BlackBuzzard
Banned
This is what caused an almost tie at day 1 btw.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Anime Mafia |OT| My Little Scum can't be this cute! ()
- Thread starter Burbeting
- Start date
This is what caused an almost tie at day 1 btw.
Dusk Soldier
Member
Only one kill? Did the scum team turn on Blargonaut-senshu?
Going to go re-read Haly-kun's posts now.
Going to go re-read Haly-kun's posts now.
Ugh, I'm sorry I missed the end of D2...had a post written up (was waiting for any scum shenanigans to go down before pre-emptively posting), and got stuck in traffic on the way home. 
What the hell happened at the end of D2? The reasoning on monkey was absolutely horrendous. So she got voted out because she wasted a vote? She's a new player. It was absolutely terrible reasoning when there were legitimate targets out there.
My read on the situation was this, and I'm really perplexed that no one else pointed this out at the end of day 2:
Posts/votes were flying all over the place while kyan was in the lead. Then squidy got in the lead, and suddenly it got quiet. It was so quiet with pretty much no movement happening even with only an hour to go. It's so painfully obvious that scum was happy where the votes were. I firmly believe squidy is town as a result.
Then after squidy's claim we got a little bit of movement. Squidy votes kyanrute. Then both squidy and kyan move to dusk. At this point palmer goes absolutely nuts and starts the lynch train against monkey. He was either trying to defend Kyan, Dusk, or both. So we have the 3 following possibilities:
1) Palmer + Kyan scum
2) Palmer + Dusk scum
3) Palmer + Kyan + Dusk scum
In any case, I believe Palmer to be scum absolutely. There's almost no doubt at this point.
Vote: Palmer[/vote]
And what the hell is this scummy as shit train against Poltergeist? Are you kidding me? You want a repeat of the monkey situation? This is either a scum driven train or the most misguided town I've ever played with. Sorry if I sound frustrated after the last day but I still can't believe you voted out monkey.
Along with Palmer/Kyan/Dusk, I'd like to add WMD is my fourth primary scum candidate. She was pushing hard against monkey early on, and she's been constantly accusing others of things that she's been guilty of all game (fluff posts, non-reads).
What the hell happened at the end of D2? The reasoning on monkey was absolutely horrendous. So she got voted out because she wasted a vote? She's a new player. It was absolutely terrible reasoning when there were legitimate targets out there.
My read on the situation was this, and I'm really perplexed that no one else pointed this out at the end of day 2:
Posts/votes were flying all over the place while kyan was in the lead. Then squidy got in the lead, and suddenly it got quiet. It was so quiet with pretty much no movement happening even with only an hour to go. It's so painfully obvious that scum was happy where the votes were. I firmly believe squidy is town as a result.
Then after squidy's claim we got a little bit of movement. Squidy votes kyanrute. Then both squidy and kyan move to dusk. At this point palmer goes absolutely nuts and starts the lynch train against monkey. He was either trying to defend Kyan, Dusk, or both. So we have the 3 following possibilities:
1) Palmer + Kyan scum
2) Palmer + Dusk scum
3) Palmer + Kyan + Dusk scum
In any case, I believe Palmer to be scum absolutely. There's almost no doubt at this point.
Vote: Palmer[/vote]
And what the hell is this scummy as shit train against Poltergeist? Are you kidding me? You want a repeat of the monkey situation? This is either a scum driven train or the most misguided town I've ever played with. Sorry if I sound frustrated after the last day but I still can't believe you voted out monkey.
Along with Palmer/Kyan/Dusk, I'd like to add WMD is my fourth primary scum candidate. She was pushing hard against monkey early on, and she's been constantly accusing others of things that she's been guilty of all game (fluff posts, non-reads).
BlackBuzzard
Banned
Hey be glad you are not the one who started the madness at the end of the day how you think i feel.
Dusk Soldier
Member
vote:Ultron87
Ultron87-kun, in your opinion, why do you think Haly-kun put the hammering vote on Zubz-senpai?
Ultron87-kun, in your opinion, why do you think Haly-kun put the hammering vote on Zubz-senpai?
Ugh, I'm sorry I missed the end of D2...had a post written up (was waiting for any scum shenanigans to go down before pre-emptively posting), and got stuck in traffic on the way home.
What the hell happened at the end of D2? The reasoning on monkey was absolutely horrendous. So she got voted out because she wasted a vote? She's a new player. It was absolutely terrible reasoning when there were legitimate targets out there.
