2020 called and wants its fact checking methods back.
What i mean is, when you write that on a technical level something is true, then it is not a false strawman (or false for any other reason).
I know what you mean; I just had trouble phrasing that part the right way :S His point was right in a surface level way, but it wasn't a good argument to make in defense of timed exclusives because of the complicated nature of how the benefit of timed exclusives work for the platform which has them.
It also isn't a 100% steadfast rule because timed exclusivity deals can be extended as per the terms of the contract, we've just seen this happen recently with FFVII on Xbox & PC. It should've came out for those last month but Sony extended the timed exclusivity period and who's to say they can't extend it again?
The false strawman was more to his point of trying to justify timed exclusives over studio acquisitions for platform exclusivity because his items of use to support it were incredibly flimsy .
Adding to your Psygnosis post, Psygnosis published first Drakan game which was a PC game but the sequel to that game (Ancient Gates) was PS2 exclusive (and bombed). If you wanted to play the sequel you had to buy PS2, no alternatives. At least Xbox is giving you multiple options (XBox Consoles + PC and that Valve Handheld if they are actually making it + Cloud). I'm sure they even want to bring it to Switch i feel like.
Dang I didn't even know that :S
People keep forgetting the alternative methods for delivery Microsoft actually provide, so it's good to list them as a reminder. Some of those may not be the optimal way to play those games, for sure, but they are still there as options and really meant to compliment the Xbox/PC method (IMO, at this time), not replace them.