• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Florida teens who recorded drowning man will not be charged in his death

F

Fuchsdh

Member
ironmang said:
I don't know shit about drug laws but couldn't they at least do something with this? Just to at least have any kind of punishment.
Click to expand...

Even with that, depending on how the local laws are written you couldn't get them for anything, especially if they don't actually have drugs or drug paraphernalia on their person.

(Plus if you're for drug decriminalization I don't think wishing for them to be charged makes much sense. Two wrongs don't make a right and all.)
 
F

Flo_Evans

Member
Earthbound64 said:
Alright?
"He's trying to commit suicide by drowning" would never enter my mind.

Can you link to some instances of people committing suicide by drowning where:
They didn't jump off of a bridge
They didn't weight themselves down by something
There wasn't alcohol involved

"Suicide by drowning" - apart from those above conditions - isn't something that you really can do. Your body won't let you.
Click to expand...

The link is in the op.

You really think your body won't let you drown if you walk fully clothed into the middle of a lake? LOL.
 
I

ironmang

Member
Fuchsdh said:
Even with that, depending on how the local laws are written you couldn't get them for anything, especially if they don't actually have drugs or drug paraphernalia on their person.

(Plus if you're for drug decriminalization I don't think wishing for them to be charged makes much sense. Two wrongs don't make a right and all.)
Click to expand...

I assumed if they were being interviewed after the incident maybe there was someone who had some on them or in their car or whatever.

I am for drug decriminalization but if the laws could be used to punish some shitty people in it's way out then that sounds good to me.
 
K

K Clue iXi

Member
I don't understand how someone could just sit around and watch that. It's very disturbing that they felt no need to even help, and then record him drown like that while yelling obscene stuff at the man. It's disgusting, and these kids deserved to be locked up.
 
M

Mulgrok

Member
Odds are more likely to fail when trying saving someone and end up drowning yourself. Not going/calling for professional help is pretty shitty of them though.
 
5

5taquitos

Member
Mulgrok said:
Odds are more likely to fail when trying saving someone and end up drowning yourself. Not going/calling for professional help is pretty shitty of them though.
Click to expand...
You know what's even shittier? Berating, laughing, and making fun of someone as they drown in front of your eyes.
 
F

Flo_Evans

Member
Earthbound64 said:
So in saying this was a suicide, you're using this article as your evidence?

Oh, alright then, I have evidence this wasn't suicide - the link is in the op.


Also note that I said "Can you link to some instances" - that's plural.
Click to expand...

Ok. What makes you think he wasn't trying to commit suicide? The fight with his girlfriend? Walking into the lake fully clothed? Ignoring the teens that said "don't go in there you are going to drown"

I mean it's sad but his dude killed himself. The teens are assholes but there was nothing they could have resonably done to stop him. By the time he is in trouble he is too far out for anyone to actually help had they called the police or not.
 
Fox Mulder

Fox Mulder

Member
Mulgrok said:
Odds are more likely to fail when trying saving someone and end up drowning yourself. Not going/calling for professional help is pretty shitty of them though.
Click to expand...

It's the US. Calling the cops can get you killed just as easily as trying to rescue a person drowning.
 
R

RS4-

Member
Fuck these kids, fucking garbage.

I hope they're fucked for the rest of their lives with schools, jobs, everything.
 
S

spazchicken

Member
My two questions:

I understand them not going in, risking their lives to save him but why didn't they at least call for help? Not that anyone would have gotten there in time, but still.

What was he doing in the lake in the first place?

Fox Mulder said:
It's the US. Calling the cops can get you killed just as easily as trying to rescue a person drowning.
Click to expand...
Good point.
 
M

Mullah88

Member
How about cities rewarding good Samaritans instead of punishing people not willing to help? Maybe that'll motivate some to do better if they at least know they're getting something back (I know I know, human decency and all)...i also believe this is a generational thing, still doesn't excuse the behavior
 
M

Muffin1611

Banned
Flo_Evans said:
Ok. What makes you think he wasn't trying to commit suicide? The fight with his girlfriend? Walking into the lake fully clothed? Ignoring the teens that said "don't go in there you are going to drown"

I mean it's sad but his dude killed himself. The teens are assholes but there was nothing they could have resonably done to stop him. By the time he is in trouble he is too far out for anyone to actually help had they called the police or not.
Click to expand...

Jesus fucking Christ, the police said nothing about this being a suicide, neither does the article, so stop stating this as if it was a fact.

These teens should have called the cops as soon as they saw him having trouble staying afloat, the end.

Stop trying to rationalize their behaviour.
 
