Not all change is good. I am up for change, but im sceptical of change for the sake of change. Or change which doesnt quite retain the core gameplay that made me a fan in the first place. Change which enhances the general stuff that made me a fan will make my day though.
Agreed.
And while not completely in line with what you are saying, there is the fact that none of the Halo games have ever been the same, despite all of the non-halo fans who think Halo 1 through Reach are basically clones of each other. I was wanting a clone of Combat Evolved for Halo2 - didn't get it. Then I wanted a clone of Halo2 for Halo3 - didn't get it.
Didn't want a clone of Halo3 for Reach - got it. Finally! oh wait...
I'm still waiting on a true sequel to 1 or 2 (said this a thousand times, i know); I'll never get it because there is this unwritten rule where you're not allowed to make sequels to games that don't completely revamp everything. All that change for the sake of change mentality annoys me at times (not always). How about we get a very similar game with better graphics, net-code, a continuation of the story, and only minor changes to the way the game plays? Apparently, that is a novel idea. If you have a game that does something right, don't go making massive changes for the next game. Perhaps I'm largely alone in this thinking, though. Halo2 was major departure from Halo1. And that wouldn't be bad, but no one wanted a major departure and that's mostly where my thinking is coming from. And not that Halo2 turned out bad. It turned out really good thankfully.
But, anytime I hear people say that the Halo series needs to go away, I can't help but wonder how things would be if Halo2 had been truer to Halo1, and then maybe what ended up being Halo2 could have been Halo3. Pleased fans everywhere and not the segregated fan base we have now where a lot the original fans don't even play anymore? And the current haters might have been able to experience a little of what made the first two games so good, with the later Halo games being more true to their original inspiration. When I need a change of pace from a game I love, I play something else. I don't want the game I love to be dramatically redone, at least not for the immediate sequel. And that's what keeps happening with every Halo game...