Support NeoGAF

[*Splinter]

Blarg start being useful

 

[Faddy]

It's not just your FA, but how you post in general. The point of you becoming significantly more responsive once you started to gain votes. Your patterns in general. Hell, look at THIS reason for placing your vote on Terrabyte, who ultimately killed himself:



"Voting with the majority, hoping someone follows you in doing so."

There hasn't been much about you which has convinced me of your towniness, and then above that, you meaninglessly lied about your forbidden action, which really didn't result in anything but a lot of fluff and empty discussion.

The reasoning is simple. I didn't want to lynch Blarg. 4 of us had Terra on our scum list, kingkitty had his vote on him as well. So with 5 of us suspecting him why split our vote 3-2 when it seems we are all against lynching Blarg.

Don't blame the votes for killing Terra. 5 votes out of 17 and he thinks it is game over?

 

[Blargonaut]

*snip*

Why the self-vote Blarg? I coudnt figure that out.

call it pity

 

[nin1000]

wow

This is surreal

Thanks for talking again.

 

[Ty4on]

I'm trying to keep up while at work still. I still standby my thoughts on Flush and AB. Splinter doesn't look great after being one of the first I can recall saying he thinks the suicide is a good plan. Faddy still concerns me especially after his lie that I don't think got us any new information. Blarg is likely lying too but to what end I don't know. My vote will be amongst them, going to think on it and try to follow posts as I make this presentation.

I disagree with Splinter.
Just going by past experience I feel scum!Splinter would be going much harder on a townie for anti-town behavior. He can get a mislynch and wash it of because said town was being anti-town. Town!Splinter does some weird things every now and then, and isn't afraid to pull some weird moves.

 

[nin1000]

Blarg. What kind images would you want me to post in order to communicate with us easier tomorrow ?

 

[Blargonaut]

Blarg start being useful

yes

 

[*Splinter]

No

 

[Ty4on]

Alternatively, AB stood out as the worst in the "knowing he's town" camp. Can't find the "2 dead townies" post right now though

Brb cod

 

[Blargonaut]

Blarg. What kind images would you want me to post in order to communicate with us easier tomorrow ?

omg

 

[AbsolutBro]

Alternatively, AB stood out as the worst in the "knowing he's town" camp. Can't find the "2 dead townies" post right now though

Wow. That is some quality shade.

Here, let me get that quote for you:

Fair enough, you do you. It is kinda anti-town though, since if we mislynch that means two town dead D1 :-/

Ooh, so scummy. "It is an anti-town move for town to kill themself because if we then mislynch we have two town dead D1."

Yes, clearly I know he is town. It could not possibly be:

I agree with this. If he doesn't suicide he looks bad, and scum really need to keep their numbers up to win.

As long as we are throwing shade around:

Let's assume for a second that Terra isn't bluffing. Him suiciding sounds like a good idea to me, so who would we lynch if he flips town? What about if he flips scum?

No he's right, some of you are acting way too sure he's town.

Absolut is the one that stood out to me, "2 town dead D1".

The panic in this post is hilarious as well though

How did that pro-suicide stance work out for town?

 

[nin1000]

Terra. you just suck. This suicide brought nothing to the table.
NOTHING

for the next 2 Mafia games we play together

you will be

The Shockmaster

I think your WWE/WWF Knowledge will make you understand that you are now F-Tier

-----------------

Just wanted to get that out of the way

 

[Natiko]

I disagree with Splinter.
Just going by past experience I feel scum!Splinter would be going much harder on a townie for anti-town behavior. He can get a mislynch and wash it of because said town was being anti-town. Town!Splinter does some weird things every now and then, and isn't afraid to pull some weird moves.

Seems almost backwards when described but fair enough. For some reason he just strikes me as different this game than in Zelda. Even disregarding the Terra suicide go ahead.

 

[*Splinter]

I'm not town reading Bronx, but I want to lynch someone who was in the dangerzone. If scum were protecting say scum!Faddy they'd probably be trying to shift focus over to Terra. Same goes for Blarg, but I town read him slightly.

This is probably right... I had the feeling that Faddy was the "alternative" scum wanted, but with Terra flipping town I dunno anymore

 

[nin1000]

omg

So be it

 

[*Splinter]

Wow. That is some quality shade.

Here, let me get that quote for you:



Ooh, so scummy. "It is an anti-town move for town to kill themself because if we then mislynch we have two town dead D1."

Yes, clearly I know he is town. It could not possibly be:



As long as we are throwing shade around:





How did that pro-suicide stance work out for town?

Is this a serious fucking question?