My read on the situation was this, and I'm really perplexed that no one else pointed this out at the end of day 2:
Posts/votes were flying all over the place while kyan was in the lead. Then squidy got in the lead, and suddenly it got quiet. It was so quiet with pretty much no movement happening even with only an hour to go. It's so painfully obvious that scum was happy where the votes were. I firmly believe squidy is town as a result.
Then after squidy's claim we got a little bit of movement. Squidy votes kyanrute. Then both squidy and kyan move to dusk. At this point palmer goes absolutely nuts and starts the lynch train against monkey. He was either trying to defend Kyan, Dusk, or both. So we have the 3 following possibilities:
1) Palmer + Kyan scum
2) Palmer + Dusk scum
3) Palmer + Kyan + Dusk scum
In any case, I believe Palmer to be scum absolutely. There's almost no doubt at this point.
Vote: Palmer[/vote]
And what the hell is this scummy as shit train against Poltergeist? Are you kidding me? You want a repeat of the monkey situation? This is either a scum driven train or the most misguided town I've ever played with. Sorry if I sound frustrated after the last day but I still can't believe you voted out monkey.
Along with Palmer/Kyan/Dusk, I'd like to add WMD is my fourth primary scum candidate. She was pushing hard against monkey early on, and she's been constantly accusing others of things that she's been guilty of all game (fluff posts, non-reads).
I was absolutely not the one who started a monkey bandwagon. I was absolutely okay with lynching her though. I still think squidyj/bowlie are scum, but that shitshow of a day ruined what I really wanted. I'm in the middle of board games posting from phone which is making me even more scatterbrained right now. I'll post more later.
Monkey's wanted vote wasn't why I was after her anyway. It was the lack of firm stances on almost anything previous to that. Bowlie is the one I want gone for an entirely wasted d1 vote.
If squidyj flips scum at some point, town should absolutely remember this cover that exodus is providing.
Also, you have my name wrong.
Dusk Soldier
Member
Basically:
Scum team is Haly-kun/Blargonaut-senshu, Kyanrute, Ultron87-kun, dragon-chan, and possibly Palmer as a fifth member.
Cabot is town, and shares a secret chat with Kyanrute who is scum. They are Lovers and both will die if either is killed. Cabot is still in denial about Kyanrute's true nature.
I got a note last night that I'm part of someone's harem now. It didn't contain any other information. So that's probably some neutral thing.
He didn't care which of us died and wanted easy good town points for tie preventing.
He didn't care which of us died and wanted easy good town points for tie preventing.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
Dusk Soldier
Member
flatearthpandas
Member
Lol what a waster.
flatearthpandas
Member
Seriously i was town reading you basically for trying, Palmer. The "f for effort" basically. But you spent an entire day phase and you don't even know who the fuck you're blindly targeting still. Get fucked. This is the most lazy shit I've seen in this game and i had the misfortune of playing gafia 3.
Vote: palmer_v1
Call it omgus if you want but your sheer fucking blind stupidity is something i don't have patience for. Pay attention or get fucked, seriously. After you're lynched, I'm going after inactives. I didn't sign up to waste hours of my time on people who know better. The new players are all more with it than you. Stanley was more with it than you before he got replaced. I have no patience at all for vets wasting my time. If you can't pull your head out of your ass you're​ just policy at this point. Start playing.
Vote: palmer_v1
Call it omgus if you want but your sheer fucking blind stupidity is something i don't have patience for. Pay attention or get fucked, seriously. After you're lynched, I'm going after inactives. I didn't sign up to waste hours of my time on people who know better. The new players are all more with it than you. Stanley was more with it than you before he got replaced. I have no patience at all for vets wasting my time. If you can't pull your head out of your ass you're​ just policy at this point. Start playing.
This is the first time I've heard you explicitly say this. Why are you sure Kyan is scum and Cabot is town? Is it because of your interactions with them on D2? I know you and Cabot got into some heated discussion, especially regarding Kyan. Cabot voted for Kyan once but also mentioned that it wasn't going to be his day end vote. Interesting.
Poltergust
Member
I'm really concerned about the votes being done to me considering what happened going into yesterday's vote. That was an awful bandwagon onto hey_monkey and I'm glad she was just a regular townie instead of a PR.
I feel like we had at least one of the Mafia members up on the chopping block which prompted that vote for hey_monkey. That was waaaaay too coordinated to have been anything else. I think we threw that one away for no good reason.
My suspicion primarily falls onto Kyanrute and Dragonz, who are now 2/2 in voting for town to get lynched.
That said, I'm glad the night phase went well. I'm really interested in seeing what happened when the game is over.
And without further ado...
Vote: Kyanrute
I feel like we had at least one of the Mafia members up on the chopping block which prompted that vote for hey_monkey. That was waaaaay too coordinated to have been anything else. I think we threw that one away for no good reason.
My suspicion primarily falls onto Kyanrute and Dragonz, who are now 2/2 in voting for town to get lynched.
That said, I'm glad the night phase went well. I'm really interested in seeing what happened when the game is over.
And without further ado...
Vote: Kyanrute
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
DAY 3 CURRENT VOTE TALLY:
Poltergust (5)
Swamped 1745
squidyj 1746
BlackBuzzard 1747
WhereAreMahDragonz 1748
rac 1759
Kyanrute (2)
Dusk Soldier 1765
Poltergust 1770
Palmer_v1 (2)
TheExodu5 1756
flatearthpandas 1768
ultron87 (0):Dusk Soldier 1760 1765
No active vote for Day 3: 30yearsofhurt, cabot, Cewyn, hatmoza, Kawl_USC, Kyanrute, oreomunsta, Palmer_v1, ultron87
Day 3 Postcount: 30yearsofhurt 0, BlackBuzzard 8, cabot 2, Cewyn 0, Dusk Soldier 4, flatearthpandas 2, hatmoza 0, Kawl_USC 1, Kyanrute 0, oreomunsta 0, Palmer_v1 3, Poltergust 1, rac 1, squidyj 2, Swamped 3, TheExodu5 2, ultron87 1, WhereAreMahDragonz 5
Day 3 ends:
Automated vote tally here
10 votes for majority
Poltergust (5)
Swamped 1745
squidyj 1746
BlackBuzzard 1747
WhereAreMahDragonz 1748
rac 1759
Kyanrute (2)
Dusk Soldier 1765
Poltergust 1770
Palmer_v1 (2)
TheExodu5 1756
flatearthpandas 1768
ultron87 (0):
No active vote for Day 3: 30yearsofhurt, cabot, Cewyn, hatmoza, Kawl_USC, Kyanrute, oreomunsta, Palmer_v1, ultron87
Day 3 Postcount: 30yearsofhurt 0, BlackBuzzard 8, cabot 2, Cewyn 0, Dusk Soldier 4, flatearthpandas 2, hatmoza 0, Kawl_USC 1, Kyanrute 0, oreomunsta 0, Palmer_v1 3, Poltergust 1, rac 1, squidyj 2, Swamped 3, TheExodu5 2, ultron87 1, WhereAreMahDragonz 5
Day 3 ends:
Automated vote tally here
10 votes for majority
Uh, got it wrong again.
Vote: Palmer_v1
You know, I'm not buying it Palmer. Especially all the "if I die remember this" messages. Fluff to make it seem like you're genuine town.
Definitely doesn't make Ultron look good. I was somewhat confident in a Kyan/Ultron scum duo. That being said, looks like Palmer may have saved you as well, so I'm not confident about you either.
I agree it was way too coordinated and last minute. There was far too big of a silence beforehand when votes were on squidy.
What are your thoughts on:
Palmer
Dusk
Ultron
Vote: Palmer_v1
You know, I'm not buying it Palmer. Especially all the "if I die remember this" messages. Fluff to make it seem like you're genuine town.
Definitely doesn't make Ultron look good. I was somewhat confident in a Kyan/Ultron scum duo. That being said, looks like Palmer may have saved you as well, so I'm not confident about you either.
I agree it was way too coordinated and last minute. There was far too big of a silence beforehand when votes were on squidy.
What are your thoughts on:
Palmer
Dusk
Ultron
so where are you getting this from?
Okay, so I completely missed this post.
Come on, we need more details than that. You've been alluding to a cabot secret chat since day 1. Now you reveal it's with kyan. Where is this coming from?
Poltergust
Member
I used to think Palmer is town. I thought he tried to actively contribute to helping find scum even if his opinions on who scum is is misplaced. Throughout the game I haven't really noticed anything out of the ordinary with him (although I didn't notice anything weird with Haly, either)... until the last vote happened. Obviously, not everyone who voted for hey_monkey is scum, but this still doesn't put him in a good light.
Dusk is probably town, but he makes some really weird observations sometimes. That said, it's nice to see someone trying to think outside the box. I agree with him on most of his scum picks, too.
Ultron... I have no idea. I still am not sure I believe his revealed role. I think there are more likely candidates for us to focus on for today, at least. He also didn't jump on the hey_monkey bandwagon when he had all the opportunity to.
Zero substance here. I wasted a whole phase on squidyj thanks to town flipping at the last goddamn minute. I'll happily die today if town promises to go after you and squidyj after they see my flip. I just feel bad squidyj got stuck with flakey teammates at the start, though you are at least making a strong start after the replacement.
