This Dusk Soldier swing was incredible. Where were some of you guys? Did you guys miss this exchange?
Ultron87 claims he is Giselle. The one from Enchanted that Seath is heavily breadcrumbing himself to be.
1. Why would a scum fake Ultron87 counterclaim this?
2. Why would Seath pretend to be someone he isn't? It's provoked an unnecessary name claim already, and it could've done more damage than that if Ultron87 wasn't seasoned and knew how to handle that scenario.
I don't know what Seath is doing, but do you really think Scum doesn't have fake claims afte rthat desaster that Harry Potter was? I fully believe Ultron that he's Giselle, but unless Seath is some kind of Minion, I don't see how Scum would make that play. He could also be Neutral.
If you insist of bolding the vote, please put the bold datgs outside the highlight tags, because right now your vote is counted as a vote for "Seath</b>".
Ok beauties, you've convince me to get behind lynching Seath. I'm trying to keep up and maybe terra is sounding a bit scummy, but the arguments against Seath are pretty convincing. Hoping we don't kill another of our own here, being down four on the third day would be a rough start but not impossible to come back from.
Vote: Seath
What changed to yesterday? Why did you think "No Lynch" was better than Seath and why do you now think Seath is better than "No Lynch". There is literally no new information about Seath since yesterday.
And for the record, this is the actual story, why only AbsolutBro can see it is beyond me.
My first post this phase obviously showed I got it, but I wanted you to explicitly confirm it? What on earth do you gain by never stating "We killed flatearthpanda" and instead potentially confusing some players by just hinting to it. I'll admit the hints were pretty on the nose, and I think every single player in here should have seen it, but I still don't see the motivation behind it at all.
Have to re-read the thread and look for some hint why Flatearthpandas was the target during night 1. My guess is that he was picked random.
Yeah. I wouldn't look into panda's read lists too heavily. In fact, I might be tempted to say there might be scum in his town list. I feel like scum were just aiming for an easy, suspicion-less target that might hold a power role.
Are you two even reading the thread? I take my last statement back. Maybe we should post what actually happened in italic, bold, underlined and highlighted at the same time.
Oh, and while we"re at it, let me quote that Zatoth post again in it's entirety:
Have to re-read the thread and look for some hint why Flatearthpandas was the target during night 1. My guess is that he was picked random.
The "Lovers" would have been an obvious target. So attacking them would involve high risk, as was already mentioned. I wouldn't have touched them with a ten-foot pole during night 1.
Don't see a reason not to believe them at the moment. They may be neutral. But doubt they are Mafia. Would be an incredible bold move to pull off though.
I still think Seath bread-crumbing is highly suspicious. But he also looks like an easy target. And easy targets tend to turn out Town. So I want to give them some time to explain themselves before I vote against them. Day is still young.
You do realize you voted for the "easy target" yesterday and said you'd keep your vote there. If you thought Seath was Scum yesterday, why don't you think he's Scum now? Why are you only expecting an explanation from him today and not yesterday where you just voted for him?
I also want to point out that Zatoth again is just retelling events and parroting other players after he said literally nothing of substance yesterday. I think he's Scum.
If Seath flips town or neutral, then this discussion may be in favor of scum and they may be just letting it happen. I agree with Terra's reasoning that the early days isn't the time for scum to be making bold plays; they'll be laying low letting town follow false leads and generally itself. I also personally doubt that scum would vote for its teammates at this stage of the game, no one wants to risk a potential swing in votes when the "trend" is already favoring them just to gain some town points. Too risky. Keep in mind the simplest explanation is often the likeliest one.
The whole calmness of yesterday (apart from Terra who at this point is an almost confirmed Townie) makes me think neither of the two lynch candidate was Scum (known to the main team). We really should start scumhunting and stop picking on the easy targets.