I didn't have the advantage of knowing that he would flip town, or that he was even telling the truth about his FA to begin with.

 

[kingkitty]

Kark u up?

 

[Ty4on]

Seems almost backwards when described but fair enough. For some reason he just strikes me as different this game than in Zelda. Even disregarding the Terra suicide go ahead.

What's different?

 

[*Splinter]

Seems almost backwards when described but fair enough. For some reason he just strikes me as different this game than in Zelda. Even disregarding the Terra suicide go ahead.

A fair observation, but I was barely playing Zelda until my last day.

 

[Bronx-Man]

Splinter
a} doesn't defend his extremely boneheaded decision
b) votes for me for calling out his boneheaded decision
c) immediately switches over to Blarg so everyone can stop talking about his boneheaded decision

These are extremely townie actions. Extremely.

 

[Karkador]

Kark u up?

yes, hi

 

[Faddy]

We have 3 players with less posts than Crimson. He is running the game you are supposed to be playing

OceanicAir
kingkitty
Royal_Flush

 

[kingkitty]

yes, hi

did u see my last question?

 

[*Splinter]

Splinter
a} doesn't defend his extremely boneheaded decision
b) votes for me for calling out his boneheaded decision
c) immediately switches over to Blarg so everyone can stop talking about his boneheaded decision

These are extremely townie actions. Extremely.

Bronx
a) is dead weight or scum
b) is dead weight or scum
c) is dead weight or scum

 

[Karkador]

if you don't have one, does that mean you can't suicide by FA? like Terra or others who can purposely or accidentally violate their FA.

that's correct

 

[Bronx-Man]

Bronx
a) is dead weight or scum
b) is dead weight or scum
c) is dead weight or scum

You gonna explain pushing Terra to suicide at any time or.......?

 

[*Splinter]

If I'm not around next phase (and because I won't have time this phase) take a look at the time gap between suicide being suggested and actually happening. Who actually opposed it? Who only popped up when it was too late? Etc.

 

[Ty4on]

This is probably right... I had the feeling that Faddy was the "alternative" scum wanted, but with Terra flipping town I dunno anymore

What do you think about Sorian after Terra's flip?

 

[Blargonaut]

 

[*Splinter]

You gonna explain pushing Terra to suicide at any time or.......?

I was in favour of his lynch was inevitable. IF that was the case then its equivalent to multiple lynches, and should still be considered in future.

But not rushed last minute and done before it's a certainty goddamnit Terra

 

[OceanicAir]

Is this a serious fucking question?

I didn't have the advantage of knowing that he would flip town, or that he was even telling the truth about his FA to begin with.

Well you wouldn't have the advantage unless you are scum...

But really, do you honestly think that a mafia member would suicide at any point of the game? Suicide was just a bad decision, period. And it is junk to try to treat it as an extra lynch.

 

[Royal_Flush]

Kingkitty
Sorian
Splinter
Faddy
Natiko

As of now, all five of you at the very least lean scum to me. What the hell were you people thinking?

You've been playing this long enough to know that this is bullshit. Step up your game.

Curious, is there a reason you are leaving Royal_Flush off the list? Was pretty pro-suicide.

How did that pro-suicide stance work out for town?

I didn't vote, so I'm not in that lazy ass copy-paste. And for your information, this outcome doesn't change my stance. I would give the same advice again. If you're Town and you can suicide you should once it's clear you're going to be the lynch. And I don't fucking care what your role is because you're getting lynched anyway.

Now, if Terra actually was getting lynched isn't as clear. Him being a cop certainly didn't justify that oh-so-important 2 hour deadline, as literally nothing game changing was in the flip. But with his suicide announcement he left burnt ground. There was no going back. We wouldn't have trusted him and Scum would have killed him sooner or later.

If you have the possibility to suicide, don't announce it!

I'm not town reading Bronx, but I want to lynch someone who was in the dangerzone. If scum were protecting say scum!Faddy they'd probably be trying to shift focus over to Terra. Same goes for Blarg, but I town read him slightly.

With this logic you should looking for people who backed off of Terra once he threatened to suicide.

 

[*Splinter]

What do you think about Sorian after Terra's flip?

He hasn't moved far from null all day. Being wrong about Terra doesn't change that though

 

[Blargonaut]

VOTE: Faddy

 

[*Splinter]

Well you wouldn't have the advantage unless you are scum...

But really, do you honestly think that a mafia member would suicide at any point of the game? Suicide was just a bad decision, period. And it is junk to try to treat it as an extra lynch.

There is a difference between threatening/suggesting suicide and actually doing it, yes?