Scum team is you, Oreo, squidyj, dead haly, and I'm not sure after that. I've posted why for two of you but I'll make my Oreo post later.
Dusk Soldier
Member
All I can say about that is that it doesn't make sense for scum to swing the votes to me, only to swing them to monkey-chan 5 minutes later.
Dusk Soldier
Member
Let's give them a chance to explain themselves, and why they didn't come forward when I asked point blank.
30yearsofhurt
Member
Of the three I was most sus about we have to choose between polt and kyan.
For now I will vote Kyan but am willing to change to Polt.
vote: Kyanrute
For now I will vote Kyan but am willing to change to Polt.
vote: Kyanrute
Kyan is town and Cabbie is a filthy cop enabler, I could never love him.
Poltergust
Member
Well, if the current vote against me goes through, you two will be 3/3. =P
Why did you vote for hey_monkey when her vote for me was completely harmless by itself?
Her vote was meaningless, like I somewhat implied in caps.
i guess one could call it
wait for it
waaaaaiiiiit for iiiiiiittttt
fluff
Dusk, you've been speculating about the mysterious chat since d1. What is this about? Why is it worth discussing? Your implication that I am scum makes me think that you are worried about mixed alignment chats, but that's been your implication since d1 and I find it difficult to believe that you could have concrete information to prove mixed alignments and the existence of the chat in the 1st place at that point. The evidence, please.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
So? Do you honestly believe a scum player would be on a mislynch twice in a row?
Poltergust
Member
If it was necessary to save one of their own, then sure.
how cute it's two scum fighting.
Who was being saved on day one and how did you come to this conclusion? Who was being saved on day two and how did you come to this conclusion?
Poltergust
Member
Another point I want to bring up: What has changed between the last vote and now that would have gotten people to vote for me over their previous votes?
For example, Dragonz, why did you vote for me just now instead of Dusk Soldier, who had your vote up until you switched it over to hey_monkey?
I just find it peculiar because the only person who voted for me last day phase was hey_dragon, and now all these votes are coming up rapidly.
For example, Dragonz, why did you vote for me just now instead of Dusk Soldier, who had your vote up until you switched it over to hey_monkey?
I just find it peculiar because the only person who voted for me last day phase was hey_dragon, and now all these votes are coming up rapidly.
Poltergust
Member
Day one didn't necessarily need a scum save, and I wasn't referring to day one in my argument anyways.
As for day two, that was you, I'm pretty sure. There's no way I can believe that the vote against hey_dragon was completely spontaneous. It happened too quickly and with little justification. You can't even use the "fluff" excuse here because that's all people have accused her of doing up until she was lynched, yet she only received votes going into the last 10 minutes.
Now, it's possible that they were trying to save someone else who was close to being lynched, but my suspicion primarily falls onto you due to previous arguments.
Now, would it be worth it for scum to risk exposing themselves to save another? If there is a PR on the chopping block, I would say that is a strong possibility.
-20: 5-4-3 Dusk, squid, Kyan
-12: 5-5-3 Dusk squid, Kyan
-11: 6-5-3 Dusk, squid, Kyan
-7: 6-5-4 Dusk, squid, Kyan
And then within the final seven minutes, monkey becomes the lynched.
If scum were worried about me, their beloved dear Kyan, being lynched, why did we prop up a completely new lynch to save me when we could've pushed one of the alternatives?
And I know Polter you want to say that "Well, maybe the alternatives had scum there too!" but that is kinda late now. Your argument was that I was being saved, not that multiple scum were under a threat.
-12: 5-5-3 Dusk squid, Kyan
-11: 6-5-3 Dusk, squid, Kyan
-7: 6-5-4 Dusk, squid, Kyan
And then within the final seven minutes, monkey becomes the lynched.
If scum were worried about me, their beloved dear Kyan, being lynched, why did we prop up a completely new lynch to save me when we could've pushed one of the alternatives?
And I know Polter you want to say that "Well, maybe the alternatives had scum there too!" but that is kinda late now. Your argument was that I was being saved, not that multiple scum were under a threat.
New day, new lie.
Tell me who do you fully trust on Day 2?
a startling instinct that lasted six minutes.
Swamped you seem to believe Dusk a lot more than me which makes absolutely no sense considering theres no evidence backing him up and he's suggesting an unorthodox take on a traditional role.
Why?
I think you and Dusk could be in a scum team together.
I have a theory that leans on this being a vigi (though SK isn't impossible), but it wouldn't be particularly wise to say it at this point.