• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Don’t Let These Myths Scare You Away From a Flu Shot

Status
Not open for further replies.

entremet

Member
http://vitals.lifehacker.com/don-t-let-these-myths-scare-you-away-from-a-flu-shot-1787136173

The flu vaccine isn’t perfect, but you’re still better off getting it than not. In a good year, the flu vaccine is about 70 percent effective; if we’re unlucky, the rate can dip lower.

Two years ago, the shot was only 23 percent effective. Last year’s did better, around 60 percent. The exact rate depends on which strains of flu are circulating in your area, but most years the effectiveness hovers around 50 percent.

Think of it this way: if somebody coughs on you during flu season, wouldn’t you like to have a coin-flip chance of escaping unharmed? Fifty percent is a lot better than zero. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) summarizes: “Influenza vaccination, even when effectiveness is reduced, can prevent thousands of hospitalizations.”

Why are flu shots often ineffective? Other vaccines have better track records: the measles vaccine is 97 percent effective, for example, in children who get both of the recommended doses. Here are a few reasons that make flu vaccine a weird one.

There isn’t just one flu. Flu viruses mutate a lot, so we need a new shot every year. The people who make flu shots have to choose in the spring which strains should go in the shot for that fall and winter, and if they guess wrong, the shot will be less effective. (That’s what happened in 2014, the 23 percent effectiveness year.)
Some people don’t respond well to the vaccine. Flu shots are less effective in children under age 2, and adults over 65. Other factors and health conditions can affect how well you’ll respond.

Are you getting the flu shot this year? If not, why not?
 

WedgeX

Banned
Have gotten it every year since 2011. That year only my supervisor and I got flu shots. The other ten people in our office did not.

The other ten all ended up getting the flu. My supervisor and I did not.
 
I rarely get one, my wife and daughter are both really good about doing it every year but I just get lazy about it. I'm traveling in a couple of weeks so it might not be a bad idea, maybe I will get on that.
 

Pau

Member
I haven't had good experiences with flu shots. I get sick when I get the shot, and then I get sick again a few weeks later anyways. But it seems like I got them when they were less effective?
 

tkscz

Member
I can't seem to catch to flu. Even kissed a girl with the flu and still couldn't catch it. So I never saw the point of getting a flu shot.
 

Trojita

Rapid Response Threadmaker
I missed getting one last year because I was being lazy.

I always have that problem where I have like a mini-flu a day after the shot (probably reaction caused by my immune system), but it's worth getting it.
 
They didn't cover a myth that some relatives of mine believe: Flu shots are linked to more rapid development of Alzheimer's.

Which is weird because they're REALLY not the anti-vacc types at all, it's specifically the flu shot.
 

Ryuukan

Member
Got one every year (just last week at my annual physical) for the past 13 years consecutively, never had the flu

clearly an alarming link between vaccines and not getting sick
 
My wife doesn't do them. But I do every year. Every time she gets the flu I mock her with silly shit like.

"Man, it feels so good to not have the flu, how about you...?"

"Man, this air smells so good without any nasal congestion...so glad I got that flu shot!"

She gets mad. She gets jelly.
 
My wife doesn't do them. But I do every year. Every time she gets the flu I mock her with silly shit like.

"Man, it feels so good to not have the flu, how about you...?"

"Man, this air smells so good without any nasal congestion...so glad I got that flu shot!"

She gets mad. She gets jelly.

My wife does this to me when I skip it and get sick

:p

Spouses.
 

Smokey

Member
I've never gotten one, but I have a 7 month old and it's free at my job. Think I'm going to do ot this year.
 
Never gone for one, but I also haven't been sick in about 3 years, and I think i have only had the flu maybe twice in my life (usually just minor cold symptoms).

Kids and the elderly should for sure though as it can definitely cause complications.
 

Tedesco!

Member
I never got flu shots until 2 years ago when work would bring someone in to give everyone free shots. Got the shots. Got sick. I'm not getting the shots again.
 

farisr

Member
I don't and will never get the flu shot again. Had a terrible reaction to it when I was younger, really messed up my health for a couple of years. I was one of those "1 in a million" severe reactions.

But I encourage everyone else to get it still, and everyone else in my family does.
 

clav

Member
These threads show who are anti-vaccinators on GAF.

Always get the shot as long as I can remember.

Read that hospital workers get theirs in mid-October for maximum effectiveness.
 
I never have, but I'll be starting this year as my best friend was diagnosed with an autoimmune disease recently. So I'll do whatever I can do to help keep him healthy.
 

ido

Member
It's free at my job and I get it every year. Actually just got it today, as it was the first day the nursing students were offering them.

Don't quite understand the "never get sick" posts... Sounds kind of like saying, "I never get in car wrecks, why would I bother wearing a seatbelt?"
 

entremet

Member
These threads show who are anti-vaccinators on GAF.

Always get the shot as long as I can remember.

Read that hospital workers get theirs in mid-October for maximum effectiveness.

