LTTP is looser, has more wasted space, more dead ends. And doesn't have as much story, including LA's super classily done central mystery.
It is bigger and more complex for sure. But I wasn't arguing overall best, just tightest design. LA is so efficient. Understated. It achieves so much with so little. I prefer LA, but fully understand someone preferring LTTP.
The flow of LA - the traversal from screen-to-screen (and room-to-room in the dungeons) is like a guided dance. The player becomes a leaf caught in a draft that the designers have expertly curated to bring out these beautiful swells - the flow is so meticulous. But the story beats and atmosphere feel so knitted into that flow... it's incredibly cohesive. I really feel strongly about this game.
I grew up on OoT and I remember playing a friend's copy of one of the Oracle games as a child, coming away thinking the graphics were stupid and it was just dumb. It wasn't until I was a teenager I was suddenly struck with a bizarre yearning to have and play a Gameboy, like some kind of nostalgia for something I never experienced. Obviously there are a lot of cheap games on the system that are just thrown together, but also some real gems on the system that when I got LA I knew I was playing a really good game, separate from any pre-conceived ideas. Same as when I played Super Metroid and other SNES and NES games for the first time in my late teens and 20's. No nostalgia required, man - there are some very, very well-made games out there. In fact, learning and experiencing the immediacy of older games (in terms of their mechanical play-styles) has actually retroactively diminished my appreciation for newer games I played in my youth and modern games of today that are so full of story and lore but are a chore to play sometimes! AH! Anyhoo...
Also to whoever was talking about the golden leaves quest up there - Yeah, the game is not flawless and there are two or three moments that aren't incredible, but that quest in particular really only takes a few minutes!
Why did I come into this thread..? Oh yeah! I just ordered
Dragon Warrior 2 Cobi's Journey! Don't know much about it and am excited about going in fresh
No spoilers, please and if you're going to rip into it like you did to TheFuzz's new puchase I shan't be reading! Good day!