Muppet of a Man
Member
Bloodborne is robbed.
Definitely. Best game ever made.
Bloodborne is robbed.
FE Fates over Awakening is when I stopped reading. So much promise.
Wow. Really good list. As with any list there are lots of things I'd change, but it's great to see Witness, F-Zero GX, Last Guardian, Demons Souls and others get their due.
Most glaring omissions are Mega Man X, Majora's Mask and Bloodborne.
These "all time" lists are just going to continue to get more ridiculous as time goes on. Of course Breath of the Wild is better than Chrono Trigger. It was made by a team with 10x the people for a system with orders of magnitude more computing power and with 20+ years of game design evolution behind it. It is simply absurd to compare games across eras like this.
I don't see the problem with acknowledging that games improve over time.These "all time" lists are just going to continue to get more ridiculous as time goes on. Of course Breath of the Wild is better than Chrono Trigger. It was made by a team with 10x the people for a system with orders of magnitude more computing power and with 20+ years of game design evolution behind it. It is simply absurd to compare games across eras like this.
67. EarthBound
Oh shitCheck the top-5 again. : p
Ctrl+F Nier...
My opinion doesn't line up with their opinion. Throw it in the bin!
I stopped reading at Far Cry 4
Only one Final Fantasy and it's XII? LMFAO
Don't get me wrong, I like FFXII and it would be in my Top 50, but it wouldn't be in my Top 5 FF games, and that's the ONLY one worthy in Edge's Top 100? Come on.
FE Fates over Awakening is when I stopped reading. So much promise.
Nah.
They don't even have FFT, but they have Advance War?!?!?!?
They got that part rightNah.
It isn't even about opinion.
Sometimes, an opinion can be so wrong that it is false. Like this list.
They don't even have Chrono Trigger or FF6/7 but they have FF12??!?!?!?
They don't even have WoW, a genre that stole thousands of hours from millions of players for over a decade.
Even if the game wasn't their taste, it is a game that defined a whole generation due to its massive reach in mainstream.
Hell...Millions are still playing this MMO today...so yeah.
Advance Wars is better than FFT if you ask me. It's a brilliant Strategy game.
They got that part right
The whole point of lists is an expression of taste. Otherwise you might as well make a best sellers list or copy-paste a metacritic list
Tearaway on that list but no Gravity Rush......okay?
Yeah, Tearaway is way better as much as I like GR. I thought that was common consensus tbhTearaway on that list but no Gravity Rush......okay?
Are you serious?
AW has zero story, and just a number game.
How is it a brilliant strategy game?
It is marketed toward kids because the game mechanics are basically just rock/paper/scissors.
I didn't think FFT was a GOAT matetial game. I restarted that game three time because the level scaling and unbeatable scenarios.Are you serious?
AW has zero story, and just a number game.
How is it a brilliant strategy game?
It is marketed toward kids because the game mechanics are basically just rock/paper/scissors.
... each game had to stand up today rather than making the cut for reasons of nostalgia or historic significance.
Are you serious?
AW has zero story, and just a number game.
How is it a brilliant strategy game?
It is marketed toward kids because the game mechanics are basically just rock/paper/scissors.
Couldn't even remember if the game was hard or not.
All I remember was spamming missiles and going in with tanks.
Opinions and all that yadda yadda....... but seriously Breath of the Wild, while a good game, does not deserve to be listed as the greatest of all time. I can't get behind their reasoning.
Nah.
It isn't even about opinion.
Sometimes, an opinion can be so wrong that it is false. Like this list.
They don't even have Chrono Trigger or FF6/7 but they have FF12??!?!?!?
They don't even have Starcraft, but they have SC2??!?!?!?!?!
They don't even have WC3, but they have DoTA?!?!?!??!
They don't even have FFT, but they have Advance War?!?!?!?
They don't even have WoW, a genre that stole thousands of hours from millions of players for over a decade.
Even if the game wasn't their taste, it is a game that defined a whole generation due to its massive reach in mainstream.
Hell...Millions are still playing this MMO today...so yeah.