• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Fitness |OT3| BroScience, Protein Dysentery, XXL Calf Implants, and Squat Rack Hogs

Status
Not open for further replies.

deadbeef

Member
I find it takes a lot of focus to do step-ups at all. Doing them without pushing with the foot/leg on the floor takes a generous helping of humblesauce.

Doing them high-rep must suck, but yeah, better than lunges. Either of them are taxing enough (when done with sufficient weight) to make most any man say "Fuck this" and hit the leg press instead.

Yeah. 95 lbs is plenty for me (5 sets of 20). I have to do all the left leg then all the right leg or else I get all jumbled up.
 
D

Deleted member 12837

Unconfirmed Member
I'm switching from 3 sets of dips to failure to 3 sets of weighted dips that I can progressively add weight to like my other main lifts. How many reps do you guys usually do? Does it fall under the 3x5 scheme or do you do something more like 3x8 since it's an accessory exercise?
 

Brolic Gaoler

formerly Alienshogun
I'm switching from 3 sets of dips to failure to 3 sets of weighted dips that I can progressively add weight to like my other main lifts. How many reps do you guys usually do? Does it fall under the 3x5 scheme or do you do something more like 3x8 since it's an accessory exercise?

IMO if you can't do 20 dips straight without stopping I wouldn't add weight.

Otherwise, I wouldn't add any more weight than you can do 10+ times.

At a certain point you may end up adding weight and compromising form. Those two stipulations may save you from that.
 
D

Deleted member 12837

Unconfirmed Member
IMO if you can't do 20 dips straight without stopping I wouldn't add weight.

Otherwise, I wouldn't add any more weight than you can do 10+ times.

At a certain point you may end up adding weight and compromising form. Those two stipulations may save you from that.

Hmm OK good to know, maybe I'll hold off then. I'm at around 17-12-7 for my 3 sets unweighted right now. I can wait until I hit 20 in that first set before adding weight, and do 3 sets of 10 once I get to that point.
 

Brolic Gaoler

formerly Alienshogun
Hmm OK good to know, maybe I'll hold off then. I'm at around 17-12-7 for my 3 sets unweighted right now. I can wait until I hit 20 in that first set before adding weight, and do 3 sets of 10 once I get to that point.

Yeah, I cut out weighted dips and do body weight atm and I'm at 20+ dips. I could probably do around 25-30 the first set, but until I can do 3 sets of 20 body weight I probably won't add any weight.
 

Izick

Member
Okay, so I've been lifting for a little over 4 years now, so I think I have a good idea about what's going on, but I had a question for FitGAF.

I've been told that for getting bigger, the best thing to do is mix up your routine completely every week.

Basically, what I've been doing is been going heavy with 8 reps per set, but I was informed that every other week, it's best to switch to a different amount of reps, like 15 per set.

That, and it's good to switch up the exercises you do every week, for example: do BB bench press 1 week, then the next week switch that up by doing DB, or something along those lines.

So, my dear FitGAF, what is the truth to these things?
 

Mr.City

Member
Okay, so I've been lifting for a little over 4 years now, so I think I have a good idea about what's going on, but I had a question for FitGAF.

I've been told that for getting bigger, the best thing to do is mix up your routine completely every week.

Basically, what I've been doing is been going heavy with 8 reps per set, but I was informed that every other week, it's best to switch to a different amount of reps, like 15 per set.

That, and it's good to switch up the exercises you do every week, for example: do BB bench press 1 week, then the next week switch that up by doing DB, or something along those lines.

So, my dear FitGAF, what is the truth to these things?

I've been told that for getting bigger, the best thing to do is mix up your routine completely every week.

This unfortunately has some shreds of truth lost in misinformation. It's true that as you progress, your programming will have to change, however this is based on the lifter's ability to progress. For example, you wouldn't follow a program that has you working for monthly gains when you are capable of making gains workout to workout. What you're talking about is based on an arbitrary idea what "needs to be done."

