Support NeoGAF

[DonJorginho]

DEATHLOOP REVIEW THREAD

Welcome to the DEATHLOOP Review Thread!

Reviews are now LIVE!

Will update the thread as we go!

MC: 90
OC:88 (94% CR)
​

IGN (10/10)

Deathloop encases fun investigation work and satisfying combat in a unique time loop mechanic to create a tremendously satisfying adventure.

Gamespot (10/10)

Arkane Lyon's follow-up to Dishonored is a masterclass in open-ended action game design.

VideoGamesChronicle (5/5)

Deathloop is slick and inventive, with a delicious sense of style and humour. It distils Arkane’s hefty systems into something more explicitly playful, then leaves its sparkling cast to run riot in its huge interlocking puzzle of an island. One of the smartest and most outright entertaining games of the year.

GameInformer (9/10)

Deathloop is a rare game I started replaying as soon as the credits finished rolling. Now deep in a second playthrough, I'm still discovering new secrets and ways to play

PlayStationLifestyle (9.5/10)

There isn't anything else quite like Deathloop. It's a riveting detective mystery, plays with time loops in unique ways, and never feels like it slows down, even in those stealthier moments. It's a game that's thought out top-to-bottom, with two perfect leads heralding the charge and a unique multiplayer component that feels central to everything that Deathloop is, without ever getting in the way. Whether you're looking to break the loop or preserve it, Blackreef is certainly worth the visit. You may find yourself as stuck there too.

EuroGamer (ESSENTIAL)

A brilliant timeloop shooter that gives Dishonored's best tricks and techniques more opportunity to shine.

GameSpew (9/10)

Deathloop is seriously slick. It’s a game that entrusts its players to engage with its systems in their own way, and while you’ll never at be a loss on what to do, you won’t have your hand held, either. It’s fast, it’s smooth, it’s a hell of a lot of fun. I almost don’t want the loop to end, quite frankly.

TheGamesMachine (9/10)

Deathloop is an unusual but fascinating game to be experienced in one breath as a superb noir thriller in which, however, we are the killer. The AI is out of place compared to the rest of the game and it's not a perfect game, but it's not afraid to dare, it has style in spades, shows the creative team's burning passion in every corner and when finally get that perfect loop, the satisfaction is immeasurable.

Playstation Universe (10/10)

Deathloop is not only one of the most conceptually ambitious and well executed games ever made, but Arkane's PlayStation swansong also has a boundless energy and ingenuity that no other game can match. Quite simply, Deathloop is an unparalleled synergy of first-person shooter design, explorative bliss and narrative complexity that we likely won't see again for a very, very long time.​

The Sixth Axis (10/10)

Deathloop is the kind of game that will get in your head and stay there even when you're not playing. Colt is a great protagonist, the intricate environmental design is a dream to explore, and the loop system keeps things fresh and offers so much replayability. Simply put, Deathloop is fantastic.

NextGenBase (9/10)

Deathloop is not only one of the most conceptually ambitious and well executed games ever made, but Arkane's PlayStation swansong also has a boundless energy and ingenuity that no other game can match. Quite simply, Deathloop is an unparalleled synergy of first-person shooter design, explorative bliss and narrative complexity that we likely won't see again for a very, very long time.

HobbyConsolas (9/10)

Although there are some elements from Dishonored in the game, Arkane Studios delivers a unique FPS, with great characters an intriguing story and a wise use of time loops. There are some technical issues here and there, but we loved the experience.

Destructoid (9/10)

Deathloop combines a classic Arkane stealthy-shooty foundation with a genuinely interesting and fun premise to aplomb. This is going to be on a lot of Game of the Year lists.

Press Start (9/10)

It's not an easy thing Arkane has done here in serving up a genuinely fresh take on one of the medium's most enduring genres. Deathloop redefines what a shooter can be, and the developer has used their entire toolkit to get there. Satisfying action, world-building that's second-to-none, style and substance, and a genuinely enthralling riddle at the centre, Deathloop delivers it all. And it's through these triumphs that Deathloop earns its place in the first-person shooter pantheon, and puts its hand up during Game of the Year talks.

PCGamer (89/100)

A thoughtful response to Dishonored that makes for an entertaining stealth shooter in its own right, but it's the multiplayer invasions that make Deathloop sing.

EasyAllies (8/10)

Push Square (8/10)

Few games have the confidence and swagger of Deathloop. Packed full of charisma and wit, it's a game that can be played your way, with your own style and cunning. A very accomplished package of gameplay features supplies the goods, and the time loop delivers fun and deceitful opportunities over and over again.

GAMEMag (8/10)

Consistency is the mother of mastery. And DEATHLOOP is another consistent release of Arkane Studios. For newcomers this game can serve as a great entry point to the Arkane portfolio. While all the hadcore fans will surely get what they expect from this title, even with this new and experimental format. There's no better place for experiments than in the endless time loop, after all.

 

[Banjo64]

Hope this game reviews really well. Never seen such unwarranted hate for a game, and especially a timed exclusive.

 

[TransTrender]

The time has finally come.

I didn't think it would be this soon.

 

[Concern]

 

[SoggyBiscuit]

Hope Arkane knock this one out of the park. Think the game looks like more excellent work, I hope it builds on lessons learned from Dishonored.

 

[BaneIsPain]

 

[Hobbygaming]

 

[GHG]

Hope this game reviews really well. Never seen such unwarranted hate for a game, and especially a timed exclusive.

Considering how good prey and dishonoured are along with the recent surge in high quality roguelike games it's baffling.

Also its evident nobody played prey mooncrash.

 

[DonJorginho]

 

[TonyK]

Hope this game reviews really well. Never seen such unwarranted hate for a game, and especially a timed exclusive.

I think is a case of over exposure. I love Arkane and I'm tired of the game and it's not even released.

 

[SJRB]

It's an Arkane game so it'll probably review well, sell poorly and be an underrated niche fan favourite.

Can't wait!

 

[crunchyBiscuits]

Looking forward to this one. It's been such a long wait! Hopefully the wait was worth it

 

[Yoboman]

Hope this game reviews really well. Never seen such unwarranted hate for a game, and especially a timed exclusive.

Its a bit much the game looks fun

 

[Fools idol]

Have been playing on PS5 all weekend - copy arrived early on friday from TGC...

I will be very surprised if this doesn't get high 80's maybe even low 90's. It's really good.

Arkane fans will not be disappointed.

 

[DonJorginho]

Have been playing on PS5 all weekend - copy arrived early on friday from TGC...

I will be very surprised if this doesn't get high 80's maybe even low 90's. It's really good.

Arkane fans will not be disappointed.

Let's just hope they have an FOV Slider on launch for PS5 as that 65 FOV is sending me on my own kind of Deathloop..

 

[Hobbygaming]

I'm interested in how it does. Is this playable offline?

 

[DonJorginho]

I'm interested in how it does. Is this playable offline?

Yes you can.

The official director of Deathloop has just confirmed that the game will be playable offline Many people have been asking this since the game originally got revealed; it seems like we finally have an answer.

Deathloop is Playable Offline confirms Director - Gaming Route

The official director of Deathloop has just confirmed that the game will be playable offline Many people have been asking this since the game originally got

gamingroute.com

 

[Inviusx]

Have been playing on PS5 all weekend - copy arrived early on friday from TGC...

I will be very surprised if this doesn't get high 80's maybe even low 90's. It's really good.

Arkane fans will not be disappointed.

Can you comment on the "character yells at you over the radio" trope that we've seen a lot of so far in the trailers? The only thing holding me back was how annoying that seemed, even only after a few minutes.

 

[DonJorginho]

Can you comment on the "character yells at you over the radio" trope that we've seen a lot of so far in the trailers? The only thing holding me back was how annoying that seemed, even only after a few minutes.

That's quite a regular occurrence I believe, it's the main way you communicate with Julianna.

 

[Markio128]

I’m going to miss Deathloop trailers being shown by Sony

 

[DonJorginho]

I’m going to miss Deathloop trailers being shown by Sony

Can't wait for the launch trailer and Accolades trailers!!!

 

[Perfo]

This might be Arkane's best game yet given the footage and ambitions shown in it. I hope they make it big!

 

[Markio128]

In all seriousness, I hope the game is good as you can’t have too many good games to choose from.

 

[nani17]

Do reviews scores still matter?? Don't forget Cyberpunk got 86% and IGN gave it 9/10

 

[Hobbygaming]

Yes you can.

Deathloop is Playable Offline confirms Director - Gaming Route

The official director of Deathloop has just confirmed that the game will be playable offline Many people have been asking this since the game originally got

gamingroute.com

My interest increases

 

[Kenpachii]

Do reviews scores still matter?? Don't forget Cyberpunk got 86% and IGN gave it 9/10

Not really, pretty much all of them are paid reviews.

 

[DonJorginho]

My interest increases

 

[DonJorginho]

Not really, pretty much all of them are paid reviews.

They matter if it's someone you trust.

And I guess they matter if you're a fanboy who uses screengrabs of Metacritic scores to try and one up people in debates on Twitter

 

[Flabagast]

Hope this game reviews really well. Never seen such unwarranted hate for a game, and especially a timed exclusive.

Yes gamers are simply absolutely and irreversibly stupid to hate on this game.

Let them enjoy their piece of shit brain dead super hero games I guess.

 

[Starfield]

The time has finally come.

I didn't think it would be this soon.

wdym. It was supposed to release in May lol

 

[DonJorginho]

wdym. It was supposed to release in May lol

And before that the launch of the PS5 lmao

 

[JusticeForAll]

I liked all of Arkane's games so I preorderd this one, even though it seems like the least attractive game for me they made so far. I hope it reviews well.

 

[Bryank75]

 

[sircaw]

Hope this game reviews really well. Never seen such unwarranted hate for a game, and especially a timed exclusive.

Give me a predicted meta score,

I got 82%

 

[Roufianos]

I can see it getting an 85 or so. Can't say I'm too excited for it buy I'll probably pick it up at some point.

 

[Banjo64]

Give me a predicted meta score,

I got 82%

I’d say between 82 and 85.

I think some reviewers might boost their scores due to the user reaction Prey received.

 

[Arun1910]

I wanted 4 more trailers before release

 

[sircaw]

I’d say between 82 and 85.

I think some reviewers might boost their scores due to the user reaction Prey received.

Right, it's a bet, if I am right you take a ban.

If you are right, we contact the mods to ban Riky

 

[Banjo64]

Right it's a deal, if I am right you take a ban.

If you are right, we contact the mods to ban Riky

What if we are both right and it’s 82?

 

[sircaw]

What if we are both right and it’s 82?

We get each other banned, Dammit.

Riky still goes lol

This deal sucks haha

 

[Star-Lord]

I’m expecting nothing but praise for this game, given it’s by Arkane. It looks seriously fun.

 

[Moonjt9]

Really curious how this game will be received. I was definitely tired of seeing trailers for this game all year, but maybe it’s a really good game.

 

[GymWolf]

I expect the usual "fantastic game that nobody buy" out of 10.

 

[Gameplaylover]

I’d say between 82 and 85.

I think some reviewers might boost their scores due to the user reaction Prey received.

I say 78-82.

I think some reviewers might lower their scores for the same reasons it's hated on GAF.

 

[Freeman76]

Impressions from people who got it early have been overwhelmingly positive. I didnt give a shit about this game until 2 days ago I actually sat and watched a trailer and it looked like a wierd combo of Hitman and Goldeneye. If it reviews well I'm in! Its this or tales of arise so i cant lose. Great times for gaming

 

[DonJorginho]

I have seen nothing but overwhelmingly positive hands-on impressions from reviewers and players alike.

Which means this game will get a 80 Metacritic and will only be praised universally once enough people buy it on sale 18 months down the line.

 

[GymWolf]

Let's just hope they have an FOV Slider on launch for PS5 as that 65 FOV is sending me on my own kind of Deathloop..

There is no fov slider on ps5.

 

[DonJorginho]

There is no fov slider on ps5.

There isn't yet I'm aware, crossing my fingers for it to be in a Day One Patch.

I'll still enjoy the game regardless but will take some mighty adjusting at first.

 

[Lanrutcon]

I think this game will received a "It's cool but where is Dishonored 3?" out of 10. But that's not what the reviewers will write, even though they want to.

 

[El Pistolero]

It will review well and sell poorly, imo. I would like to be proven wrong, but the combination of FPS/Unknown IP/Quirky gameplay mechanics that are difficult to explain via video might limit its reach.