-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
DisneyPrincess Mafia |OT| Mirror, Mirror on the Wall, Whos the Scummiest of Them All
- Thread starter YesNOnoNOYes
- Start date
weemadarthur
Member
All the ones I thought I saw in people's posts were apparently wrong, so I must be bad at finding them.
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
He's a prince in the Disney film, and is there for all of 2 scenes at the very end.
Dude just stop. Ariel swims out into the fucking ocean every night. Isn't that a claim going around? Where are you then, flavor police?
Lone_Prodigy
Member
There was also that movie with the girl from Twilight.
weemadarthur
Member
The Huntsman is canon. He works for the evil queen, who is apparently named Grimhilde, which is stated in that wiki but I don't recall it in the movie.
With regard to Snow White, canon says he hides her but he never obeys her. He does it because he's a decent person.
Unless you meant that other movie with kristen stewart.
Unmasked Ferret
Member
Ughhh. I'm in class now be back later.
unvote
unvote
AbsolutBro
Member
So your defense is now, I'm an important role and instead of shutting the fuck up and keeping quiet I decided to gambit instead?
This is amazingly difficult on mobile.
The huntsman is part of the original lore, but in the Disney story it is a prince that saves her I believe.
weemadarthur
Member
No, the Huntsman has scenes in the beginning. He's the bearded guy. He gives the queen a pig heart rather than a human girl heart, so she kills him. The Prince doesn't have many scenes, but he's the pretty boy. I think his pic was posted in this thread somewhere.
Disney Extended Universe is intense and puts Star Wars to shame.
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
CURRENT VOTE TALLY:
Darryl (7)
AbsolutBro .805
TheExodu5 .814
Septimus Prime .873
Barrylocke .910
Royal_Flush .1013
Terrabyte20xx .1047
weemadarthur .1055
AbsolutBro (6)
Darryl .958
gryvan .968
Trigger .1008
StackpoleH .1011
Zatoth .1021
Christina Mackenzie .1078
Christina Mackenzie (4)
Mazre .1030
Seath .1085
Lone_Prodigy .1094
Fireblend .1106
Seath (2)
Freakinchair .561
Euphemism .572
TheExodu5 (1)
Enker .744
Septimus Prime (0)
Zatoth (0)
Euphemism (0)
Terrabyte20xx (0)
gryvan (0)
GreatCharleston (0)
weemadarthur (0)
Enker (0)
ultron87 (0)
Trigger (0)
No active vote for Day 2:
ultron87 (has previously voted)
Unmasked Ferret (has previously voted)
Day 2 ends:
12 votes for majority
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
Lone_Prodigy
Member
Self-explanatory.
Wikipedia:
From Sun Tzu's Art of War. On the Wikipedia entry on Sleeping Beauty:
So unless I'm totally off, Christina is breadcrumbing Sleeping Beauty (Aurora).
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
That's my point of the Crab Scale, it's getting ridiculous. If these are actual flavor then it needs to stop.
It's just flavor. It's meant to be fun. It's not supposed to be used for deduction.
weemadarthur
Member
Freakinchair, have you even voted today? That post is so old it looks like it's from end of Day 1.
Seriously? Why are you making suspected scums arguments for them?
Lone_Prodigy
Member
Current votes are 7 for Darryl, 6 for AB, and 4 for CM.
Scum will sit on a Darryl vote. If necessary, vote out AB to spare Darryl for one night.
Unless... we start another bandwagon.
Scum will sit on a Darryl vote. If necessary, vote out AB to spare Darryl for one night.
Unless... we start another bandwagon.
Lone_Prodigy
Member
The posts are there for everyone to see.
Indeed. Stringing them together into a claim should be left to the person who makes the claim. You're basically helping to construct an out for them.
It doesn't make sense. CM was saying he was Anastasia.
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
Why can nothing in this game make sense anymore?
Maybe L_P knows Christina isn't scum and wants to be seen as helpful? Because he's scum himself? Eh?
Well there's one reason.....
Freakinchair
Member
Might want to finish reading the thread and try again.
You're not looking good there dude. Maybe finish reading the thread before doing that.
Fuck.
So, either:
1) Daryl made a good town play by claiming a useless role to cover his cop role. Got unlucky as another Wendy was in the game
2) Daryl made a good scum play and is trying to get another role out in the open by having the real Snow White counter-claim.
I'm leaning towards 1, because I don't see why he would claim Wendy in the case of 2.
Unvote
So, either:
1) Daryl made a good town play by claiming a useless role to cover his cop role. Got unlucky as another Wendy was in the game
2) Daryl made a good scum play and is trying to get another role out in the open by having the real Snow White counter-claim.
I'm leaning towards 1, because I don't see why he would claim Wendy in the case of 2.
Unvote
Royal_Flush
Member
Are you fucking kidding me? I hope noone actually believes this last minute roleclaim by Darryl. This is way too late to be sincere! In this light his whole fucking behaviour this dayphase doesn't make the slightest sense! I am going to flip tables if he gets this swung to someone else!
