?
It was an honest question, I didn't remember you two interacting much and wanted to know if there was something I missed. You don't need to get that defensive over it. :x
Gotcha. How is that affecting your lynch choice though? Would you still rather lynch Nin over Muffin or vice versa?
'I gut read him as not-town' doesn't give me any idea as to why you feel that way. Does he vote weird? Is there something you don't like about the questions he asks? Something specific like that, or if you have quotes that would be find too. Mostly something more than just a 'I don't feel he's town' vibe.
How does his vote throwing at the end of the last Day Phase show he's more reserved?
I pointed out way earlier in the game ( I'll get the post if you want it ) but he was rather quiet and reserved early on and wouldn't do much until I, or someone else, would call him out on it and then he would get active. He's since shifted and no longer needs to be prodded for his thoughts/questions, a pretty sharp contrast to Day 1 Muffin. That's why I asked why you didn't consider that point against him, you even agreed with this point way back on Day 3 ( ? ) or so for similar reasons.
Sorry sawn, I mean nothing personal by getting defensive over the question
this is just a tight spot to be in at this point in the game, and one l little thing can lead to a lynch
It's less than ideal to me that we have both of them coming into this day, but I'll still take a Nin lynch over muffin. Right now, my suspicions are that between you, nin, and muffin, we have our two scum. Isaac is my neutral guess. There's no path to a town victory if we focus on the neutral today, so unless my read on isaac changes, I won't be pursuing a neutral lynch.
My suspicions of muffin started with what I felt to be attempts to sidetrack the conversation to hunting the neutral in D2, even if was just posed as a series of questions. Since then, we've done some tunneling in on each other, and I haven't seen muffin do much to shake off that initial suspicion. That being said, however, he isn't my strongest scum lean, since he refutes my suspicions well enough that I have to stop and think :/
When I talked about nin's reservations, it's more about his activity throughout the rest of the day. He was pretty quiet during the last couple of day phases, I thought, but still would come out at the end of day madness to try to land a wacky lynch
To your observations on Muffin's activity, I'm not sure I'd draw that as much of a negative except for the point where you claim he changed behavior after you called him out. I'm a quiet player, so I get not having a lot of activity in the first few days, and being called out on it is like having a fire lit under your seat lol