who are you talking to
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Bar MAFIA |OT| There's Gonna Be Shots
- Thread starter Kawl_USC
- Start date
Wheresmahdragonz she just voted hyper
That's a good post Dragonz. It hasn't convinced me you're not scummy, but it's definitely convinced me that we should wait on lynching you and lynch an inactive instead. You're response to my post seemed honest (although maybe I'm just being naive this time) and it's all pretty consistent with what you'e posted before. So I'll unvote.
Unvote: Wherearemahdragonz
I can see that. With so many inactives I feel like we have to do something right? What everyone's doing now obviously isn't working. If I had to pick an inactive I'd vote Dust, I've said before I didn't like his opening posts and his general lack of activity despite the fact it seems like he's reading the thread is suspect to me.
Unvote: Wherearemahdragonz
I can see that. With so many inactives I feel like we have to do something right? What everyone's doing now obviously isn't working. If I had to pick an inactive I'd vote Dust, I've said before I didn't like his opening posts and his general lack of activity despite the fact it seems like he's reading the thread is suspect to me.
Are you on board for a euphemism lynch from that one post?
sure why not
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
I voted hyper because I think he's scum. This isn't a political play.
Yes but your vote is a ripple and I want to see if we can work together to make waves. Who else would you vote?
Dusk Soldier
Member
It's ok, I didn't want to correct you in case you voted for me lol.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
What?
No just bored and trying to make the game move faster.
Are you high
timetokill
Banned
Oh, Catvoca. Very disappointing and suspicious activity. To vote someone and then pull it immediately after a rant like Dragonz just posted, after you made such a good case.
Dragonz, the whole reason I didn't mention you sooner is because I didn't want to bandwagon you and do scum's work for them. But honestly you've been kind of suspicious and after Catvoca made that case, I figured it was time to throw down a vote.
I'm not sure how it'd be considered a weak vote. When I voted Stackpole I gave my reasons, just as I did for you. It wasn't an idle threat, and as such you're keeping my vote until somebody else gains more suspicion from me, like maybe Catvoca who folded his vote like a cheap lawn chair in a summer breeze.
...
Also where the fuck is Tar-Miriel? I ordered this martini for her hours ago! Now it's getting all warm and who knows who's been sipping it.
Dragonz, the whole reason I didn't mention you sooner is because I didn't want to bandwagon you and do scum's work for them. But honestly you've been kind of suspicious and after Catvoca made that case, I figured it was time to throw down a vote.
I'm not sure how it'd be considered a weak vote. When I voted Stackpole I gave my reasons, just as I did for you. It wasn't an idle threat, and as such you're keeping my vote until somebody else gains more suspicion from me, like maybe Catvoca who folded his vote like a cheap lawn chair in a summer breeze.
...
Also where the fuck is Tar-Miriel? I ordered this martini for her hours ago! Now it's getting all warm and who knows who's been sipping it.
no
but
compared to the other inactive he suddenly has had a lot less pressure
i got a feeling
that tonight's gonna be a good night
After you do that let's you, me, cat, and kitty all vote dusk and see what happens. I think he's around.
timetokill
Banned
Wow sorry Ouro I guess I should post nonsense half sentences to get my post count up
timetokill
Banned
is this a good one
I mean I still think Dragonz has acted scummy, I just think it's more productive right now to put pressure on less-active posters. If Dragonz is lynched and ends up flipping town it sucks since she's really trying to post and could be helpful to town. If Euphmism or Dusk or Matty flips town it doesn't really impact us, and there's about as much chance as them flipping scum as Dragonz no matter what my D1 reads are. Andsas I said, there was something about her response to me that seemed honest, and she was actually remarkably consistent based on her previous thoughts. I feel like scum might be more defensive or start changing their story a little when put under pressure but she was solid as a rock.
Who's cat? And it seems like you keep moving back and forth on people. Trying to start a bandwagon, huh.
Yeah, you're doing great.
maybe
but you'd be the only one
new scum list
timetokill
retroid
kyanrute
mattyg
you're off the hook for now batsnacks
still reading
*ahem*
There are a few people I'm fine with voting. I think a bandwagon would be really useful right now to get some actual pressure and defenses going.
catvoca said he would vote dusk. So did ouro, and kingkitty is already voting him.
timetokill
Banned
Haha, holy shit, after some people mentioned euphemism I did a little back reading, and he's been invisible. three goddamn posts, and only one barely any substance.
I did find it funny that this was posted:
I did find it funny that this was posted:
...and Euphemism didn't post for nearly a whole 24 hours from that point. Case closed!
Dusk Soldier
Member
?
Why do you keep lumping me in with the low-activity posters, when players like Stackpole, tomakas, Barry, and Retroid are MIA?
timetokill is new
I think this is how Retroid plays every game especially the no lynch stuff.
I would rather make some progress on the more talked about people so that we can either find reasons to move on or lynch them and move on that way.
It feels like you're never involved in the discussion here. You had you're posts with Hyper and then it's mostly fluff. Like there's been a decent amount happening these last few pages and you don't comment on any of that. I think that's low activity. Maybe I should stop lumping you in with the people who have posted nothing recently though, you are a little different to those, you're not MIA.
timetokill
Banned
Dusk Soldier
Member
I personally try not to get too invested the Day1 #scumhunt.
If pretty much never leads to scum getting lynched, and most of our discourse is going to be thrown out the window 12 hours before the deadline when everyone suddenly notices how much AbsolutBro has flown under the radar.
This is the kind of thinking that is why we should be saving ourselves for today. If we are going to be killing someone today, the reasoning probably won't be great and there probably won't be great reasoning to not kill them. The only thing stopping people today is the thought that if someone posted a lot today, they are probably worth saving which I think is kind of silly. If we are going through with this, for me it would have to be between Ourobolus and TheExodu5. Both are at opposite ends of the spectrum when it comes to their actions today. I also think Ourobolus could become a burden to myself down the line as our play styles don't exactly match.
lmao.
ok so last night i was roleplaying a bit *hic* so i realized that i probably didn't read everything as thoroughly as i should have. decided to go back and take another look
so apologies if i am rehashing old arguments
====1. In Which We Discuss if it Should be "IIII" or "IV" on a Clock====
originally i didn't like that timetokill suddenly stopped being a major topic of discussion, despite us talking about all of the "inactives"
granted, he's not the most inactive or anything, but it felt strange, so i started with that and went back to read. he give his first vote on stackpoleh under the guise of "randomness," which I've never been a fan of
. If timetokill ever flips scum, I'm gonna take a look a bit harder at stackpoleh, and vice-versa (although stackpoleh gets a thumbs-up for an alice and bob reference)
====2. Nostalgioid for Retroid====
i kinda forgot about retroid's adamant stance on no-lynching and how he's arguing that we can get information by doing so. now this is a bit of WIFOM but retroid knows that no lynching is more of a townie statement (in theory - i mean, what if you hit town? gasp) and he also should be aware of how silly his stance is. i don't like it.
he also is uncomfortable with my playstyle
what playstyle
sickreads and awesomeness are not a playstyle
it's a way of life
also he was on a team with blarg before, so i'm assuming we aren't on the same team here
this is just weird. like, what is #3 even supposed to mean
if we lynch someone today we have a chance to hit scum
if we don't lynch someone today we have no chance to hit scum
statistics boiiiiii
====3. Why Ya Gotta be so Rute? Don't You Know I'm Townie Toooooo====
i don't really get his reads list. it's mostly about activity levels, which, sure, fine, it's a day one reads list. but there's not a whole lot of substance there within those words
also has a ridiculous theory about me and hyper being scumbuddies
as if
i'll admit that kyan is really more of a hunch from me, but he's giving me pause and despite it being a gut thing at this point, i'll keep poring over his posts for now
so apologies if i am rehashing old arguments
====1. In Which We Discuss if it Should be "IIII" or "IV" on a Clock====
originally i didn't like that timetokill suddenly stopped being a major topic of discussion, despite us talking about all of the "inactives"
granted, he's not the most inactive or anything, but it felt strange, so i started with that and went back to read. he give his first vote on stackpoleh under the guise of "randomness," which I've never been a fan of
high-five!
====2. Nostalgioid for Retroid====
i kinda forgot about retroid's adamant stance on no-lynching and how he's arguing that we can get information by doing so. now this is a bit of WIFOM but retroid knows that no lynching is more of a townie statement (in theory - i mean, what if you hit town? gasp) and he also should be aware of how silly his stance is. i don't like it.
he also is uncomfortable with my playstyle
what playstyle
sickreads and awesomeness are not a playstyle
it's a way of life
also he was on a team with blarg before, so i'm assuming we aren't on the same team here
this is just weird. like, what is #3 even supposed to mean
if we lynch someone today we have a chance to hit scum
if we don't lynch someone today we have no chance to hit scum
statistics boiiiiii
====3. Why Ya Gotta be so Rute? Don't You Know I'm Townie Toooooo====
i don't really get his reads list. it's mostly about activity levels, which, sure, fine, it's a day one reads list. but there's not a whole lot of substance there within those words
also has a ridiculous theory about me and hyper being scumbuddies
as if
i'll admit that kyan is really more of a hunch from me, but he's giving me pause and despite it being a gut thing at this point, i'll keep poring over his posts for now
I'm not sure if that is true. In my first game my stance on day one left me with a lot of problems. Most people do like to kill on the first day.
i really don't think we can use a shred of what happened in harry potter as a barometer for...well pretty much anything
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
Hi
Tar-Miriel
Banned
Ok guys, sorry i'm LTTP. I will post more tomorrow when i finish reading all these pages. Got through about 7 this afternoon but it was so nice outside i had to take a break. Also i hope there is no carding in this bar because you might find i'd have to to thrown out. (this is not in fact a mafia related metaphor but just a true fact)
Anyway, lovely to be here with you all and i shall be back soon.
Anyway, lovely to be here with you all and i shall be back soon.