• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

GAF Mafia/Werewolf |OT| A forum game of secrets and treachery - sign up to play!

  • Thread starter Deleted member 231381
  • Start date

RetroMG

Member
Hahaha, oh wow, I'm an idiot. OK, writing results now. Shouldn't take too long, because a lot of it got written for the spectator thread.
 

Timeaisis

Member
I've said this before, but I think we need a separate thread for ONUW. I know it's super fun, but it kind of eats up the discussion here a lot. This thread should be for sign-ups, season discussion and game ideas.

Just my opinion, though. I don't mind reading through multiple pages to find a game list or anything, but new players might be super confused.
 

RetroMG

Member
Post is finished. (At least until I get some caffiene)
Ouro PM'd me halfway through the game to say, "If I minage to win this, I want to go down in history as the best mafia player ever."

Ouro, not a clear win, but you're still pretty great.
 

RetroMG

Member
I've said this before, but I think we need a separate thread for ONUW. I know it's super fun, but it kind of eats up the discussion here a lot. This thread should be for sign-ups, season discussion and game ideas.

Just my opinion, though. I don't mind reading through multiple pages to find a game list or anything, but new players might be super confused.

I've thought about it, and maybe. I would still be posting here somewhat to announce games. I'd really love to host the games on GAF itself instead of QT, but that seems unfeasible. (I doubt the Mods would like a new ONUW thread every week.)

I honestly keep thinking ONUW is going to run out of gas at some point, but people keep wanting to play, which I really appreciate. Thanks, guys.

...why...
...did you have the votes all along

No, but order of events and the role list and stuff were all written out.
 

Haly

One day I realized that sadness is just another word for not enough coffee.
I'm wondering how there could have been a tied situation with one vote missing, if there were 12 players

Someone selfvoted so it was 11 with a 5-5 split and 1 undecided (burbeting).
 

Timeaisis

Member
I've thought about it, and maybe. I would still be posting here somewhat to announce games. I'd really love to host the games on GAF itself instead of QT, but that seems unfeasible. (I doubt the Mods would like a new ONUW thread every week.)

I honestly keep thinking ONUW is going to run out of gas at some point, but people keep wanting to play, which I really appreciate. Thanks, guys.



No, but order of events and the role list and stuff were all written out.

It's fine to announce games here, no problem. It's just that ONUW games happen so much more frequently than the season games that it's talked about more than regular mafia...which would be fine if it had it's own thread. At present, this thread seems like 80% ONUW discussion, 10% season 4 talk and 10% signups.

Btw, put me down for the next ONUW game. I'd like to see what all the hubbub is about. :p
 

RetroMG

Member
It's fine to announce games here, no problem. It's just that ONUW games happen so much more frequently than the season games that it's talked about more than regular mafia...which would be fine if it had it's own thread. At present, this thread seems like 80% ONUW discussion, 10% season 4 talk and 10% signups.

Btw, put me down for the next ONUW game. I'd like to see what all the hubbub is about. :p

lol I have you on the list.
 

Haly

One day I realized that sadness is just another word for not enough coffee.
I was pretty sure I had lost. These were my predictions:

Blargonaut -Blargonaut
Burbeting - ?
Coppanuva - ?
Fireblend - Royal_Flush
Haly - Hyperactivity
Hyperactivity - Royal_Flush
Karkador - Hyperactivity
Ourobolus - Royal_Flush
Royal_Flush - Hyperactivity
RoytheOne - Royal_Flush
Salvapot - Hyperactivity
Swamped - Royal_Flush

So #teamflush had one more over #teamhyper and #teamhyper would need both Burbeting and Coppa's votes to win. I assumed that a tie would be no-lynch, and no-lynch means werewolves win, which means #teamflush won in 3 of 4 potential scenarios whereas #teamhyper only won in one.
 

RetroMG

Member
I was pretty sure I had lost. These were my predictions:

Blargonaut -Blargonaut
Burbeting - ?
Coppanuva - ?
Fireblend - Royal_Flush
Haly - Hyperactivity
Hyperactivity - Royal_Flush
Karkador - Hyperactivity
Ourobolus - Royal_Flush
Royal_Flush - Hyperactivity
RoytheOne - Royal_Flush
Salvapot - Hyperactivity
Swamped - Royal_Flush

You are INCREDIBLY close. Blarg did not vote for himself. (he's crazy, not stupid.)

I don't normally do this, but I will put the votes list in the thread.
 

Haly

One day I realized that sadness is just another word for not enough coffee.
Yes, I figured out he voted for Ourobolus...

Which means so did Burbeting. Interesting, actually. I don't see the point of it unless he was intent on generating the "tie".
 

Haly

One day I realized that sadness is just another word for not enough coffee.
LOL COPPA

Switched a wolf and a wolf and then forced a tie.
 

SalvaPot

Member
I guess we can move to quick topic if it becomes a problem.

e: for new page

Nintendo NX Launch Night Mafia

1. cabbeh
2. TheGoddamn
3. roytheone
4. Darryl
5. Sorian
6. batsnacks
7. Fireblend
8. Karkador
9. Burbeting
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.

Heads up, we'll be doing 72 hour days and 48 hour nights.

Put me in, I want to be the one that buys it just for the amiibo.
 
2UxyrcW.gif
 

Swamped

Banned
I guess we can move to quick topic if it becomes a problem.

e: for new page

Nintendo NX Launch Night Mafia

1. cabbeh
2. TheGoddamn
3. roytheone
4. Darryl
5. Sorian
6. batsnacks
7. Fireblend
8. Karkador
9. Burbeting
10. SalvaPot
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.

Heads up, we'll be doing 72 hour days and 48 hour nights.

This sounds like soooo much fun. Are you planning on starting it next week? If so, I probably shouldn't participate.
 

Burbeting

Banned
Blarg is the boss that ends up in the sequel as a secret encounter and because he is behind a side quest, he will actually be stronger than a regular end boss fight. I'll have to level up with side quests this time to take him out. I'll be ready.

If he is a secret boss does it mean he will only join thw game as an replacement later?
 
Blarg is the boss that ends up in the sequel as a secret encounter and because he is behind a side quest, he will actually be stronger than a regular end boss fight. I'll have to level up with side quests this time to take him out. I'll be ready.

woooooooooo fight fight fight~ <3
aaaa yuriii giffff ^____^
i made my yuri run around in his black bunny ears ngl couldnt resist :< dont judge~


@Salva, aawwww rly? :< butbut i am #team800feet~ i believed~ *______*
 

Sorian

Banned
If he is a secret boss does it mean he will only join thw game as an replacement later?

Oh dear, I hope not. Maybe he will be the party member that betrays you halfway through the game, his first encounter is main story but his final encounter is behind the side quest gate and will lead to his re-recruitment
or death
 

roytheone

Member
From now on, I will play every ONUW game with the assumption that I ended up in team wolf, because that seems to be the way these games always go for me :) (expect for that one awesome seer/witch combo together with Sawneeks)
 
Top Bottom