get one, otherwise it adds to the bulk of the phone for something only marginally useful. If you want qwerty with Android, wait and see how Droid pans out.

FunBoy said:

Yeah, that has been posted before, but that's just the announcement, not the release.
 
Tideas said:
i just looked at Verizon's plan. They charge you $10 a month to use the GPS. WTF. seriously? Don't other companies include GPS usage into their data plan, but verizon you gotta pay for it separately?

Anyone know if we'd need to purcahse vz navigator if we want to use the droid's GPS?

This is how Verizon cripples all their users on anything other than phone calls. To answer your question, I don't know and I don't think anyone does at the moment. I think everyone is waiting to see how much influence Android will have over the interface. So in other words:

Droid + Android OS = sex
Droid + Verizon's interface = lol
 
BlueMagic said:
Hi guys, I'm really new to this Android stuff, and I have a couple of questions...
What is the best device that supports Android and has a qwerty keyboard? The one I like the most is the HTC G1, but I don't really know many other devices that have Android. Or are they better off without qwerty keyboards?

Also, is Windows Mobile better than Android? I once tried a WM phone (Moto Q, i think), and I hated it. It looks a hundred times better now, though.

EDIT: Just in case, I did read the OP.

Motorola Cliq seems to be the number one contender in the hard keyboard space. We'll have to see how the Droid fares.

jasonng said:
This is how Verizon cripples all their users on anything other than phone calls. To answer your question, I don't know and I don't think anyone does at the moment. I think everyone is waiting to see how much influence Android will have over the interface. So in other words:

Droid + Android OS = sex
Droid + Verizon's interface = lol

The Verizon UI has only been applied to their dumbphones. All their WM and BB smartphones still use the standard OS, so I don't see where this argument is coming from. Furthermore, it has been repeatedly reported (and pictured) that the Droid is from a strong collaboration between Verizon and Google (and Motorola.) To think Google would let Verizon muss with the first public release of Android 2.0 is really... hrm... dumb.

PS- You have to pay for VZNavigator, but I'm pretty sure there's nothing Verizon can do about standard GPS.
 
Andrex said:
PS- You have to pay for VZNavigator, but I'm pretty sure there's nothing Verizon can do about standard GPS.

from what I've been reading, you have to use VZNavigator if you want to use the GPS. It locks out the GPS from using anything else.
 
ASUS Android smartphone unveiling 'this year'

by Thomas Ricker posted Oct 19th 2009

garmin-asus-06-03-09-android.jpg


It's short and sweet but we thought you'd like to hear the good news doled out by ASUS chairman Jonney Shih and CEO Jerry Shen at a local press meeting in Taiwan today. Shih says that the company's first Android phone will be "unveiled this year," not next as originally rumored. For a second, it makes you wonder what's going to happen to the OS underpinning the ASUS-Garmin nuvifone G60 -- then you remember that you weren't going to buy that phone anyway.

Manufacturers can't get enough of Android.
 
Tideas said:
from what I've been reading, you have to use VZNavigator if you want to use the GPS. It locks out the GPS from using anything else.

Well if you look in the Android 2.0 screenshots, there's the standard Google Maps app and no VZNavigator to be found.

Bluemercury said:
I thought this had two cpus, one at 600mhz and another for graphic capabilities....

It (the Droid) does. An ARM Cortex A8 600 MHz CPU and a PowerVR GPU.

Fatalah said:
Is it me or should Google hold a tradeshow just for feature the Android lineup? I can't keep up with all of this!

That's what this thread is for! I'm trying to make it as easy as possible to keep track, it's not easy you know!

SimleuqiR said:
Manufacturers can't get enough of Android.

That Garmin phone was supposed to be out like two years ago. I'll believe it when I see it.
 
Tideas said:
from what I've been reading, you have to use VZNavigator if you want to use the GPS. It locks out the GPS from using anything else.
Not true, I can use my Storm's built-in GPS with Google Maps perfectly fine and I don't pay anything for it.
 
MThanded said:
One thing i keep seeing is people complaining about the cpu speed on existing android devices. I am not saying I am a master in hardware or anything but I am currently doind my phd in the field of embedded systems security and have had a runin with quite a few cpus.


A 500 mhz processor is more than beefy enough to do amazing things. Its really about the software.

These Android phones are all running basically the same software (U/I enhancements aside). So the performance is all about the hardware.

Also, we have not gotten battery tech good enough to support amazing procs. Yes we are now getting faster mobile procs but there are a lot of hardware tricks you can pull to make the battery stretch.

Cortex has much higher IPC than ARM11 so you could get equivalent performance at lower clocks/voltage/power. Die size is larger, so static power is higher, but I'm better energy usage is better on the Cortex since the performance is so much higher at a given clock.
 
Tideas said:
i just looked at Verizon's plan. They charge you $10 a month to use the GPS. WTF. seriously? Don't other companies include GPS usage into their data plan, but verizon you gotta pay for it separately?