S

SpiceMelange

Member
This is what true evil looks like. Not personally helping at all I would feel a bit of contempt but understandable especially in a drowning scenario. Not even calling for help the bit of contempt turns into pure disgust. Actively mocking the guy DYING on top of that? I truly have no words. Humans shouldn't be capable of this.
 
C

chrisPjelly

Member
Fuck those teenagers and FUCK everyone who uses the "waaaah but they're just kids they'll learn" argument. Sociopathic behavior is NOT NORMAL at this age, and I'm pretty sure people who are this are more than likely the high school bullies of their class. Fine the parents, make them do community service up until college, put them through psychological exams/correction; everything short of putting them in the big house (obviously).
 
Ryzaki009

Ryzaki009

Member
5taquitos said:
You know what's even shittier? Berating, laughing, and making fun of someone as they drown in front of your eyes.
Click to expand...

This. I could even understand them walking away as awful as that is. But to jeer at him while he's dying? That's a certain level of outright malice that's disgusting.
 
G

GeordieMark

Member
spazchicken said:
Good point
Click to expand...

Is it though? Is that how most 911 calls end?

I can't imagine how the family must be feeling knowing how this poor guy had to suffer being taunted as he drowned. And then to find out nothing can be done to get justice against those responsible is so tragic.

I get why the kids might not dive in and try to rescue the guy, but I'll never understand how someone can act they way they did. It's sad that none of them realised what they were doing was extremely wrong and stepped up.
 
Y

yyzjohn

Banned
"To think that anyone would just lack any kind of moral conscience to call for help," Martinez said. "It's one thing to see something and not want to put yourself at risk, but to not call anybody, to sit there and to laugh and humiliate this person is beyond my comprehension."
Click to expand...

This perfectly sums up what I feel. How can anyone turn out like this?
 
D

deo

Banned
What red blooded human-being can possibly watch apathetically as a man literally dies before your very eyes? So heartless... RIP
 
Demoskinos

Demoskinos

Member
Geoff said:
OK you're correct -

So to be sued you either have to have caused harm, broken the law or broken a contract.

You'd have to go on "caused harm" here I suppose. But they haven't really caused any harm. The harm would have happened had they not been there. They just haven't actively tried to prevent harm bur I don't think that's good enough because if it was then it would open up people to suits all over the place when they could have acted and didn't.

/armchair lawyer not even from the same country
Click to expand...
I think there is an easy case of emotional distress to be argued on the families part. People win civil suits over emotional distress all the time.
 
LordKasual

LordKasual

Banned
Earthbound64 said:
attention
Click to expand...

There's a difference between me acknowledging that a person is under no real obligation to save a dying person just because they're witnessing their death (especially if it's an accident or suicide)...and me not being aware that they could have maybe put their phone down and actually tried to help

I don't know why you would jump to such a stupid conclusion after i condemn them in the very next sentence for what they did, but now you have your answer


Earthbound64 said:
Alright?
"He's trying to commit suicide by drowning" would never enter my mind.

Can you link to some instances of people committing suicide by drowning where:
They didn't jump off of a bridge
They didn't weight themselves down by something
There wasn't alcohol involved

"Suicide by drowning" - apart from those above conditions - isn't something that you really can do. Your body won't let you.
Click to expand...

...people drown in pools without even trying to. Why on earth would it be difficult to kill yourself in a pool? It's exceedingly easy, actually.
 
E

Earthbound64

Banned
I H8 Memes said:
Yes I want their names. I dont want to work next to someone like that. Do you?
Click to expand...

There's a difference between "not wanting to work next to someone" and wanting an internet mob launched upon people.


Flo_Evans said:
Ok. What makes you think he wasn't trying to commit suicide?

[...]

I mean it's sad but his dude killed himself
Click to expand...

I mean, when you keep assuming ahead of time your conclusion, this is obviously not going to go anywhere.
 
R

Reeks

Member
Geoff said:
If you haven't broken any laws I'm pretty sure you can't be sued successfully
Click to expand...

What about something like pain and suffering, The last moments of his life were made that much worse by the taunting. I don't know much about the law

It's one thing to not help someone in distress, it's another thing to actively participate in psychological torment.


chrisPjelly said:
Fuck those teenagers and FUCK everyone who uses the "waaaah but they're just kids they'll learn" argument. Sociopathic behavior is NOT NORMAL at this age, and I'm pretty sure people who are this are more than likely the high school bullies of their class. Fine the parents, make them do community service up until college, put them through psychological exams/correction; everything short of putting them in the big house (obviously).
Click to expand...