To quote Makai from the Woof2 Scum chat:
To quote Makai from the Woof2 Scum chat:
Vote: Enker
Fuck it. I'm going with my initial suspicion. There's no guarantee what he said (used a night action on me and it did nothing) was true.
I'm travelling for the rest of the day, so this might be my final post.
I'd vote CM, but I want to leave him a chance to defend himself and I won't be around to change my vote.
Fuck it. I'm going with my initial suspicion. There's no guarantee what he said (used a night action on me and it did nothing) was true.
I'm travelling for the rest of the day, so this might be my final post.
I'd vote CM, but I want to leave him a chance to defend himself and I won't be around to change my vote.
He's had a chance to defend himself and has thus far declined to use it.
weemadarthur
Member
Would scum move their vote from Darryl to someone else and then disappear for the rest of the voting time?
1) scum definitely has fake roles, right? So why claim Wendy when the role is in use by someone else?
2) why claim Wendy in the first place at all? He was under no pressure. The only possible benefits are saving Seath and painting himself as town...but why not use one of the fake role names given to scum in that case?
3) if he was trying to fish for a counter claim...why not claim a princess with a likely more powerful role than Wendy?
His claim makes sense. He was saving Seath while hiding his cop role. It was the right play. He just got unlucky.
weemadarthur
Member
Oh yeah, I thought of another one.In the games I've read, there are some pretty typical behaviors when town figures out a scum candidate. Usually there's a mix of:
1. Claim a role. If another player doubts something in it, claim another role to explain why it necessary to lie. Repeat until lynched.
2. Deflect. Pick a player that isn't active, or that no one likes, and try to start a vote on that player.
3. Attack the accuser. If a player found an inconsistency in the scum player's tactics, the scum will try to discredit that player.
4. Insult accusers. If players suggest they may be mafia, scum will try to make the accuser doubt their own arguments, with the goal of getting the accuser to be quiet, or even go as far as backing down on the accusation.
5. Be confusing. Say a bunch of stuff that sounds important but doesn't quite make sense. Aim to get the town team to leave scum for another day, on the basis that if they keep explaining it will eventually make sense.
6. Give up. Posts start to sound defeated and uninterested. Occasionally the scum player will admit they're on the mafia team and ask for a quick vote.
When considering which of two players to vote on, scum tell behavior can be one clue to look at.
I wrote this down for me to look at later, when I reread some more, but if it helps other readers, great!
7. Use role claims of high value so Town is scared to lynch scum player. Push for opposing role claims from Town players in order to get good targets.
8. Fish for any information that scum team is missing. If Town players aren't talking about extra information from role pms and night moves, keep bringing up various theories that could be contradicted by Town information. Has the benefit of distracting uncertain townies from the suspicious behavior of the scum that's been caught.
Christina Mackenzie
Member
I liked your Aurora suggestion Lone_Prodigy but sorry I'm not her. There probably is a real Aurora out there so claiming as her will only get me into more trouble.
Might as well come clean. I'm Princess Anastasia, if I'm lynched or night killed, my killer also dies with me. I attempted to bait mafia by dropping several bread crumbs of Disney characters.
Obvious Aurora role claim.
Giselle role claim, note the comma.
Ariel role claim.
Sun Tzu quote, Mulan role claim.
I decided to role claimed today because I genuinely thought that if I got stuck with a non-Disney role, maybe there were others as well. Also the way I saw the game heading, I was going to be the among the lynch candidates sooner or later. Being a non Disney princess, I stick out too much and many of you already have role claimed. It's was only a matter of time.
Seriously if I were mafia, I'd have a better princess name than Anastasia.
And for the record I never said I was neutral nor did I ever breadcrumb that. The remark about neutrals was genuine advice for new players in the event we would ever need the help of neutrals to win the game. They can't be trusted.
Mazre was the one who said I "breadcrumbed" as Neutral not I. Look it up. And expect him to harp on and on and on about it.
Might as well come clean. I'm Princess Anastasia, if I'm lynched or night killed, my killer also dies with me. I attempted to bait mafia by dropping several bread crumbs of Disney characters.
Obvious Aurora role claim.
Giselle role claim, note the comma.
Tell me how do you feel about crustaceans?
Ariel role claim.
Sun Tzu quote, Mulan role claim.
I decided to role claimed today because I genuinely thought that if I got stuck with a non-Disney role, maybe there were others as well. Also the way I saw the game heading, I was going to be the among the lynch candidates sooner or later. Being a non Disney princess, I stick out too much and many of you already have role claimed. It's was only a matter of time.
Seriously if I were mafia, I'd have a better princess name than Anastasia.
And for the record I never said I was neutral nor did I ever breadcrumb that. The remark about neutrals was genuine advice for new players in the event we would ever need the help of neutrals to win the game. They can't be trusted.
Mazre was the one who said I "breadcrumbed" as Neutral not I. Look it up. And expect him to harp on and on and on about it.