Anyone know if we'd need to purcahse vz navigator if we want to use the droid's GPS?

I haven't had the data plan for a few months now, but when I did, if you paid for unlimited data plan (my plan was about $100mo) GPS was free. They only charged you $10mo if you didn't have an unlimited data plan.
 
tokkun said:
These Android phones are all running basically the same software (U/I enhancements aside). So the performance is all about the hardware.

An equivalently clocked processor with android on one phone and windows mobile on another and android will perform better. No need to worry. Android seems to be a very nice RTOS code base. Moral of the story is, this current gen of devices is more than beefy to run android with all the bells and whistles.

G1's are still the current dev phone and anything with similar specs will still work great. The real time operating system class here is using g1s for all of their projects. Sadly I am not in the class this semester.

however..... there is one thing that worries me about all of this.....

It is weird to see android phones with beefier specs and an upgraded OS so close to all of these recently released devices. Is google going to segment their market or will we all be getting a new OS version. I would be pissed if my htc hero is outdated so soon. I am assuming that 2.0 has new api calls that devs can use. If they do segment the market then I suspect a lot of backlash.

I just got a 1.5 device that came out this same month and less than a month away a 2.0 device is coming out. Its not like android has hit full capacity in the US or anything. This is the first wave of phones and they are getting shuffled away very fast... As a consumer that is sort of disheartening :-/ . I have a 1st gen ipod touch and it still runs the majority of the apps on the app store(not all) but i expect that due to how long ago i got the device. The htc hero just came out in the US this damn month and i feel like its going to be an old device before the end of december.
 
This is a quote from Verizon's TOS regarding the data plan.
DATA PLANS AND FEATURES

Data Plans and Features (such as NationalAccess, BroadbandAccess, GlobalAccess, Push to Talk, and certain VZEmail services) may ONLY be used with wireless devices for the following purposes: (i) Internet browsing; (ii) email; and (iii) intranet access (including access to corporate intranets, email, and individual productivity applications like customer relationship management, sales force, and field service automation). The Data Plans and Features MAY NOT be used for any other purpose. Examples of prohibited uses include, without limitation, the following: (i) continuous uploading, downloading or streaming of audio or video programming or games; (ii) server devices or host computer applications, including, but not limited to, Web camera posts or broadcasts, automatic data feeds, automated machine-to-machine connections or peer-to-peer (P2P) file sharing; or (iii) as a substitute or backup for private lines or dedicated data connections. This means, by way of example only, that checking email, surfing the Internet, downloading legally acquired songs, and/or visiting corporate intranets is permitted, but downloading movies using P2P file sharing services and/or redirecting television signals for viewing on laptops is prohibited. A person engaged in prohibited uses, continuously for one hour, could typically use 100 to 200 MBs, or, if engaged in prohibited uses for 10 hours a day, 7 days a week, could use more than 5 GBs in a month.

I was wondering how this would come into play with the Droid doing something like a running a Pandora app all day at work or watching A LOT of youtube videos. Anyone who has a data plan with Verizon every run into any problems with this?
 
As nice as this Droid phone is looking, it's still made by Motorola, who has a rather poor reliability track record. LG seems to always be on top of Verizon's quality lists, and I'd love to hold out for their phone, but it's not on Verizon, right?
 
MThanded said:
It is weird to see android phones with beefier specs and an upgraded OS so close to all of these recently released devices. Is google going to segment their market or will we all be getting a new OS version. I would be pissed if my htc hero is outdated so soon. I am assuming that 2.0 has new api calls that devs can use. If they do segment the market then I suspect a lot of backlash.

The transition from ARM11 to ARM Cortex is really no different from what happened with the iPhone. The vast majority of the current installed base is running on the older processor (G1, Magic/MyTouch, Hero) so I expect developers will not try develop software that requires a faster processor for a while. Existing devices should eventually get Android 2.0 as well.

The thing that concerns me a lot more about market segmentation is the lack of standard interface buttons. For a while, everything had trackballs. Suddenly devices are coming out with d-pads and no trackball. Even the devices with d-pads can't decide if they should put them on the right or left side. It will become impossible to actually use those buttons for things like games.
 
tokkun said:
The transition from ARM11 to ARM Cortex is really no different from what happened with the iPhone. The vast majority of the current installed base is running on the older processor (G1, Magic/MyTouch, Hero) so I expect developers will not try develop software that requires a faster processor for a while. Existing devices should eventually get Android 2.0 as well.

The thing that concerns me a lot more about market segmentation is the lack of standard interface buttons. For a while, everything had trackballs. Suddenly devices are coming out with d-pads and no trackball. Even the devices with d-pads can't decide if they should put them on the right or left side. It will become impossible to actually use those buttons for things like games.

When i was looking at these devices that is one thing that worried me too.