Right? I was a shitbag in high school, many of us were I'm sure. But this behavior would never have been on my radar.
 
S

spazchicken

Member
GeordieMark said:
Is it though? Is that how most 911 calls end?

I can't imagine how the family must be feeling knowing how this poor guy had to suffer being taunted as he drowned. And then to find out nothing can be done to get justice against those responsible is so tragic.

I get why the kids might not dive in and try to rescue the guy, but I'll never understand how someone can act they way they did. It's sad that none of them realised what they were doing was extremely wrong and stepped up.
Click to expand...

I assumed he was joking or being sarcastic. I don't think any of us believe the majority of 911 calls end with the person who called being killed by police. Just sometimes.

I do wonder how Florida police would treat a group of black teenagers at a scene where someone just died, though.
 
G

GoldenEye 007

Member
These people are sociopaths. Wouldn't be surprised if this group has some kittens among their body counts. They watched someone die and laughed at them about it.

I won't be shocked if in a few years they end up killing someone themselves.

I understand not jumping in to try to save someone - that can get dangerous for both quick if not trained. But you at least call 911.
 
F

Flo_Evans

Member
Muffin1611 said:
Jesus fucking Christ, the police said nothing about this being a suicide, neither does the article, so stop stating this as if it was a fact.

These teens should have called the cops as soon as they saw him having trouble staying afloat, the end.

Stop trying to rationalize their behaviour.
Click to expand...

"F------ junkie, get out the water, you gonna die," one said.

"Ain't nobody's going to help you, you dumb b----," another said. "You should've never got in there."

Police said that Dunn walked into the pond by himself, WKMG-TV reports. Police aren't sure if he was suicidal but said he just had an argument with his fiancee. Dunn's body wasn't found until July 14.
Click to expand...

What else do you need a note? It's pretty clear what happened.
 
M

Muffin1611

Banned
Flo_Evans said:
"F------ junkie, get out the water, you gonna die," one said.

"Ain't nobody's going to help you, you dumb b----," another said. "You should've never got in there."



What else do you need a note? It's pretty clear what happened.
Click to expand...

Yes, it's pretty clear that the kids didn't call for help when they should have.

That you're assuming him being suicidal as fact when the article itself doesn't confirm that to defend these kids is gross.
 
T

Toros

Member
I mean, I don't think anyone really expected them to swim in after him. Especially since everyone has varying expertise in swimming. Call 911 or someone else over? Probably yea.
But, I mean, the very least they didn't have to record the thing like one big joke.
 
J

Javaman

Member
Earthbound64 said:
So you're basing thinking he was trying to drown himself on "What do you think he was doing?"

If I see someone in the water, drowning or otherwise, the thought of "Maybe they're trying to kill themselves" wouldn't even begin to enter my mind. That is so absurd.
Click to expand...

They did see him walk into the water wearing all his clothes.
 
N

Nipo

Member
Have they been doxxed yet? I know if i were hiring someone i wouldn't want a sociopath like that. They posted the video on social media, release their names.
 
C

CountAntonius

Member
LordOfChaos said:
Reminds me of the woman in Kuwait recording her ethiopian maid hanging from a video, both are so rage inducing, but this one would have been even less risk to assist, as helping a drowning person can be dangerous.
Click to expand...

aaaand I just watched a person die...great.

The link is graphic. warning.

Edit: She fucking survived! HOW!

The maid — an Ethiopian who had been working in the country for several years, according to the Kuwait Times — survived the fall. The videographer, her employer, was arrested last week on a charge of failing to help the worker.
Click to expand...
 
Liljagare

Liljagare

Member
ricardo_sousa11 said:
Is this normal? I live in Portugal, and im pretty sure its illegal not to aid someone in such a life threatning situation.
Click to expand...

In alot of countries it's a crime not to report a ongoing event that you are a witness to, accident, robbery, suicides etc to rescue services and police.

But I do not know of any country where it's a crime to decide against getting involved in something that can kill you.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

“It’s what the hero Himmel would’ve done” - Frieren fan stops train knife attacker in Taiwan
33
3K
Zathalus replied
  • Locked
[TNYT] Brazil Blocks X After Musk Ignores Court Orders
Social News Community 2
69
4K
ManaByte replied
[UK] Nicola Bulley, missing woman in strange circumstances (Up: Body found, positive ID)
2
69
8K
Jezbollah replied
The man who owes Nintendo $14m: Gary Bowser and gaming’s most infamous piracy case
2
85
7K
SHA replied
Ancient Roman figures brought to life via AI
Science 2 3
100
9K
Dirk Benedict replied
Top Bottom