Support NeoGAF

[MiguelItUp]

I enjoyed DRDR for what it was as I loved the original so much, but it is wild to see what was altered in terms of details. It's really disheartening seeing such limitations in newer games. Be it sequels or remakes, it just makes no sense to me. We have better hardware now, so, why on earth would we have less details than we did in the original? It makes absolutely no sense. Definitely makes you question the RE Engine a bit more. I mean, sure, in a lot of cases it can look real good, but maybe it can't do as much as we thought it could. Or at least as well.

The AI upscaling part is honestly something that I found really disappointing as well. You can't act like you care about your game and everything, but then just be okay with doing such a thing. I mean, some of the examples that were shown were completely broken textures. It looks lazy and careless.

I couldn't careless about the censorship stuff, it's everything else that honestly bums me out.

 

[SJRB]

This video is insane, I had no idea the game was such a botched job.

Not just the censorship but the super poor lack of details, AI upscaling textures, it's ridiculous.

When it switches to the fucking WiiU footage that has better mirror effects than this remake, lol.

Soulless indeed.

 

[Giallo Corsa]

Was going to get it eventually but, after seeing those differences side to side...yeah, it's a no from me dawg.

I can live with the..."political correctness" but those botched details like less gore, not being able to shoot zombies in the distance , no mirror reflections, AI upscaled shit job, dumbed down enemy AI and difficulty etc etc...scream of a rush job and definitely something that I won't reward by buying a copy - and they want 50 Eurodollars for this ?

This is why we can't have nice things.

 

[kunonabi]

Like they're just being petty bitches with the yellow paint now.

 

[MrRibeye]

His latest videos just haven't been the same.

Right? Noticed that as well. Something is off.

 

[tommib]

This video is insane, I had no idea the game was such a botched job.

Not just the censorship but the super poor lack of details, AI upscaling textures, it's ridiculous.

When it switches to the fucking WiiU footage that has better mirror effects than this remake, lol.

Soulless indeed.

I don’t get how we got from mirror effects on a Wii to no mirror effects on a PS5. Boggles my mind.

 

[NeverYouMind]

This is a common issue with all kinds of remasters and the like. The original product is made with a AAA team with visionary talent and passion with huge budget and years of time, while these remake projects are often given to a small, low level team of novices, interns etc. with low budget, few months of time and no proper director to handle the big picture of the vision. These guys not only lack the artistic talent the original team had but also don't care or understand the original art or what made it special and think things get better by just adding more superficial detail.

A good example of this 'not understanding the original vision' is changing the origial DR's amazing liminal space feeling with a generic zombie horror mood. The point is that the mall is a normal place with clean hallways and well kept gardens. Zombies just happened to invade the place, so what's with the overgrown leisure park in the remake for example?

Original DR is one of my absolute favorite games and I'm so glad I dodged the bullet with this turd of a demake.


ART IS DEAD

VISION IS DEAD

PASSION IS DEAD

I played the Dead Space (2023) not long ago and I have to say that it is a major improvement over the original without cutting corners. So, while this remaster is a hatchet job, it does not mean all modern ones are.

 

[StueyDuck]

Didn't realise it went further than erotica shots.

That lady store turning into her is quite the eradication of women move

 

[fatmarco]

It's crazy that we have people defending a remaster made 18 years later that is buggier, broken, less detailed and censored as if this should be at all acceptable.

They likely had more developers working on this this than the original, had the base code to work with, and still somehow created less and charged nearly full price for it.

 

[Jack Videogames]

The AI upscaling sure is something.

I caved in and bought the game but... goddamn that's so glaring

 

[ResilientBanana]

Welp, I was going to buy it, now I'm not.

 

[Giallo Corsa]

It's crazy that we have people defending a remaster made 18 years later that is buggier, broken, less detailed and censored as if this should be at all acceptable.

They likely had more developers working on this this than the original, had the base code to work with, and still somehow created less and charged nearly full price for it.

I mean, the shadows of the damned hella remaster has apparently heavy dips into the 30s on a PS5 of all things and that's as basic as remasters go (it's basically an up-res job)...

I don't know what's worse to be completely honest, although, I'm still grabbing SOTD (when they'll patch it) while DRre is still a no go since it's pretty much unfixable - not to mention - by choice.

People hate the term "lazy devs" but Goddamn if that isn't the case with most late remasters.

