Elon Musk's Iron Man UI

Status
Not open for further replies.

GusBus

Member
Searched, didn't see anything yet.
This is some very cool stuff.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xNqs_S-zEBY

Edit: Article from Teh Verge

The workspace of the future is in Elon Musk’s lab. Using a variety of virtual reality and gesture-sensing tools, Musk has set up a system that allows himself and his engineers to design and manipulate rocket parts using just their hands. He's compared it to the Iron Man laboratory, and in many ways, it looks like just that.

But you won't need the technological expertise of Tony Stark in order to make one: Musk employs a Leap Motion Controller, an Oculus Rift, and a projector — among other common tools — in order to make the setup work. Not all of those are necessarily being used at once though. Musk says that he began with the Leap Motion, but then moved on to more advanced setups, such as one that involved projecting 3D mockups onto a translucent piece of glass.



While Musk admits that it's partially just "a fun way to interact with a complex model," he thinks that this new setup could mean far more than that. "I believe we're on the verge of a major breakthrough in design and manufacturing." Musk demonstrates how using the Leap he can fully move and rotate the object by just swiping, opening, and closing his hands.

"WE'RE ON THE VERGE OF A MAJOR BREAKTHROUGH."

Musk says that this virtual reality workspace is important because it allows users to "really apply your intuition." He believes that the entire setup will allow users to "take something from your mind to a physical object with far greater ease than we currently do." In a video demonstrating the setup, he explains how this could work, using the example of a cryogenic valve housing being designed. Musk shows someone moving its model on a screen by shifting their hand in the air.

While this could be seen as a disappointingly low-tech approach to Musk's grand promise of an Iron Man-style lab, the entrepreneur seems to see these new tools as the future of engineering. 3D printing will also play a big role in allowing those prototypes to be quickly tested and iterated upon. Musk certainly doesn't see these as simple novelties: "It’s going to revolutionize design and manufacturing in the 21st century."

http://www.theverge.com/2013/9/5/4699214/elon-musk-iron-man-lab-revealed-video
 
Really cool concept, top rated comment made me laugh too:

"My theory: Tony Stark was working in his lab in the Marvel-verse and accidentally opened up a Space-Time rift that sucked him in and then deposited him in our universe. Quickly realizing that Tony Stark was a comic character here he instead adopted the identity "Elon Musk" and has since spent his time revolutionizing everything."
 
Pretty neat and all, but when it comes to actually designing something, I would crush them with a KB/M.
 
Damn that's pretty cool.

Why do we not have cool iron-man style 3D hologram projections yet? They seems like it should be one of the more doable sci-fi tropes.
 
Pretty cool stuff. I love the 3D printing though, always looks and sounds awesome.
 
It's cool to see someone working on this, but I think we're still really really far off from it being practical as a real alternative for creating 3d models, etc.

What's great about a wacom/mouse/keyboard combination is you get hundreds of motions and functions without moving your arms and hands very much. This makes it really fast once you learn it, and you don't get tired. It's way more efficient, even though there's a learning curve. People are really keen to remove the tools and just use your hands, but is that really the most efficient way? These demos look really slow and clunky. Look how cumbersome it seems just to rotate an object, and there's a lot of lag. Again, it's a sweet idea, but I think we'll see it more in theme parks and interactive demos rather than as a serious creation tool.
 
Really cool concept, top rated comment made me laugh too:

"My theory: Tony Stark was working in his lab in the Marvel-verse and accidentally opened up a Space-Time rift that sucked him in and then deposited him in our universe. Quickly realizing that Tony Stark was a comic character here he instead adopted the identity "Elon Musk" and has since spent his time revolutionizing everything."

I mean really, what sort of name is Elon Musk anyway?
 
Really cool concept, top rated comment made me laugh too:

"My theory: Tony Stark was working in his lab in the Marvel-verse and accidentally opened up a Space-Time rift that sucked him in and then deposited him in our universe. Quickly realizing that Tony Stark was a comic character here he instead adopted the identity "Elon Musk" and has since spent his time revolutionizing everything."

Maybe Musk is like that guy in Bioshock Infinite who peers through portals into other realities and steals their ideas
 
Wow I excepted a lot more. This is nothing special and nothing new. I've used technology just like this and some stuff even better at research exhibitions. I dont see the leap here beyond what we already have. Long way to go before actual Iron Man UI.
 
Hater gunna hate
I'm not a hater, I love the stuff he's doing. But this is him just testing out a bunch of other people's products, as you'd expect him to do. I guess one should give him credit for being open about this very early stage, but there is nothing substantial being demonstrated here.
 
3D printing a titanium rocket piece is cool.

Awkwardly fumbling around with a 3D projection of it, dealing with the imprecision and input delay of a camera system and the lack of physical feedback in the process is not cool.
 
3D printing a titanium rocket piece is cool.

Awkwardly fumbling around with a 3D projection of it, dealing with the imprecision and input delay of a camera system and the lack of physical feedback in the process is not cool.

I wonder if they are using the printer for prototyping or for making functioning pieces.
 
There are probably dozens of computer science departments that have similar prototypes using wii controllers, kinect, hydras, leap motion etc. there's absolutely nothing new here. The stuff he's doing with the leap in that video is pretty much a one week student project. Smoke and mirrors.
 
I was wondering if we had a guy who was like that who would do all of the innovating and drive us in some kind of cool future. He is like a super engineer like Tony Stark. Now who is going to be our Reed Richards that's what I want to know?

Awesome stuff, I wonder how many jobs will come of applications such as those?
 
The more I look into NUI, the more it seems to me that it's incredibly efficient at enabling communication of and interaction with volume intensive qualitative information, while sacrificing effectiveness of similar vectors for granular quantitative information. Pushing for one over the other is essentially forcing a search for the inflection point where raw quantified data input outweighs the efficiencies of the qualitative input; I feel like there has to be a hybrid interaction mechanic to be discovered somewhere.

Also, the leap motion I played with was much less responsive than his. :(
 
Awkwardly fumbling around with a 3D projection of it, dealing with the imprecision and input delay of a camera system and the lack of physical feedback in the process is not cool.

Yes, seemed more useful for manipulating and viewing an existing design rather than creating from scratch and seriously modifying anything.

Still, you have to start somewhere.

Throw in voice commands and you start opening up the possibilities.
 
This looks like it would be really annoying, laggy and imprecise. Doing things in Maya like this would slow me down greatly. A pointing device resting on a solid surface and buttons is still very intuitive and fast and won't be replaced anytime soon. Current methods aren't nearly as in unintuitive as he tries to make it sound. Besides, aside from the VR immersion, he's not actually interacting with it in a different way. His hands are simply in the air instead of on the desk. I'm all for something like this eventually but until its as precise and responsive as current methods it will just be a cumbersome novelty.
 
There are already 3D styluses that are lag-free and way, way more accurate. This sort of stuff is neat, but the "revolution" part won't come until there are accurate 3D projections that you can interact with via a touch interface. The hand gestures shown seem just about as intuitive as a keyboard and mouse. But if these videos get some support for pushing all that tech forward, then go for it. Let's see some holograms, Musk.
 
He even looks uncomfortable using it.

You can't fool me Elon. You can't fool me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom