-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
COMICS |OT| September 2016. Comics Should Be Good.
- Thread starter Tyrant Rave
- Start date
echoshifting
Banned
Those are all top tier books, fine choices!
TetraxShards
Member
I saw the first ANAD SamCap trade today. I absolutely love that it's called "Not My Captain America". I had to hide the laughter.
I think there's only one trade out atm.
RepairmanJack
Member
I need to give Sam Wilson another shot. I loved the first couple issues but then I seem to remember suddenly hating the next couple.
Is this a thing people say now?
edit: You edited, but you can't repair the damage.
That IS cheap. Is Savage Dragon supposed to be legitimately good, or know? I know nothing of the book/character outside of what the main character looks like.
Yeah, but when I would want to read Captain Falcon I want to read it since he got the Shield from Cap
It picks with the Standoff issues and continues to be quality afterwards.
Freezasaurus
Member
Messi. Send me the list of the things for the thing. I can find what I need, I just need you to tell me which ones.
BenjaminBirdie
Banned
Remender Uber Alles
I sent the list no?
Freezasaurus
Member
Send me the final list for the Indies. You said you wanted specific covers.
echoshifting
Banned
Hickman da god
Yea I literally bought all of Sam Wilson past the free stuff on MU.
Donniewahlberg
Banned
Favourite writer of the moment: John Arcudi. Writes one of the best ongoing image books right now, and he's been indispensable as the writer of BPRD for years. Quietly writes some of the best comics month after month.
Storm Chamber
Banned
Gonna go ahead and read Civil War 2 up to the current issue.
How much of a trainwreck am I in for?
How much of a trainwreck am I in for?
People liked it until the last issue.
Brian Fellows
Pete Carroll Owns Me
Chris Dingess!
The newest issue of Captain America Steve Rogers bumped the event up a bit for me lol.
BKatastrophe
Member
It's not that bad. I quite enjoy it, but the most recent issue wasn't done very well.
Steve Orlando
echoshifting
Banned
Give yourself a few days to enjoy the first half and appreciate the decent job Bendis is doing before you read the catastrophic #5.
Also consider some of the best tie-ins: Sam Wilson Cap, Ms. Marvel, Spider-Man. Good deeper cuts: Power Man and Iron Fist, Mockingbird, Spider-Woman, Ultimates. A few of those will hopefully keep you interested when the event nosedives
Edit: Oh Kingpin is pretty good too I guess
Storm Chamber
Banned
Hmm!
Gonna dive in after this pizza arrives
Gonna dive in after this pizza arrives
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
Fred Van Lente
BrightLightLava
Unconfirmed Member
Lashley
Why does he wear the mask!?
Going off of what I'm pulling currently, Rick Remender.
And I'm not going to highlight those spoilers of Saga #38 until I read the issue. The cover looks wonderful, though.
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
At one point not long ago, I would have said Remender, but his output has been a mixed bag lately. Deadly Class is still ace, but others less so.
Ah, man, what the fuck Saga...
Lemire for Black Hammer. Honorable mentions: Hickman for TBMM. Remender.
Lemire for Black Hammer. Honorable mentions: Hickman for TBMM. Remender.
So we going to act like Low is not good? Or is this a Valiant joke
echoshifting
Banned
Guess I better read Saga
RepairmanJack
Member
echoshifting
Banned
RepairmanJack
Member
Favorite writer ATM: King hands down. I'm on my way to full on Stan status.
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
I've not read that far into Low, admittedly, but Tokyo Ghost and Devolution were duds in my book. That's just two books man :|
Also, Fear Agent and Uncanny X-Force are two of my all time faves...
ElBoxyBrown
Banned
"Viktor loves huge nipples."
Brian Fellows
Pete Carroll Owns Me
I really haven't had anyone pull away from the pack yet. That's why I just went with the writer of my favorite book.
Brian Fellows
Pete Carroll Owns Me
Primethius
Banned
Scalped, Vol 2: Casino Boogie
[5/5]: Wow. Aaron's just doing so many things with this comic that I'm simply in love. It feels like a TV show with the way Aaron manages to effortlessly juggle around so many view points. But what impresses me is that they all manage to be pretty compelling. I think much of it is down to how this entire volume was structured.
The alternative would've been the perspectives without a clear end goal, leaving the reader sort of aimless as to their purpose.
Great art and coloring of course, but the positioning of the scene given all the context we were given via other perspectives... it was just masterful.
--
Weekly comics plus another volume of Scalped is my checklist for the week. Hopefully I have the time. I don't want to have a (bigger) backlog.
[5/5]: Wow. Aaron's just doing so many things with this comic that I'm simply in love. It feels like a TV show with the way Aaron manages to effortlessly juggle around so many view points. But what impresses me is that they all manage to be pretty compelling. I think much of it is down to how this entire volume was structured.
Despite many of the events taking place before the death of Dash's mom last volume, that event became an intriguing enough catalyst that Aaron used it to setup several different perspectives without slogging down the pacing down.
I also enjoyed how much this volume humanized Red Crow. Now, about the only character that feels one dimensional in his portrayal is the FBI leader-prick. Red Crow also had my favorite scene in the entire volume: the one where he gives cash to Poor Bear.
--
Weekly comics plus another volume of Scalped is my checklist for the week. Hopefully I have the time. I don't want to have a (bigger) backlog.
ElBoxyBrown
Banned
Purple Man is some MRA dude and Jessica is a victim and Jessica is all "fuck you bro!" And Purple Man starts dabbin.
And I have finished Simonson Thor. That was enjoyable, though often a bit too wordy for my personal tastes. But a lot of fun, crazy arcs, and plenty to love there. I really could see the Surtur stuff making a great movie. Like, (if the movies were awesome enough to include such a character), do the Bill introduction the same with that great slow build-up of the sword being forged, then I guess pick something for a middle arc there as things start to heat up (though presumably not directly the stuff from that part of the comics, as admittedly none of that would probably fit so well), and then end on that crazy final battle that already feels tailor made for a Marvel movie.
Other thoughts: wow, the art suddenly improved in the Jormungand battle. Like, in the issue before he looks like kind of crap generic dragon, and then all the sudden it's freaking amazing artwork. Also, if nothing else, all the Thor I read convinces me that I would totally read a Volstagg series. He's generally pretty great, especially for a guy who's so tailor made for just slinging fat jokes at (which he still gets, but his character fairs surprisingly well in spite of that). Also, I really like the Hela costume as it is in this series, with that absolutely crazy cloak.
Unrelated topic: How does one best approach Astro City nowadays, and is it indeed worth picking up? I already purchased a ton from the Vertigo sale (because HOLY CRAP at those prices, especially for series like Y The Last Man and Preacher that already had nice cheaper collections on Comixology), so I'm not sure I will dive in either way, but yeah, the whole thing seems a tad messy as to how I should be picking it up.
Other thoughts: wow, the art suddenly improved in the Jormungand battle. Like, in the issue before he looks like kind of crap generic dragon, and then all the sudden it's freaking amazing artwork. Also, if nothing else, all the Thor I read convinces me that I would totally read a Volstagg series. He's generally pretty great, especially for a guy who's so tailor made for just slinging fat jokes at (which he still gets, but his character fairs surprisingly well in spite of that). Also, I really like the Hela costume as it is in this series, with that absolutely crazy cloak.
Unrelated topic: How does one best approach Astro City nowadays, and is it indeed worth picking up? I already purchased a ton from the Vertigo sale (because HOLY CRAP at those prices, especially for series like Y The Last Man and Preacher that already had nice cheaper collections on Comixology), so I'm not sure I will dive in either way, but yeah, the whole thing seems a tad messy as to how I should be picking it up.
Donniewahlberg
Banned
Haha! Even manage to get you in a gaming thread this week
) that's awesome man, I was kind if wondering how you would take the pacing of the volume given that it doesn't really progress THE big thing from volume 1 but I totally agree, it is like a good tv show, or a good book. There's a lot of stuff going on in vol 1 but vol 2 is where Aaron sits back and gets comfortable in the seat after spending the whole of the first volume typing away on the edge. Character first storytelling at its best, and it's worth it to get you invested in all this disparate viewpoints as they converge, both now and in a broader way as the series goes on. Also yea, Red Crow is honestly a very compelling guy as you start to see his layers peeled back. Also a huge strength of Southern Bastards, giving the quote unquote villains time be much much more. Glad your enjoying it as you get to it anyway man, I actually was going to say Jason Aaron for favourite writer earlier but with the Goddamned still not in trade, thought I'd hold off and give someone else the nod. Dude is a really great writer though. Scalped and The Other Side were the first things I read by him and he's never disappointed since.
no one mention original sin
Similar threads
- x2