bobs99 ... said:
It should. Guy literally set the foundations for a lot of the fiction. I mean im not sure how much came from his head and how much came from Bungies, but the Fall of Reach was a fantastic book which could have easily sucked.
No, it shouldn't. =P
I'm not saying his books aren't good. They are. It's just Halo, like Star Wars, should be limited and restricted to the creative limitation of just one person.
With Star Wars, I have my favourite authors but I wouldn't want them writing every book (never mind the logistical problems involved with that or how exhaustive it would be or how bored the authors would become with the series very quickly). It's the same with Halo - the universe is big enough and I'd like to see some new takes on things.
Look at Joe Staten and Contact Harvest - the dude knocked it out of the park. Not saying a Nylund version of the same book wouldn't be good but it takes fresh blood to bring a fresh perspective.
Look at Star Wars. Lucas did the first film. It was sweet. Then he buggered off and let other directors handle the other two. It worked out well for everyone. The he went back and did three more films by himself on a massive ego trip fueled by merchandising, cgi fuckery and fan hatred. I'm still bitter about Jar-Jar.
And Nylund isn't my favourite Halo author, so ner ner. That's why.