I think it's required for many health care pros due to their contact with various at risk demographics--immuno comprised individuals, the very young and old.
 
No, last time I had one I was probably in high school which was years ago. The only time I get sick is when my wife is and it's weird. Anyone else can be sick and I can be around them but when my wife gets sick I will eventually catch it.
 

Ryuukan

Member
No, last time I had one I was probably in high school which was years ago. The only time I get sick is when my wife is and it's weird. Anyone else can be sick and I can be around them but when my wife gets sick I will evntually catch it.

I'm going to wager that you have contact with your wife in ways that are different from other people in your life
 
My wife doesn't do them. But I do every year. Every time she gets the flu I mock her with silly shit like.

"Man, it feels so good to not have the flu, how about you...?"

"Man, this air smells so good without any nasal congestion...so glad I got that flu shot!"

She gets mad. She gets jelly.

lol

Don't think I've had mine yet, but I do every year. I'd rather not take a week off work (cause I work in a hospital and taking sickness to work is dangerous).
 
No, last time I had one I was probably in high school which was years ago. The only time I get sick is when my wife is and it's weird. Anyone else can be sick and I can be around them but when my wife gets sick I will eventually catch it.

I assume those other people aren't in your home all the time getting their germs all over everything you own. That's probably why.
 

gohepcat

Banned
1. I got one and my coworker didn't and he got the flu
2. I got one and my co-worker didn't and I got the flu

Both of these have nothing to do with why you should get the flu shot.

You can't get sick from the flu shot. I realize people are going to shit on me for this, but you just can't, and none of you have (barring an allergic reaction to eggs).

You are exposed to about 15 thousand antigens every day. The flu shot is a drop in an ocean. It just adds a single entry in a huge database along with the 15,000 others you will get that same day.

but I got sick because of my flu shot

No you didn't. You got sick after you got a flu shot from something unrelated.

but even doctors say you can have a mild reaction

Doctors will never say something is 100% safe or effective. No scientist will. It's just not the way they are wired. The number of reactions to the flu shot fall under the margin of error. They are statistical anomalies.

Also Ron Paul is a medical doctor and he thinks flu shots are some sort of government boondoggle. Some doctors are just fucking idiots.
 
I've twice had the flu without getting the flu shot (about 15 & 20 years ago). The first time I didn't have insurance...the second, I was still on the probationary period at a new job and insurance hadn't started yet. The second time was the worst...I gained full blown pneumonia on top of it. Took me a month to recover...and I still had to work (factory jobs suck about giving time off for illness).

Ever since then I've always gotten the flu shot (it helps to not work in factories any more...office job now). Even when I catch the flu in spite of the shot (I know how the shots work, I know the shot didn't "give" me the flu, I caught a flu strain not covered by the shot) its been way easier to manage. Even two years ago with the low effectiveness rate and the particularly nasty strains of flu that year...still easier then what I delt with 15 years ago.

So, yes...I get the shot every year.
 

-Plasma Reus-

Service guarantees member status
Best to get sick every year.
I skipped 2 years. And I nearly died this year. Throat swelling up, preventing breathing, had to go to hospital and get cameras down my throat twice.
 

DJ_Lae

Member
Always get it - there's no good reason not to, especially when it's free.

Anything that might help prevent me from getting it, or passing it to my kids. They all get it too.
 
I haven't had the flu shot ever. Only ever had the flu once when I was about 8. Until last year. I had it bad. 3 days of sleeping or waking up not knowing what the hell was going on, it was awful.

Definitely getting the shot this year.
 
lol

Don't think I've had mine yet, but I do every year. I'd rather not take a week off work (cause I work in a hospital and taking sickness to work is dangerous).

I'm on the train and subway constantly. Mofos is nasty. I need protection against the mofo pick his nose then smear his hand on the pole.

I'll usually take my chances. I'm no anti vaxxer but the effectiveness seems so random.

70% is random???
 
Haven't had a flu shot since my freshman year of college, which was way back in 2000.

The last time I actually had the flu? You guessed it: 2000.

Haven't had either since.
 

Guevara

Member
I'm on the train and subway constantly. Mofos is nasty. I need protection against the mofo pick his nose then smear his hand on the pole.



70% is random???
We wish we could get to 70%

And yeah, pretty random

R30qDlQ.png
 
Before I moved to the US I used to get sick almost every year (I'd get a break maybe every 4 or 5 years.)

I've been getting the shot every year since moved here (no such luxury in my country.) Since then I've only gotten sick twice.
 

ido

Member
Haven't had a flu shot since my freshman year of college, which was way back in 2000.

The last time I actually had the flu? You guessed it: 2000.

Haven't had either since.

But don't you think that's a little like saying...

Last time I had a car wreck: 2000
Last time I wore a seatbelt: 2000

The shot didn't give you the flu, and not getting the flu shot isn't helping you not get the flu. You might as well get the shot, just like you might as well wear a seatbelt, even if you haven't had an accident in 20 years.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom