2blackcats
Member
Yeah a little under a week, it was posted on September 2nd, and lasted until about an hour prior to the digital release of the game at midnight Sept 9th, west coast time.
The first page of OT2 contains 100 posts in the span of under 3 minutes, a rate of more than one post every 2 seconds. This was obviously before it was possible to have LFG posts or even talk about playing the actual game.
This is where all the trouble began.
I don't think a dedicated thread for LFG requests is necessary and if the issue was that Discord has reduced the activity level in this thread on the whole, I don't think further fragmentation into mulitple threads would help.
LFG requests weren't actually ever the majority of posts in an OT statistically speaking, even if it may have felt like because of the sheer volume of posters participating. What those posts did accomplish, to the community's benefit in my opinion, was bump the thread frequently and successively even if there was no "news" to discuss, which enabled lively discussions and sustained engagement- even if sometimes hard to follow. I can sympathize with the idea that it cluttered the thread, and the speed and volume of discussion did lead to a lot of repeated questions and retreading of ideas, but then this in turn led to the creation of FAQs and guides to address common topics, which were able to help out a greater number of individual posters than a slower-paced thread would have in total.
If having LFG posts within the thread is actually frowned upon by the mods or anything then a dedicated thread is a good idea because I will never expect everyone in the community to use Discord. But if not, I always considered them a net positive.
Great post.