Your body doesn't adapt and resist a movement, rather it requires a great amount of stress in order to force a change. For example, benching 200x5x3 on Monday, and then going 205x5x3 on Friday, and so on...
 

grumble

Member
Okay, so I've been lifting for a little over 4 years now, so I think I have a good idea about what's going on, but I had a question for FitGAF.

I've been told that for getting bigger, the best thing to do is mix up your routine completely every week.

Basically, what I've been doing is been going heavy with 8 reps per set, but I was informed that every other week, it's best to switch to a different amount of reps, like 15 per set.

That, and it's good to switch up the exercises you do every week, for example: do BB bench press 1 week, then the next week switch that up by doing DB, or something along those lines.

So, my dear FitGAF, what is the truth to these things?

Best thing for getting bigger is to systematically add weight or reps to the same movements over time. Compound movements are better, and weight increases are easier to sustain than rep increases.

This means limited inter-week variation, to allow for systematic progress (unless advanced lifter).

Food is necessary. Eat lots of protein and nutritious calories.
 

Izick

Member
I've been told that for getting bigger, the best thing to do is mix up your routine completely every week.

This unfortunately has some shreds of truth lost in misinformation. It's true that as you progress, your programming will have to change, however this is based on the lifter's ability to progress. For example, you wouldn't follow a program that has you working for monthly gains when you are capable of making gains workout to workout. What you're talking about is based on an arbitrary idea what "needs to be done."

Your body doesn't adapt and resist a movement, rather it requires a great amount of stress in order to force a change. For example, benching 200x5x3 on Monday, and then going 205x5x3 on Friday, and so on...

So should I just stick with what I've been doing so far? (Meaning heavier weight, 8 reps)
 

Izick

Member
Best thing for getting bigger is to systematically add weight or reps to the same movements over time. Compound movements are better, and weight increases are easier to sustain than rep increases.

This means limited inter-week variation, to allow for systematic progress (unless advanced lifter).

Food is necessary. Eat lots of protein and nutritious calories.

I've been doing and heading the advice that you have listed before, but I must admit it's hard for a college student to try and eat enough. I try to always get enough bang for my buck protein wise when I eat though. (Always get milk, eggs, meat or something into every meal; but I will miss breakfast/lunch occasionally ]: )
 

Brolic Gaoler

formerly Alienshogun
Wow, for bench I adjusted how I arch my back more like how EFTS guys do it (feet closer to the middle of your back on your toes and trying to push your heels down) and now my ass (literally) is sore, lol.
 

grumble

Member
I've been doing and heading the advice that you have listed before, but I must admit it's hard for a college student to try and eat enough. I try to always get enough bang for my buck protein wise when I eat though. (Always get milk, eggs, meat or something into every meal; but I will miss breakfast/lunch occasionally ]: )

It's not really hard for a college student to eat enough; in fact, it's easier than it is at most other points in your life.

Wake up early instead of five minutes before class, buy an unlimited meal plan for your school cafeteria, and binge as much as possible to hit your goals. It's not expensive, it's convenient and you can fit it around your schedule.
 

Slayer-33

Liverpool-2
Wow, for bench I adjusted how I arch my back more like how EFTS guys do it (feet closer to the middle of your back on your toes and trying to push your heels down) and now my ass (literally) is sore, lol.

Feels like I'm wearing nothing at all, nothing at all, NOTHING AT ALL.
 

Izick

Member
It's not really hard for a college student to eat enough; in fact, it's easier than it is at most other points in your life.

Wake up early instead of five minutes before class, buy an unlimited meal plan for your school cafeteria, and binge as much as possible to hit your goals. It's not expensive, it's convenient and you can fit it around your schedule.

Unlimited meal plan? Don't know if my school has one.

Also, I have to wake up early since I commute from about 20ish minutes away.
 

Timedog

good credit (by proxy)
So squats are hurting the fuck out of my shoulders (rotator cuff, I think), and leaving huge red scratch marks across my traps from the weight (it's 185, not a huge amount).
 

despire

Member
What did Petrie do?