 

[Royal_Flush]

But really, do you honestly think that a mafia member would suicide at any point of the game? Suicide was just a bad decision, period. And it is junk to try to treat it as an extra lynch.

No, but they would threaten it in order to get people to back off.


This discussion is leading nowhere. I will not accept any arguments that are based on interactions with Terra's threatened suicide for today's lynch. We can talk this over tomorrow.

 

[Ty4on]

To be honest, the scum meta currently seems to be 'be as inactive as humanly possible then let Town implode from the uncertainty' so I'm not surprised Sorian is suspicious

Of who?

You.

Sketch, what made you think Terra was inactive?

 

[nin1000]

VOTE: Faddy

 

[OceanicAir]

We have 3 players with less posts than Crimson. He is running the game you are supposed to be playing

OceanicAir
kingkitty
Royal_Flush

And if you go by post count as an indicator of anything in this game other than as a count of how many times people hit "post reply", then I don't know what to tell you. A good third of this game is useless BS.

 

[Royal_Flush]

VOTE: Faddy

Stop fucking around with non-posts and tell me right here, right now if you will be speaking answering machine again tomorrow and why you didn't play any of our communication games. Your behaviour today was anti-town as fuck.

 

[kingkitty]

that's correct

if there's no way you can purposely or accidentally commit suicide in any way, that seems weird. like isn't that part of the gimmick of this game? to worry about violating something? what has crimsonfist done.

 

[Blargonaut]

UNVOTE: Faddy

VOTE: nin1000

That's it, I'm gonna pull you off me like a bare-handed suckerfish off a sharkskin sofa

 

[AbsolutBro]

Is this a serious fucking question?

I didn't have the advantage of knowing that he would flip town, or that he was even telling the truth about his FA to begin with.

I thought it was obviously a snarky rhetorical question. The answer is badly. It worked out badly for town.

I didn't vote, so I'm not in that lazy ass copy-paste. And for your information, this outcome doesn't change my stance. I would give the same advice again. If you're Town and you can suicide you should once it's clear you're going to be the lynch. And I don't fucking care what your role is because you're getting lynched anyway.

Now, if Terra actually was getting lynched isn't as clear. Him being a cop certainly didn't justify that oh-so-important 2 hour deadline, as literally nothing game changing was in the flip. But with his suicide announcement he left burnt ground. There was no going back. We wouldn't have trusted him and Scum would have killed him sooner or later.

If you have the possibility to suicide, don't announce it!

I didnt realize that was just a list of Terra voters, my bad. My bad.

Look, while I can see your point I have to disagree. Town suicide is almost always bad for town. A not insignificant part of the game is numbers, and potentially losing two town is rarely a good idea. I will drop it though. What is done is done and we (almost certainly) cannot bring Terra back.

I can also agree, in principle, that even if suiciding was a good idea, that Terra's actual methodology was pisspoor. :-/



I have to head out shortly. I will have spotty connection while on the train, and will not be home until after deadline.

 

[Blargonaut]

Stop fucking around with non-posts and tell me right here, right now if you will be speaking answering machine again tomorrow and why you didn't play any of our communication games. Your behaviour today was anti-town as fuck.

cute

I'll say yes, just to aggro you further

 

[FluxWaveZ]

Stop fucking around with non-posts and tell me right here, right now if you will be speaking answering machine again tomorrow and why you didn't play any of our communication games. Your behaviour today was anti-town as fuck.

Yep, and it's why I've been up for a Blarg lynch from the start. When it comes down to it, it's either Blarg or Faddy right now, and Terrabyte was (worse) than a waste of time, as I had originally thought.

if there's no way you can purposely or accidentally commit suicide in any way, that seems weird. like isn't that part of the gimmick of this game? to worry about violating something? what has crimsonfist done.

Precisely why you should be considering the meaning behind Karkador being potentially the only player (or set of players) without a forbidden action when everyone else has one.

 

[Blargonaut]

yes

 

[Royal_Flush]

cute

I'll say yes, just to aggro you further

Can we just lynch him please?

 

[Blargonaut]

c'mon

I'm giving you all the excuses, right here, friends

Hit me

 

[Ty4on]

Yep, and it's why I've been up for a Blarg lynch from the start. When it comes down to it, it's either Blarg or Faddy right now, and Terrabyte was (worse) than a waste of time, as I had originally thought.

Why didn't you comment on Terra when Sorian and Splinter were going after him and what were your views of him pre-suicide?

 

[StarSketch]

Sketch, what made you think Terra was inactive?

Wasn't Sorian giving Terra crap over being inactive?

-Backreads-

...Oh. No he was not.

Oops.