I am still debating whether i will switch to the samsung moment November 1st. There was not been 1 review and launch is 11 days away. :-/
 
Iknos said:
n00b question: that thing on the right of the keyboard...is that some sort of touchscreen dpad or mouse?

It's actually a normal (button) d-pad cleverly disguised.

Wendo said:
As nice as this Droid phone is looking, it's still made by Motorola, who has a rather poor reliability track record. LG seems to always be on top of Verizon's quality lists, and I'd love to hold out for their phone, but it's not on Verizon, right?

Not that we know of as of yet.

tokkun said:
The transition from ARM11 to ARM Cortex is really no different from what happened with the iPhone. The vast majority of the current installed base is running on the older processor (G1, Magic/MyTouch, Hero) so I expect developers will not try develop software that requires a faster processor for a while. Existing devices should eventually get Android 2.0 as well.

The thing that concerns me a lot more about market segmentation is the lack of standard interface buttons. For a while, everything had trackballs. Suddenly devices are coming out with d-pads and no trackball. Even the devices with d-pads can't decide if they should put them on the right or left side. It will become impossible to actually use those buttons for things like games.

As a game semi-developer... I wouldn't really say it's a problem. For most games, the trackball an d-pad would remain functionally similar. The bigger issue is the keyboard on some devices; already, apps like emulators require hard keyboards (last time I checked.) It'll just require a couple minutes of thinking on the part of the developer to decide how the control scheme should be for the different devices.

Of course, if there's ever a non-touchscreen Android device...
 
After looking at some video previews on the moment i think i will stick with my hero. That little optical nub seems like a pain to use. In every video i saw it seemed like it did not work too well.They should have just thrown a trackball in there instead of that optical nub.

Also they showed the usb port on the moment and unlike the htc proprietary port it does not seem like it would fit a normal mini usb cable( i hope this is not true, if so that sucks). Still waiting for reviews though.
 
MThanded said:
After looking at some video previews on the moment i think i will stick with my hero. That little optical nub seems like a pain to use. In every video i saw it seemed like it did not work too well.They should have just thrown a trackball in there instead of that optical nub.

Also they showed the usb port on the moment and unlike the htc proprietary port it does not seem like it would fit a normal mini usb cable( i hope this is not true, if so that sucks). Still waiting for reviews though.

Many people, like myself, think a trackball + touchscreen is (1)ugly and (2)pointless. Samsung has the same mindset with the Moment, they hid the search button, made most of the buttons touch buttons and got rid of the trackball. I really can't justify a trackball on a touchscreen, I would never touch it and it would just annoy me. Just touch the screen.
 
jonnybryce said:
Many people, like myself, think a trackball + touchscreen is (1)ugly and (2)pointless. Samsung has the same mindset with the Moment, they hid the search button, made most of the buttons touch buttons and got rid of the trackball. I really can't justify a trackball on a touchscreen, I would never touch it and it would just annoy me. Just touch the screen.
Well i thought i wouldnt need a trackball because of the touchscreen but when you are on a website and there are a lot of links it makes it easier to go between them. the optical pad just seems like a pain i dunno. I am still holding out for a review. The htc hero trackball is far from ugly. Also that optical pad is far from good looking lol

samsung-Moment-Phone.jpg


dont see how the above looks better than the below

sprint_hero_08-thumb-330x465-25016.jpg


lol. The trackball is definitely more aesthetically pleasing.
 
yeah I definitely find the trackball easier for hitting links on a website. Sometimes it's even easier in doing menu selections, and means your hand can be lazy and just roll the trackball around instead of moving around the screen with your finger.
 
santouras said:
yeah I definitely find the trackball easier for hitting links on a website. Sometimes it's even easier in doing menu selections, and means your hand can be lazy and just roll the trackball around instead of moving around the screen with your finger.
yeah its really nice. I never owned a device with a trackball but i use it a lot on my hero. I am very used to using touch screen devices, ipod touch, touch pro but i think having a trackball really makes things a lot easier.

A lot of people have been complimenting the way the phone looks when the trackball is backlit.
20zbiux.jpg


I did not buy the device for its good looks but ill take that too :lol
 
MThanded said:
yeah its really nice. I never owned a device with a trackball but i use it a lot on my hero. I am very used to using touch screen devices, ipod touch, touch pro but i think having a trackball really makes things a lot easier.

A lot of people have been complimenting the way the phone looks when the trackball is backlit.
20zbiux.jpg


I did not buy the device for its good looks but ill take that too :lol

anyone complaining about the hero trackball hasn't seen or used it in person. it looks great and adds usability. definitely not a drawback at all.
 
Manmademan said:
anyone complaining about the hero trackball hasn't seen or used it in person. it looks great and adds usability. definitely not a drawback at all.

Yeah, it's not a fashion accessory it's a tool.

Then again, some of these tools think it's a fashion accessory.

I used a MyTouch last week and the trackball doodad was pretty nice. I prefer that to navigating a site and accidentally fucking "clicking" on shit. loliPhonelol
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom