Alright hold up, as an aside, this is one of the most infuriating descriptions anyone can ever have to describe themselves politically, because it's literally wanting to have your cake and eat it too.
"I'm totally on your side, I'm just supporting all the policies that do nothing but harm you, but it's nothing personal, it's just in my financial best interest to do so"
Saying you're socially liberal but fiscally conservative is saying you don't actually give a fuck about anyone but yourself, but you're too afraid to openly admit it.
You then spin it as a positive. Since you "don't care" about other people, you don't match up with those who are actively bigots/racists/sexists/etc, so you seem reasonable. But since you're still voting for policies that ultimately serve to harm those who aren't already rich and/or white, at the end of the day you're doing the exact same fucking thing.
Colin's problem isn't that he's actively racist/sexist. It's that when confronted by the idea that he could have been either of those things, even by accident, he shrugs it off and/or lashes out/doubles down on it. That doesn't seem like a "level headed" person. He just wants to preach and not be questioned. "Colin was Right" isn't a joke. It's actually how he lives his life.