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=462637

Thread basically got out of control with some people saying that fat people shouldn't be criticized since they have no control over their eating and have bad genetics etc. and some people were saying that they shouldn't be told that it's not in their control and that they can lose the weight if they just put their mind into it. And bunch of other stuff..
 

snoopen

Member
So squats are hurting the fuck out of my shoulders (rotator cuff, I think), and leaving huge red scratch marks across my traps from the weight (it's 185, not a huge amount).

Sounds like it's too high up your back, can't link too much off my phone but you should post a video/pic if you need advice.

The wear on the skin is normal. Look up some Rippetoe videos.
 

Trey

Member
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=462637

Thread basically got out of control with some people saying that fat people shouldn't be criticized since they have no control over their eating and have bad genetics etc. and some people were saying that they shouldn't be told that it's not in their control and that they can lose the weight if they just put their mind into it. And bunch of other stuff..

Yeah, I read through that quagmire earlier. Just turrible.
 

SeanR1221

Member
No, do HIIT after you squat.

Edit: Sorry Tourettes, replied before I saw your response.

Oops, sorry, I misread what your originally typed.

I should probably start off easy to avoid stressing my knees, right?

Something like 5 minute warmup, 5 30 second sprints followed by 1 minute jogs?
 

JB1981

Member
No, I've noticed no knee issues at all. Do they bother yours?

last time i did dumbell step ups i found them really hard on the knees. maybe i was doing them wrong? i was stepping up onto a flat bench, rotating between legs. i would push through the bench with one leg to bring the other leg up. repeat with other leg. are you supposed to step up with the leg on the floor instead?
 

Brolic Gaoler

formerly Alienshogun
So much contradicting advice about hiit. I've heard that you should do on non lifting days and now after lifting?

Huh? The point is to get it in when you can. If the only time you can fit it in is after a lift, do it after the lift.

The only reason you don't do it before lower body work is that it will negatively impact your main lift. If your non lifting day falls right before a lower body day, don't do HIIT then, do it after you do your lower body work. If your off day falls before an upper body day, go ahead and do it on the off day. It's simple.

Oops, sorry, I misread what your originally typed.

I should probably start off easy to avoid stressing my knees, right?

Something like 5 minute warmup, 5 30 second sprints followed by 1 minute jogs?

Yeah, like anything else ease into it.
 
last time i did dumbell step ups i found them really hard on the knees. maybe i was doing them wrong? i was stepping up onto a flat bench, rotating between legs. i would push through the bench with one leg to bring the other leg up. repeat with other leg. are you supposed to step up with the leg on the floor instead?
I'm not doing step-ups right now but am intrigued by the statements by dead and Mj that they are superior to lunges. But I would think doing them on a bench would be bad because of the padding, for the same reason wearing cushioned shoes are?
 

deadbeef

Member
last time i did dumbell step ups i found them really hard on the knees. maybe i was doing them wrong? i was stepping up onto a flat bench, rotating between legs. i would push through the bench with one leg to bring the other leg up. repeat with other leg. are you supposed to step up with the leg on the floor instead?

That's pretty much how I've been doing them. When I get tired I step down pretty hard and I can see how that might bother your knees but I usually terminate the set shortly after it gets to that point so I don't fall and break my neck. But if I'm not tired I step up, drive through with the leg that's up on the bench, then step down, landing more or less on the balls of my beet as I come down.
 

oxrock

Gravity is a myth, the Earth SUCKS!
I'm pretty sure at some point in this thread someone posted a recipe for protein bars you can make at home. I was hoping whoever may have that recipe would be so kind as to repost. Also, is it low carb? Been trying to keep myself in ketosis.
 

entremet

Member
Huh? The point is to get it in when you can. If the only time you can fit it in is after a lift, do it after the lift.