Royal_Flush
Member
Answers to all your questions is that any other character doesn't make any sense as a protector to Tinkerbell. Just because a name isn't listed as fakeclaim it doesn't mean it's in the game. They probably thought there wasn't another character from Peter Pan
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
LESS THAN TWO HOURS TO DELICIOUS BLOOOODY TIEM, PRINCESSES
CURRENT VOTE TALLY:
Darryl (7)
AbsolutBro .805
Terrabyte20xx .807 .957
TheExodu5 .814 .1133
Lone_Prodigy .864 .977
Septimus Prime .873
Barrylocke .910
Seath .915 .936
Darryl .933 .958
Royal_Flush .1013
Seath .1042 .1085
Terrabyte20xx .1047
Fireblend .1050 .1098
weemadarthur .1055
Lone_Prodigy .1061 .1067
Freakinchair .1129
AbsolutBro (6)
Darryl .875 .880
ultron87 .951 .1103
Darryl .958
gryvan .968
Unmasked Ferret .974 .1109
Trigger .1008
StackpoleH .1011
Zatoth .1021
Christina Mackenzie .1078
Christina Mackenzie (3)
Mazre .1030
Seath .1085
Lone_Prodigy .1094
Fireblend .1106 .1139
TheExodu5 (1)
Enker .744
Terrabyte20xx .751 .807
Christina Mackenzie .767 .1078
StackpoleH .769 .924
weemadarthur .776 .1055
Seath (1)
Freakinchair .561 .1129
Euphemism .572
TheExodu5 .575 .660
Septimus Prime .618 .873
Christina Mackenzie .684 .767
Lone_Prodigy .689 .864
Terrabyte20xx .695 .751
Seath .907 .915
Freakinchair (1)
Fireblend .1139
Enker (1)
Darryl .656 .661
TheExodu5 .660 .814
Seath .688 .850
Fireblend .775 .1050
TheExodu5 .1135
Septimus Prime (0)
Darryl .795 .875
Darryl .880 .900
GreatCharleston (0)
Trigger .570 .990
gryvan (0)
Lone_Prodigy .586 .689
Zatoth (0)
weemadarthur .584 .691
weemadarthur (0)
Darryl .900 .933
Terrabyte20xx (0)
StackpoleH .594 .651
Euphemism (0)
Darryl .661 .795
Christina Mackenzie .664 .684
weemadarthur .691 .776
Trigger (0)
Terrabyte20xx .957 .1039
ultron87 (0)
Seath .624 .682
Seath .682 .688
No active vote for Day 2:
ultron87 (has previously voted)
Unmasked Ferret (has previously voted)
Day 2 ends:
12 votes for majority
CURRENT VOTE TALLY:
Darryl (7)
AbsolutBro .805
Septimus Prime .873
Barrylocke .910
Royal_Flush .1013
Terrabyte20xx .1047
weemadarthur .1055
Freakinchair .1129
AbsolutBro (6)
Darryl .958
gryvan .968
Trigger .1008
StackpoleH .1011
Zatoth .1021
Christina Mackenzie .1078
Christina Mackenzie (3)
Mazre .1030
Seath .1085
Lone_Prodigy .1094
TheExodu5 (1)
Enker .744
Seath (1)
Euphemism .572
Freakinchair (1)
Fireblend .1139
Enker (1)
TheExodu5 .1135
Septimus Prime (0)
GreatCharleston (0)
gryvan (0)
Zatoth (0)
weemadarthur (0)
Terrabyte20xx (0)
Euphemism (0)
Trigger (0)
ultron87 (0)
No active vote for Day 2:
ultron87 (has previously voted)
Unmasked Ferret (has previously voted)
Day 2 ends:
12 votes for majority
Pitiful.
AbsolutBro
Member
I'm guessing a few may be scum trying to sneak a lynch through by waiting for a few votes to swing from Darryl to Christina or someone else.
Lone_Prodigy
Member
-Dusk (RIP) as Jane (ordinary, confirmed)
-FEP (RIP) as Alice (ordinary-ish, confirmed)
-Ultron as Giselle
-Darryl as Snow White (cop)
-AbsolutBro as Wendy
-Seath as Tinkerbell
-Exodu5 as Ariel (commuter)
-Enker as someone
-Christina as Anastasia (lynch/night bomb)
-Terrabyte as Elsa (X-shot vig, lover with Anna)
-Septimus as Anna (lover with Elsa)
11/24 have claimed in some way, and it's so convenient that two of them are lovers and two are not going to be targeted at night.
-FEP (RIP) as Alice (ordinary-ish, confirmed)
-Ultron as Giselle
-Darryl as Snow White (cop)
-AbsolutBro as Wendy
-Seath as Tinkerbell
-Exodu5 as Ariel (commuter)
-Enker as someone
-Christina as Anastasia (lynch/night bomb)
-Terrabyte as Elsa (X-shot vig, lover with Anna)
-Septimus as Anna (lover with Elsa)
11/24 have claimed in some way, and it's so convenient that two of them are lovers and two are not going to be targeted at night.
Why bait/breadcrumb multiple characters tho?
There was zero reason for you to claim today. I will gladly call your bluff on lynch bomb. The night kill piece is super scummy.
Christina Mackenzie
Member
I was hedging my bets. I thought they would at least pick one of them up.