Barrylocke
Member
No comment. Go town go.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Bar MAFIA |OT| There's Gonna Be Shots
- Thread starter Kawl_USC
- Start date
Lone_Prodigy
Member
So CB gave his last ID to Dusk and then ignited him, bats, and Barry?
Are there any previous night deaths that could account for Barry's shot?
I'm surprised scum didn't go for TTK, our tracker.
bats was a lost partner so it would be interesting to see who he avoided talking about.
Are there any previous night deaths that could account for Barry's shot?
I'm surprised scum didn't go for TTK, our tracker.
bats was a lost partner so it would be interesting to see who he avoided talking about.
timetokill
Banned
Holy shit :O
Yeah, yeah ~ a lot of people died, big whoop, what a surprise. Let's focus on the details of yesterday.
Nin forced a tie (even though I don't think it was intentionally, he never wanted me dead and was always going to vote corn).
TTK you changed your vote without any reason. Why did you do this 1 minute before deadline?
And... hey, remember what I said? Eh?
BATS WAS SCUM!
Our D1 vote list looks far better, and do you remember who argued against my logic? Motherf'n scumnacks.
He was also by far the only one to put some effort into an argument against me. Barry provided his reasons. Both didn't vote me.
Timeaisis came 2 hours before the bell to justify his vote. No one else provided any sustainable reason against me.
Salva, (Dusk), Matty, Retroid and TTK. I have yet to see proof of my bandwaggony behaviour you all deemed worthy killing me for. I have a proven useless power and nobody cares.
12 players left
9 town
3 scum
We can pull this.
TTK do you have any info for us? Or shall I announce my night target myself?
My gut feeling is still with timeaisis. If toma is scum and wins this game I'm retiring from mafia for good. No vote on 3 consecutive games and still not replaced.
Nin forced a tie (even though I don't think it was intentionally, he never wanted me dead and was always going to vote corn).
TTK you changed your vote without any reason. Why did you do this 1 minute before deadline?
And... hey, remember what I said? Eh?
BATS WAS SCUM!
Our D1 vote list looks far better, and do you remember who argued against my logic? Motherf'n scumnacks.
He was also by far the only one to put some effort into an argument against me. Barry provided his reasons. Both didn't vote me.
Timeaisis came 2 hours before the bell to justify his vote. No one else provided any sustainable reason against me.
Salva, (Dusk), Matty, Retroid and TTK. I have yet to see proof of my bandwaggony behaviour you all deemed worthy killing me for. I have a proven useless power and nobody cares.
12 players left
9 town
3 scum
We can pull this.
TTK do you have any info for us? Or shall I announce my night target myself?
My gut feeling is still with timeaisis. If toma is scum and wins this game I'm retiring from mafia for good. No vote on 3 consecutive games and still not replaced.
I'm not so sure about this anymore.
timetokill
Banned
I switched last second "without reason" because the clock was ticking and I didn't have time to explain. Ultimately I didn't want a no lynch, which is something I've been against from the start. Unfortunately nin made it happen anyway. I would've preferred CornBurrito get lynched, and it would've saved us trading two town for a minor scum.
Also, I didn't track you Gorlak, either night. I tracked somebody else that I was suspicious of. Two nights ago it was Lone_Prodigy. Last night, well, I'm not saying just yet.
Also, I didn't track you Gorlak, either night. I tracked somebody else that I was suspicious of. Two nights ago it was Lone_Prodigy. Last night, well, I'm not saying just yet.
We'd never have gotten batsnacks if he were still alive.
And I gave my drink to timeaisis last night. It's time for you all to realize that I'm town. My drinks don't hurt anyone, the neutral arsonist is dead. Three people I gave my drink to are still alive.
Lone_Prodigy
Member
You think TTK is tracker scum who threw WAMD under the bus?
Scum killed Exo even though it was unclear what his role was. Crab died, he too claimed to have more. And now it seems that scum were afraid of CB's fake claim or thought he was an arsonist. If somebody hints that they have a role that could hurt scum, they get killed by scum.
Why is ttk alive still?
Why is ttk alive still?
Why would he need a tracker power in that case? The lack of info fueled my doubts, was thinking about an x-shot possibility as well(similar to crab, gaining attraction and being killed, after deliviring). It may be a bit unlike but not impossible.
Anyway for now we should focus on other people.
Dusk Soldier
Member
spec thread, scum chat please
He didn't provide anything yesterday. Don't you think Corn was the bigger threat to scum?
What do you think of Salvapot?
As the patrons stared into the great abyss, an existential crisis building hastily within them all due to the dwindling numbers, a voice could be heard going through all their heads. Telepathic communication? why didn't you have that power?
even in death, no one had a clue what the hell he was on about....
Dusk Soldier said:
even in death, no one had a clue what the hell he was on about....
Hyperactivity
Banned
A. Can I get dead thread?
B. Does this count as a win for me? Cuz I got the neutral/scum/town trifecta now.
C. Fuck yeah 1 of my night actions was good
D. Look at my avatar. It's a molotov cocktail. I swear to god, I had this avatar before I got this role
E. Kingkitty burns me as the gossip arsonist in werewolf 2. Kingkitty and I are lovers in Love Boat. Kingkitty is my role in GAFIA 2. Kk and I are the cop and forger in this game
B. Does this count as a win for me? Cuz I got the neutral/scum/town trifecta now.
C. Fuck yeah 1 of my night actions was good
D. Look at my avatar. It's a molotov cocktail. I swear to god, I had this avatar before I got this role
E. Kingkitty burns me as the gossip arsonist in werewolf 2. Kingkitty and I are lovers in Love Boat. Kingkitty is my role in GAFIA 2. Kk and I are the cop and forger in this game
Cb won the game. You sucked.
Yesterday CB was the one scum were the most afraid, you are right. The fact that only three died makes this rather likely. I was thinking about the overall way scum seem to be using their night kills: killing power roles that threaten them. ttk essentially killed dragonz and could do more if he hits the correct player. Why do they let a clear threat live when they've killed people for less? They had their moment of vengeance on night three but went with Crab.
It is not enough in my opinion but it is very strange if he is alive tomorrow. Oh and ttk, could we get the tracking result today instead of waiting for tomorrow please? If you wanna bait someone to say something contradictory, you might wanna get on with it.
For the second part I went over Salva's posts because he claimed that he had posted actual serious posts. The claim was strange in my opinion but this is what I found. For the record, Salva's final votes are Ouro/Ouro/Gorlak/Gorlak.
Day one is a feel and I don't think anything can be drawn from it. It could be either way, a perfectly normal town misread or a scum saying random things.
Day two the feel continues. Ouro's lynch in general was a shitshow in my opinion and I have to go back and look at the votes once again after this. The feeling itself does not look that bad, but the fact that nobody really offered more than feels is scummy. The whole train offered very little in terms of reasons for voting Ouro and when asked about this, iirc, of all the Ouro voters, only Barrylocke bothered to answer. He flipped town. Of course, saying nothing fits Salva's general playstyle of shitpostimus maximus: if you say nothing, nothing can be used against you.
Day three "reasoning" is just scummy.
It takes some nights for Salva to explain his reasoning. And it actually makes sense, since Gorlak's reads hadn't been that marvelous up to that point. I think he is even the first to bring up the discussion point, so he is not parroting either. Some #townpoints there, but when I ask for Team Kill Gorlak to explain what they think about Gorlak's role, only Salva answers, and with a shitpost.
One post a day is not enough for anything but to appear present. I want to reflect Salva against others on the Ouro train 1st before voting but if I had to go with the feel I have now, I'd lean scum.
Never Forever
Member
hey sisters
I'm still catching up in between daily life but I didn't realise the phases are shorter going into this day so I thought I'd have more time
if you want me to actually contribute anything of worth before the day's end, I'll have to actually do some reading, there's no way I can scumhunt without doing that tbh
I'm still catching up in between daily life but I didn't realise the phases are shorter going into this day so I thought I'd have more time
if you want me to actually contribute anything of worth before the day's end, I'll have to actually do some reading, there's no way I can scumhunt without doing that tbh
None of that proves you're town nor proves that the drinks have no other effect.
What is the effect then? Two additional killing roles have been revealed now, the jailer and the arsonist. Surely we can expect that there are no more.
Could be just about anything honestly, as you say another kill related mechanic is unlikely but just because there's no apparent effect doesn't mean there isn't any effect. His story could absolutely be true but it is also in no way proven yet by current known information.
Lone_Prodigy
Member
So the Gorlak wagon is dead because he can't possibly be a second arsonist? Is that the excuse you're going with here for voting him in the first place? Okay.
try harder kid. this move sure is one of your worst lol.
"Yesterday's nonsense" he says lol dont mate me laugh.
my track record is clean.
Even if you try to throw those pitiful eggs at me, my vest will still be clean.
What is bizarre with my soft claim ? I mean if you would stop for a second in order to think you would realize that you are indeed on the wrong track.
But.. and here it comes i can understand that you will never ever say that you were wrong about me. I doubt it since no one wants to say that nin is right.
that one single vote wont even bother me mate.
I've seen worse.
Openly claiming any level of night kill immunity is a very strange thing to do.
Just take your time hermano.
timetokill
Banned
Ehhhhh, except I had good evidence on dragonz, (the only main scum we've gotten by the way... you're welcome) and I've been forthright on what I've done so far.
At any rate, scum will probably kill me tonight unless another player makes himself an even bigger target like CornBro did yesterday. I'm not sure why you are so desperate to do their work for them.
timetokill
Banned
Oh and PS Lone_Prodigy didn't go anywhere two nights ago. Of course one night doesn't prove much, he could still be scum, but still.
The thingis , i expected you to die sevral nights ago yet you did not.
Shall i give you another night ?
i guess yeah since you are being sincere.
UNVOTE
One additional thing to consider: since scum seemingly went for CB with their night kill, shouldn't it be expected that the night kill was the plan B? The plan A would've been to get CB lynched during the day. In the end, while the outcome was somewhat all right to scum (-1+vigi+confirmed townie), there is no way that scum would've known that this would be the end result of CB surviving. Thus I believe that there should be at least one scum, likely not more since scum like to spread the votes, on the CB lynch.
Don't be like this bae.
So who pushed against me yesterday again?
I want to highlight this post by Barrylocke. Wrong reasons all over his post. And he was convinced by bats to not vote me, after Bats put huge effort in discrediting me anyway.
Guess what Timeaisis. I fight for my logic because this is who I am. Would I have looked for this confrontation if I was scum? Wouldn't scum keep quiet and .. kill Crab at night, like what happened? Like what you did? Defending myself is scummy. Ah yeah.
This leaves Salva, Matty, Retroid and TTK who voted me for bandwaggoning...
Salva changed his opinion today just because.
Matty doesn't play the game.
NF catches up.
Nice.
Yesterday I asked for some reads:
Dusk+reasons, mine, Mazre, Nin, Kyan
Some more reads today would be very welcome!
If we as town want to win this game, we have to be more productive. Please try to engage more in conversations. Say who you think is scummy, try to find a contradiction and look at the votes. I want to win this game, let's do this!
I want to highlight this post by Barrylocke. Wrong reasons all over his post. And he was convinced by bats to not vote me, after Bats put huge effort in discrediting me anyway.
Guess what Timeaisis. I fight for my logic because this is who I am. Would I have looked for this confrontation if I was scum? Wouldn't scum keep quiet and .. kill Crab at night, like what happened? Like what you did? Defending myself is scummy. Ah yeah.
This leaves Salva, Matty, Retroid and TTK who voted me for bandwaggoning...
Salva changed his opinion today just because.
Matty doesn't play the game.
NF catches up.
Nice.
Yesterday I asked for some reads:
Dusk+reasons, mine, Mazre, Nin, Kyan
Some more reads today would be very welcome!
If we as town want to win this game, we have to be more productive. Please try to engage more in conversations. Say who you think is scummy, try to find a contradiction and look at the votes. I want to win this game, let's do this!
I can support to vote out the following players.
Tkk, Timeaisis, Matty and Salva.
Mazre is confused kid. Catvoca had me as town and I read him as such but Mazre is just playing bad all along. So I might vote him out in the following days. No need for such a bad player
What exactly are you talking about? What made you change your opinion? Vote out somebody you think is town because they are playing "bad"? Because he doubts you?
No, it is more like a hunch. I don't mind him doubting me. Since I can be pretty unbearable at times with those Arnold pictures. What gave me the hunch (and this is something inevitable) was the change of players. I was a strong believer he was town whole catch a was playing. Since he got replaced he has towned it down and in my book opened up a page that is showing me, that he can be scum aswell.
Ofc that is unfair since it was inevitable when someone gets replaced that the way of playing changes but like I said. It's a hunch at this point and my vote is better on zeemumu.