The only reason you don't do it before lower body work is that it will negatively impact your main lift. If your non lifting day falls right before a lower body day, don't do HIIT then, do it after you do your lower body work. If your off day falls before an upper body day, go ahead and do it on the off day. It's simple.



Yeah, like anything else ease into it.

I still do full body workouts, that why I ask. Basically the OP program. So I guess after the full body workout?
 

blackflag

Member
So much contradicting advice about hiit. I've heard that you should do on non lifting days and now after lifting?

Not sure where you are reading all this conflicting info, but if you squat 3x per week and do hiit on off days, your body will not remcover and you will fail miserably.
 

JB1981

Member
That's pretty much how I've been doing them. When I get tired I step down pretty hard and I can see how that might bother your knees but I usually terminate the set shortly after it gets to that point so I don't fall and break my neck. But if I'm not tired I step up, drive through with the leg that's up on the bench, then step down, landing more or less on the balls of my beet as I come down.
It was driving thru with the quads/knees that seemed to put a lot of stress on the knee for me
 

Izick

Member
So thanks for the advice so far, but could anyone answer my earlier question:

Should I just stick with heavy weights and my 8 reps sets?
 

ianp622

Member
So squats are hurting the fuck out of my shoulders (rotator cuff, I think), and leaving huge red scratch marks across my traps from the weight (it's 185, not a huge amount).

You're probably trying to support the bar with your arms. Use a thumbless grip, and remember that your arms should only be pushing the bar against your back, not pushing up. Also, remember to keep your grip close to your body to provide cushioning for the bar.
 

grumble

Member
You're probably trying to support the bar with your arms. Use a thumbless grip, and remember that your arms should only be pushing the bar against your back, not pushing up. Also, remember to keep your grip close to your body to provide cushioning for the bar.

Yeah, here's the trick.

1. Pull shoulders back to create ledge.
2. put hands as close together on bar as you can, to help with ledge.
3. Use thumbless grip, wrists rotated over bar, not under.
4. Keep thoracic spine upright to prevent hunching, which will kill the ledge and put your spine into contact w/ the bar.

You'll feel a hard ledge when you do low-bar squats which is very comfortable to put the bar on. If you do high-bar squats (bar resting on top of traps), it'll be less comfortable.

I've done 300+ lbs for sets across without any discomfort and only slight redness which fades in a few minutes.
 

MjFrancis

Member
I'm not doing step-ups right now but am intrigued by the statements by dead and Mj that they are superior to lunges. But I would think doing them on a bench would be bad because of the padding, for the same reason wearing cushioned shoes are?
I wouldn't do them on a bench for that reason as well. Flat, stables surfaces are winners.

Jim Wendler briefly describes step-ups as an accessory movement in the original 5/3/1 manual. That's why we have no doubt that they are already awesome!

Jim Wendler said:
Step-ups

Remember when all the Olympic lifters thought the Bulgarians replaced squats with step-ups? And since they couldn’t think for themselves, they did too? Remember when they realized the joke was on them? I still laugh about that today. In any case, the step-up is a great exercise for your legs and ass. Just don’t be Cheater McCheaterstein and use a box that’s 10” off the ground, push off with your back leg like a donkey, then post on message boards how you did 315x10 with each leg on step-ups. Actually, the worst part of this whole scenario is you posting on message boards.

As with lunges, you can use a variety of implements and different box heights. A general guideline is to use a box that puts your leg at about parallel to the ground. Single leg movements will reveal coordination, strength and balance problems in the body. Instead of wasting 14 days of assessments, you can do some one leg movements, squatting, deadlifting and Blast Strap pushups and get all your answers in about ten minutes.

For a more detailed description of how to to step-ups, I actually used Jim @ Beastskills tutorial on progressing towards a pistol squat.

http://www.beastskills.com/tutorials/tutorials/38

Modified Single Leg Step-Ups

This next exercise may look familiar, but it has subtle variations that make it much harder and more effective.

Now most people have probably done some sort of leg exercise where they stepped up onto a box or bench. In the very least most of us have walked up a flight of steps! In this exercise we are going to try and take away any and all assistance that the lower leg provides. This will essentially force the body into a one legged squat.

stepup.jpg


First thing to notice is that my bodyweight is shifted forward over the top leg. This is to help ensure that I press only with that leg. The second and most important feature of this exercise to take note of is my bottom foot.

stepupfoot.jpg


I am dorsiflexing the foot, which is just a fancy way of saying that I'm lifting up and holding my toes at the start of the exercise. In a regular step-up, you would instinctually press the ball of this foot into the ground as you flex your calf and ankle to help lift your body up. By lifting up the toe and keeping them off the ground, the calf can no longer help lift you up.

You still need to be careful not to flex and extend your knee when stepping up. This will assist your other leg and reduce the effectiveness of the exercise. So keep your toes up and concentrate on not moving that bottom leg at all. There should be absolutely no movement in the bottom leg. None. Zero. Nada.

This exercise is difficult for two reason, first is that when done correctly the top pressing leg is essentially doing a one legged squat from the bottom up. The second difficulty is overcoming your natural reaction to use that bottom leg. Again, don't flex at the ankle or knee! Only press with the top leg! If this exercise is easy the first time you do it, and you can't do a pistol yet, then you may very well be doing it wrong!

Obviously you can increase or decrease the height of the step to make the exercise easier or harder. If you don't have an open box like I have in the picture, then stand so that your free leg is to one side or another of the box.

Weighting the exercise down is also an option and in my opinion, more comfortable than trying to weight down a pistol. More on that point at the end.
 

ezrarh

Member
So thanks for the advice so far, but could anyone answer my earlier question:

Should I just stick with heavy weights and my 8 reps sets?

Sure. If your goal is to get stronger and bigger. Also you need to progressively add weight.


On a side note, I think I got my grocery store to start finally stocking 2%fat chobani yogurt. Finally noticed them after I put in a letter into the suggestion box a week ago.
 

ianp622

Member
Yeah, here's the trick.

1. Pull shoulders back to create ledge.
2. put hands as close together on bar as you can, to help with ledge.
3. Use thumbless grip, wrists rotated over bar, not under.
4. Keep thoracic spine upright to prevent hunching, which will kill the ledge and put your spine into contact w/ the bar.

You'll feel a hard ledge when you do low-bar squats which is very comfortable to put the bar on. If you do high-bar squats (bar resting on top of traps), it'll be less comfortable.

I've done 300+ lbs for sets across without any discomfort and only slight redness which fades in a few minutes.

Right. To give you an idea of the strength of the ledge, some people can do squats without using their arms at all.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pg8D90wUvAo

Not saying to do that, of course.
 

Brolic Gaoler

formerly Alienshogun
Can't wait for cycle 2 on Monday. Upped my BBB percentages to 50, 50, 60, 50.

60 being bench.

Also, I'm throwing LTEs back into chest day, my triceps have gotten smaller even with all the BBB work, and that's going to start effecting my bench and military press.

My biceps have exploded in size though from doing chins more. So that's good.
 

Izick

Member
Can't wait for cycle 2 on Monday. Upped my BBB percentages to 50, 50, 60, 50.

60 being bench.

Also, I'm throwing LTEs back into chest day, my triceps have gotten smaller even with all the BBB work, and that's going to start effecting my bench and military press.

My biceps have exploded in size though from doing chins more. So that's good.

Oh really? Do you think chin ups are worth incorporating fully into bicep/tricep day if I'm looking for size?
 

Brolic Gaoler

formerly Alienshogun
Oh really? Do you think chin ups are worth incorporating fully into bicep/tricep day if I'm looking for size?

I don't do bicep work at all. It's all coming from chins and kroc rows.

Chins are always worth incorporating into a routine though.

I would do chins on a push day like bench or military press though. That way you offset the movement and maintain symmetry.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom