So, I was just trying to steal a [it's a monster you hunt], but every time I've gone in to confront him, I've stolen some other, more common, item and been told that there were no more items.Wyvern Wing from the Wyvern Lord
Enemies only have one item you can steal from them, when you've stolen it, they have nothing else to steal
In the case of Wyvern Lord, there's only a 3% chance that item will be a Wyvern Wing
[55%] Yensa Scale
[10%] Crooked Fang
[3%] Wyvern Wing
With a Thief's Cuff equipped:
[80%] Yensa Scale
[30%] Crooked Fang
[6%] Wyvern Wing