Yeah. I drastically edited the OP, due to complaints and confusion, because I genuinely want to have this discussion. If I could delete it all and start over, I would, but I'm trying to clean it up.Wait...did the op really just repost the op?
Yeah. I drastically edited the OP, due to complaints and confusion, because I genuinely want to have this discussion. If I could delete it all and start over, I would, but I'm trying to clean it up.Wait...did the op really just repost the op?
Yeah. I drastically edited the OP, due to complaints and confusion, because I genuinely want to have this discussion. If I could delete it all and start over, I would, but I'm trying to clean it up.
The whole OP that I cut was re-posted to archive and have a link to in the new version.
Yeah. I drastically edited the OP, due to complaints and confusion, because I genuinely want to have this discussion. If I could delete it all and start over, I would, but I'm trying to clean it up.
The whole OP that I cut was re-posted to archive and have a link to in the new version.
I'm just trying to make it more concise and neutral. I don't want people to feel defensive or feel that I'm being condescending.
You take this to it's logical conclusion and you end up making pro-life anti-abortion arguments, hahaAs much as possible, I ensure the meat I eat is humanely made. Obviously most people don't have that luxury.
At the same time, the reality is that if we didn't eat cows and chickens, they would not exist. I find it very difficult to stomach an argument that says that genocide is preferable to suffering, although obviously that argument is there. So I think I would probably eat them in any case.
I see. Have you watched documentaries on porn production's dark side/did you read the article from The Japan Times that I posted in the original post? I guess I am assuming too much in that I believe one would feel guilty knowing those things and enjoying porn, but my questions have also been about why one does not feel guilty while also being educated on the topics. That has, since the original, un-edited post at the beginning, been a clear option that I recognized. When that is the case, I'd like to know why.
So, why is it that you don't feel guilty, despite knowing what the women go through? I'm genuinely asking, and I'm not going to tell you that you should be guilty.
but my questions have also been about why one does not feel guilty while also being educated on the topics
Right, and I don't say that in a defeatist, "let's just give up" way.
I'm genuinely, earnestly saying that in attempting to take a principled, all-encompassing stance, we may cause more harm than good.
Does one require ignorance or cognitive dissonance to take such strong stances, then?
We need to know more, more, more.
By the way, I think this is a great thread. I understand and even relate to how some people naturally become defensive, but it's a good discussion to have!
Now that's cognitive dissonance.I find myself asking this question a lot but here it goes again.
Where do you draw the line?
I didn't make the bed I sleep on nor did I gather or refine the raw materials that went into its creation. I didn't farm for the fruits I eat nor did I gather and filter the water I drink (though I filter tap if that counts). I didn't raise the chickens who eggs I consumed nor did I the cow that went into my fajitas. I didn't build the roads or develop shipping the infrastructure, prop up the businesses I work with, design the vehicle I drive, invest in the R&D in the electronics I use, fight for my country and so on and so on ad infinitum. My job as a freelance illustrator/ graphic artist is completely unnecessary and a luxory to society and my entire existence is predicated on taking advantage of a disproportionate amount of labor and exploitation. It takes thousands of people to keep my lifestyle going and here I am at 3am on neogaf. Surely some of it is exploitative and it's possible people have already died in the process of something I directly take advantage of. And to be alive right here right now surely wars had to have been fought and groups of people made extinct for me to win the biological lottery to even exist.
Why limit myself to feeling guilty about these two specific things? Why is the line drawn here?
I don't think there is anything moral about feeling guilt here for these two specific things. I think it comes from a completely self serving place to cherry pick two instances that make you feel better to bat for.
To answer the question no - I do not feel guilt. Society would have not reached the peaks that allowed us to even have this conversation if it had not been for backs of the exploited and the lives of those who lost. Sure there has been instances where I have looked upon the world and myself in disgust but I know enough to know that if I feel guilt for one thing and not literally everything else I'd be lying to myself one way or another.
See "War on Drugs"
Such a defeatist way of thinking. A single human can have a lot of influence on the world. We are powerful.Again, you're asking the sky to be green. It's irrelevant to the discussion-Even if you showed me the most brutal shit about porn, on how the people are treated, I still probably wouldn't feel guilty watching it. And no, it's not because I don't lack empathy.
Let's look at this.
Because there's a certain point where it's futile to worry about such things. I know about existing slavery in different countries, sex trafficking, poverty, corruption, children being indoctrinated to cause violence, child abuse, etc.
To single out porn since it's one of the two title subjects, saying 'well haven't you seen these documentaries? How could you not feel guilty' is well....futile. I don't feel guilty because I don't associate guilt with it. Just like I don't feel guilty eating meat because I don't associate guilt with it, therefore there's nothing to feel(Guilt, in this case). I'm also not naive in thinking that as a singular person, with little to no influence on this world, will feel like I'm making a change in this world by not partaking in meat and/or porn.
Again, you're asking for something that isn't there. I do not associate these subjects with personal guilt, therefore the only thing I can explain is my thought process on why I don't associate guilt with these things. It's not a matter of 'Why don't you feel guilty', it's a matter of 'why should I, for myself, assign guilt to partaking in these things which I have no control over how it's done.'