 

[March Climber]

I don’t get how we got from mirror effects on a Wii to no mirror effects on a PS5. Boggles my mind.

This specifically makes me think it might be an RE Engine issue. How many times were there mirrors in any of the recent Resident Evil games?

 

[Go_Ly_Dow]

Mega botched wow

 

[Dr.Morris79]

Another game I'm glad I held off buying

What a load of shit.

 

[IbizaPocholo]

These are the videos I want to see of comparisons, and not the easiest ones, which only show the graphics we see daily.

 

[MacReady13]

This guy makes videos about the details of blood stains on wood and other irrelevant things.

You mean like Digital Foundry looking at backround objects in a racing game, for example?

 

[Danny Dudekisser]

I'd seen a lot of the censorship, but it's incredible just how thoroughly they missed the mark.

 

[Skitso]

I played the Dead Space (2023) not long ago and I have to say that it is a major improvement over the original without cutting corners. So, while this remaster is a hatchet job, it does not mean all modern ones are.

Absolutely. That's what I said: "a common issue". The Dead Space remake for example was perfect! A 10/10 update of a timeless classic.

 

[bender]

When it switches to the fucking WiiU footage that has better mirror effects than this remake, lol.

Chop Till You Drop is a Wii game, not a Wii U game.

 

[Majukun]

tone of the video seems a bit too apocalyptic

it is a shame about the difficulty and the gameplay effecting stuff, like more passive zombies and the inability to make barricades and at the same time how certain element of the environment are now unbreakable barriers for the zombies...the rest is stuff that it's not THAT important, although it's a shame that we didn't get the same attention to detail 18 years or so later

also did not find that much differrence in the voice acting part

Definitely sad with all the censorships happening for no reason, but the gore/blood ones are definitely because of less talented devs or stricht deadlines, because would make no sense to tone down blood just a little bit, but leave all the rest. But one thing always surprise me of modern games is the lack of reflections in mirrors/clean surfaces. Seems that now you can just have reflections if you have RTX ON, but like shown in the video even Wii games had more than decent reflections. I mean, in Alan Wake 2 on PS5 is basically impossible to see a mirror reflect something, but I can see everything reflected in Duke Nukem 3D. I don't know what happened, but definitely we are going back on some aspects, same for interaction/physiscs, at least in AAA games.

well most of the times in old titles reflections are not actual reflection, they are duplicated models.

 

[Dacvak]

Oof. Those AI textures are really, really bad.

 

[Umbral]

Absolutely. That's what I said: "a common issue". The Dead Space remake for example was perfect! A 10/10 update of a timeless classic.

I’ll say 9/10. There were some unnecessary changes made. Nicole’s model and the gender neutral bathrooms come to mind immediately. Kendra’s voice acting bothered me too. Original was better. No reason to do that but they did it, likely because of EA.

I hope that they do Dead Space 2 and don’t botch it at all.

 

[The Janitor]

The AI upscaling sure is something.

Homomade cookies

 

[bender]

I’ll say 9/10. There were some unnecessary changes made. Nicole’s model and the gender neutral bathrooms come to mind immediately. Kendra’s voice acting bothered me too. Original was better. No reason to do that but they did it, likely because of EA.

I hope that they do Dead Space 2 and don’t botch it at all.

Pretty sure the laser sights in the remake don't function independently like the original.

 

[Killer8]

I’ll say 9/10. There were some unnecessary changes made. Nicole’s model and the gender neutral bathrooms come to mind immediately. Kendra’s voice acting bothered me too. Original was better. No reason to do that but they did it, likely because of EA.

I hope that they do Dead Space 2 and don’t botch it at all.

They ruined Hammond's character and some of the environmental storytelling was also inferior.

 

[Umbral]

They ruined Hammond's character and some of the environmental storytelling was also inferior.

It should have been Kendra in that engine room. Hammond was the best.

 

[Fake]

You mean like Digital Foundry looking at backround objects in a racing game, for example?

 

[Skitso]

I’ll say 9/10. There were some unnecessary changes made. Nicole’s model and the gender neutral bathrooms come to mind immediately. Kendra’s voice acting bothered me too. Original was better. No reason to do that but they did it, likely because of EA.

I hope that they do Dead Space 2 and don’t botch it at all.

You are right. It's a 9/10. I forgot those little things and they also botched the "loud room" ambiance.

 

[havoc00]

pandering to the rainbow crew ruins yet another game.

 

[Fluffytheterrible]

Classic capcpom