• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Hard disk reliability examined once more: HGST rules, Seagate is alarming

Status
Not open for further replies.

mackattk

Member
I had a seagate external 3tb that died within a year. I can get it RMA'd and replaced, but don't know if it is worth it. A hard drive is pointless if it is prone to failure that fast. Fortunately I was able to pull off about 90% of what was on it, but some things are forever lost.

After that I invested money into a file server, and use Unraid and four 3tb wd reds (with one being parity). Hopefully these things will last awhile.
 
Is there any data on the STBX2000401 2.5 inch 2TB drive recommended by eurogamer as a PS4 upgrade in this story?

http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-2014-how-to-cheaply-upgrade-your-ps4-to-2tb

I've already installed one myself (alreadydead) but I've been encouraging my pal to upgrade too and don't want to give him a bum steer. It's currently $85 on Amazon, any more reliable 2TB drives in that price range?

I've heard good things about the 2TB Samsung M9T but it might more - price-wise - than what you're expecting.
 

hateradio

The Most Dangerous Yes Man
I have a Hitachi and a Seagate on the same PC. I know I should stay away from Seagate, but I remember that the barracuda model that I got was supposedly reliable.

I should backup everything, soon.
 

DarthWoo

I'm glad Grandpa porked a Chinese Muslim
The main HDD in my old PC that I built in 2008 is a Seagate and I've not had any issues with it whatsoever (knock on wood) although I'm about to switch to my new PC soon, which has a WD that's making some odd noise that I don't recognize from my old PC. It kind of reminds me of a noise from one of the HDDs in my PC from over a decade ago, which freaked me out because I thought it was dying, but it never actually did for as long as I kept using it, even up to the point that I replaced it with another one just in case.

I'm well familiar with the traditional soft grinding sort of noise that is typical of hard drives. This was a sort of like a very brief scratchy sound that made me think the heads were hitting the platter, but I would imagine that if that was the case, the drive wouldn't have continued to work without errors. It seems to be fairly random, most often heard when the drive has gone idle for a while. Sometimes, but not always, I'll hear it right as the system shuts down too.
 

iamblades

Member
Seagate completely nosedived right when they bought Maxtor, whether that is coincidental or not is a question.

I've always likes the IBM/Hitachi drives though and hope they keep it up.
 

DarthWoo

I'm glad Grandpa porked a Chinese Muslim
So after some reading, I think the strange sounds in my hard drive are in fact automatic head parking, but I'm not absolutely sure. I downloaded a program called HDTune to take a look at the load cycles, which are supposed to be indicative of a problem if they're abnormally high for the amount of time the drive has been active. I've been using my new PC for about a month now, and the load cycles are at 1669. I've read that depending on the drive, a lifetime amount is often in the low hundreds of thousands, so that should give me many years of use, hopefully. Most people who've commented on the subject were alarmed that their cycles were in the tens of thousands within weeks. Is 1669 normal for about a month or less of use? Keep in mind that most of that was just toying with the thing while I completed the process of backing up my old PC, with the thing only being on for a couple hours a day at most. I've only started using this thing officially in the past week.

Edit: I'm not really sure, but do these programs have access to data for the LTD of the drive? I would hope that number is all the cycles since the drive has been first active. I was watching it for a bit, and hit update immediately after one of the squeaks, and it indeed increased the load count by one.

Edit 2: I guess I figured out the answer to my first edit after finding the power on hours count, which is 106, with now 1672 load cycles.
 

MicH

Member
I have two Seagate HDDs; a 1TB and a 2TB one. Bought both in 2012. Good lord I hope they don't fail on me :(
 

Larogue

Member
I remember having countless 40/80gb Seagate drives dieing on me back in early 2000s. I kept buying the same stuff, cause I didn't have alternatives in my area. But few years later, with the power of online shopping I switched to WD and never looked back.
 

Fantasmo

Member
Updated OP with a link to the full study.

If you own the ST3000DM001 (3TB drive), I feel for you.

mark-wahlberg.gif


capture1zusq.jpg


JSJq9ukb.jpg


19.jpg
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom