Ok people are serious with this?
Because it's ridiculous to think someone would be punished so severely over such a small mistake. What he wrote was recognisably a limerick, even if it didn't fit the strict definition that you've chosen to use.
Also the bolded has nothing to do with how strict or lenient blah blah
You not only missed me calling out Faddy for lying about or breaking his FA, but you also seem to have made up this whole "weird attempt to analyse the Blarg message" thing. As far as I can recall, I only mentioned Blarg once in my "hey, this is a summary of what I missed, let me reread the thread". Perhaps you are confusing me with Ty4on?
Speaking of Faddy, both myself and Ty4on (through my post) have called you out on the missed Limerick. Either you are lying, or you should be dead. Given how long it has been and you are still alive, I am assuming you are lying.
Vote: Faddy
Lemme think what sticks out, I cannot access the post count thing really easily on mobile; we should consider sticking that link in the OP somewhere.
As for the game state, the Sorian/Karkador bickering feels like play styles are just clashing. It almost reminds me of Batman, but I town read both players here so far. More so Sorian I think, mostly since he has seemed to not dwell on FAs as much, but I say that without going back and rereading so dont take it as gospel or anything.
Bronx has played like Bronx. Problem for me is that Bronx seems to play the same as town, scum or dirty neutral ascetic serial killer.
Nin has been gambiting, but why? I guess we will find out at some point.
Ty4on I town read, though I somewhat selfishly do not like him co-opting my Faddy accusation.Still, his posts have been pretty detailed and hunting.
It is ridiculous to think that a game runner would enforce the rules of his game? Seriously? So between "Faddy is lying" and "Crimson has arbitrarily decided not to enforce a rule for a player", you're going with "I think Crimson will choose to ignore the rules he himself decided on"? Okay dude
I definitely don't think his FA limits him to a single hour of actual posting. A policy lynch is one thing, but opting for that over someone you believe is scum just reads odd to me unless you think Blarg poses a bigger threat for some reason.
I've never played with scum Ty so I don't have that frame of reference. His posts when he's engaging others or putting out reads have been good enough to get him town read, it's just that middle lull where all he did was look at the Blarg stuff that gave me pause. Not enough to bump him down but I thought it was worth mentioning.
That one post doesn't really paint the whole picture. In post 490 and 493 he first discusses his stance on Blarg and Terra, explaining that he doesn't feel like a lynch on either is a good choice at this point. Then in 499 he admits he didn't follow the conversation closely enough and missed all of the exchange about Terra doing this previously as scum. Finally in 579 we have his post he quoted deciding not to listen to Blarg anymore. It's about his lack of interest. He doesn't seem engaged and flipped on both without really much thought out on his part. Just doesn't feel like town play to me, but like I said for now he's still neutral because I've misread him this same way just a game ago.
That's amazing. Now it makes sense that you were a bit confused by my rabbit hole comment. For some reason I was convinced that a) your limerick comments were about Blarg's message and b) that they were from the same person as the Blarg analysis when in fact it was started by Ty4on and you had nothing to do with it.
I have never been a mod so I'm not going to try and put myself in Crimson's shoes as far as what is and isn't acceptable. The only thing I really think stands out is the stark contrast from this claimed long back and forth over "strictly enforcing" a sonnet style and now apparently ignoring a missed syllable. It doesn't quite match up but again I really have no clue what would and wouldn't be a violation.
A policy lynch overrides anything else, at least that's how I see it. Otherwise it's an empty threat, which just devalues your vote for future days/games (which is why Blarg probably doesn't even feel threatened by the votes on him right now - I don't think we've ever followed through with a pure policy lynch).
I guess that makes sense. I suppose I'm just not a fan of policy lynches then.
If I'm being honest this is how I feel about nin. That fact that he has toned down the craziness somewhat is kinda weird (and kinda awful).
--------
I'm not going to OMGUs you as I'm not quite scum reading that choice, this has to be the weakest reversal on a hard stance that I have ever seen.
¯\_(ツ
_/¯