Such a defeatist way of thinking. A single human can have a lot of influence on the world. We are powerful.
Defeatist? Closer to morbid realism.
I hate that train of thought-'You are powerful as singular people! One person can change the world!'.
Only very few people can 'change' the world by themselves. Even then, they usually require a network that is there to support them in that change.
Me? I tend to do my own things to be happy. I don't worry about having guilt when I eat meat. Despite the world being a shitty place that's extremely volatile, I continue doing my own thing. That is better than thinking you can change the world, because chances are if you're busy thinking that, then you aren't in a position to change anything.
Would you please elaborate on your thought process? I'm interested in understanding the way others think about this topic!I enjoy both with no regret or feeling of guilt
Think about scale. Yesterday, I changed the world when I bought yoghurt. I displaced the yoghurt. Someone else could have bought it, but I bought it.
If we're going down that route...
Yesterday I found a lotto ticket on the ground. It was current! I could've won the lottery. I didn't win the lottery. I could've done good with that money. But I didn't.
So then I went out and had fun last night and didn't wallow in my sorrow of not winning and being the one.
Potatoes, rice, eggs, lentils. Shit is cheap dude. The replacements are there ... vegetarians don't sit around eating lettuce and tofu all day.Society is not built for a vegetarian lifestyle and it won't be until we actually have a cheap replacement for meat that provides as much as it does in terms of nutrients/taste. I am all for lab grown or synthetic meat and believe it will be the only way the majority of the populace will change habits. As of now though, the majority of the populace cannot afford to eat vegetarian at this point in time (both in terms of time and money). Global society however, cannot afford to be meat based. But there needs to be a significant transition period with all kinds of infrastructure changes before we reach that point.
It will be much easier to replace meat with synthetic meat than it will be to make everyone eat tofu or whatever. Synthetic meat can also integrate into our food production/delivery system in a very non-disruptive way (it doesn't really matter to McDonald's where they get their meat, but McDonald's can't survive without a meat equivalent).
One less ticket to ponder. We're changing the world, yo, one experience at a time.
You with your yogurt and me with my lotto ticket finding expertise.
If we team up, I'm sure we'll reach an event horizon where we find a winning lottery ticket in a cup of yogurt.
Well, it being charming to you made me smile still.OP, I'm afraid you're very (albeit charmingly) naive about how the world works.
Take a greater look at consumerism as a whole. We don't live in a utopia where there are zero ramification to every action we do during our lives.
Well, it being charming to you made me smile still.
I suppose you're right. In a society with such intense consummerism, how can one avoid negatively affecting tons of people by merely living their life normally?
Still, I've learned more just by creating the thread, which is a step in the right direction. I can try to be better.
The thought that we shouldn't do anything, just because each of us has a small impact is not something I can recognize.
Defeatist? Closer to morbid realism.
I hate that train of thought-'You are powerful as singular people! One person can change the world!'.
Only very few people can 'change' the world by themselves. Even then, they usually require a network that is there to support them in that change.
Me? I tend to do my own things to be happy. I don't worry about having guilt when I eat meat. Despite the world being a shitty place that's extremely volatile, I continue doing my own thing. That is better than thinking you can change the world, because chances are if you're busy thinking that, then you aren't in a position to change anything.
Right, and I don't say that in a defeatist, "let's just give up" way.
I never have really understood the sympathy behind doing adult movies because you are desperate for money. Don't get me wrong, thats a horrible situation to be in but it's no different to people who need to take a second job to keep their family or the people who work in fast food beccause they are desperate etc. I'm not trying to discredit those jobs, everyone needs to work but there are also people everywhere who hate their job but need to pay their bills.
In certain coutnries I can see this being exploited but in America for instance there are plenty of jobs for those looking and wiling to do lower end work. Adult movies shouldnt be a go to just because you are desperate
Martin Luther? Anita Sarkeesian? Bernie Sanders?
I mean sure, they did not literally change the world, but they had a big influence on issues and got people to change.
Most people, or at least a lot of people, think there's a pretty big ethical line between selling your own body and selling your skills. It's fine to disagree with that, but it's a valid point of view. I'd also throw a wild guess that selling your own body would be a lot more traumatic for most people than having to do just another normal work even if you hate it.I never have really understood the sympathy behind doing adult movies because you are desperate for money. Don't get me wrong, thats a horrible situation to be in but it's no different to people who need to take a second job to keep their family or the people who work in fast food beccause they are desperate etc. I'm not trying to discredit those jobs, everyone needs to work but there are also people everywhere who hate their job but need to pay their bills.
In certain coutnries I can see this being exploited but in America for instance there are plenty of jobs for those looking and wiling to do lower end work. Adult movies shouldnt be a go to just because you are desperate
I don't want my future food to be sick. Stop it with the antibiotic hate.
Antibiotic abuse and animal abuse should seriously be investigated, but lobbying and just plain budgeting really makes it an imperfect system.
Could you elaborate on this? I can't manage to understand your stance on antibiotics the way you have phrased it.