D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
Interesting. I was switched again. Same flavour text too. Investigation was Enker, didn't reveal anything.
Also Gorlak is still Umbridge.
Also Gorlak is still Umbridge.
- one post I directly referred to my alignment. Scum already knew my role, so I wanted to signal I'm not their enemy. All was written with the intention to survive the night! How should I make clear I'm neutral and not to be killed without giving away my role for everybody? I intended to show them I can support them indirectly (by blocking town) as a neutral (still Ministry of Magic even with V at charge).Roy was there anything else tonight? "You must not tell lies" was what Harry had to write onto his hand when Umbridge was in Hogwarts. Many other students were punished this way. Now as to her alignment, while she was in charge of Hogwarts I really doubt she is aligned with them. She indirectly supported the Death Eathers? Worked for the Ministry of Magic, even when it was taken over by "V". Probably scum? Maybe neutral?
- Because I'm Umbridge and I have none, I honestly thought there are no such things in the game.Also I do NOT believe we have to deal with Horcruxes.
How many horcruxes do you believe to be in the game? 7 sounds too much, maybe the Hufflepuff Cup, Slytherin Locket and Ravenclaw Diadem were left out of the game? The Snake Nagini could be the poisoner and therefore be part of the game. Harry is in here and probably the dairy with Ginny?
As stated above my understanding of good game balancing does not support the idea that one townie knows at the beginning about one scum member.Currently she is neutral/non-aligned; I assume she can be recruited if they know who she is.
It seems we got a Dementor(Role Blocker). And I'm poisoned now.![]()
Did you target somebody specific?! IMPORTANT
I targeted our crazy headmaster Blargonaut with my eye.
That was probably a bad choice - either Miracle or TheGoddamn were switching him, so you likely ended up watching someone random.
Also, seems to be a partial conflict between Rynam saying he will show up as MoM aligned but is sided with Hogwarts, and Gorlak saying he will show up as MoM aligned but is sided with only himself.
I guess it could be purposeful confusion introduced by ninpot for investigation roles but idk.
I didn't realize there was a difference between crucio and stupefy. I thought they were part of one package because they both happened to Blarg, and if they are separate and Gorlak was only stupefied N2, who was crucio'd?
Which investigation roles, though? We have Blarg, who sees guilty/not guilty or whatever the flavour equivalent is, me, who gets a flavour equivalent of guilty/not guilty that is less accurate, and Rynam, who is a watcher, plus didn't Burb have a quasi-investigative role? What are the odds we have a fifth investigative role to be deceived by that, because it doesn't work on the other four.
I don't buy Gorlak's claim. I know he is a neutral but I think he is concealing important information still.
If you can't be recruited, why does my role PM mention you being revealed to the mafia? The way it's worded makes it sound like an extra incentive for me not to die, but if you can't actually co-operate with the mafia, it just seems kinda random and I don't really know why we have anything to do with each other. The recruitment was a guess on my behalf, but I still feel like you are hiding details from us, because your win condition is essentially impossible in a game this large and your role is utterly pointless for a neutral survivor. What good does a roleblock do you?
I'm still not certain about the differences between Stupefy and Crucio. Blarg mentioned both, you only mentioned Stupefy. I thought Stupefy removed vowels and Crucio revealed your role, but I guess it's just Crucio doing both.
You know what kind of game we are playing? The connection between us is purely flavour wise, because you basically love how I treat people (you love the punishing as well). And yes my win condition is very hard, but I can only play with the cards I got.
For clarification: We have 3 Roleblockers in the game!
Dementor - scum (could be a passive ability of L_P)
Punish - neutral
town spell (got blocked tonight, maybe somebody wants to admit they got blocked before? "red" was part of the pm)
Rynam, can you tell us what you saw last night, when you visited Blarg?
Goodbye, dear brother. I shall see you soon, I expect.
T-hat's all, folks! Time to pore over Sawneeks's posts.
Gorlak: I'll go over your posts soon. It's 0335h right now, haha.
So Rynam what were the results you got last night?
Unclaimed roles:
-roleblocking Dementor
-Stupefy (seems like a neutral prankster sort of role, or a scum-based silencing tool)
-poisoner (scum)
Unclaimed roles:
-roleblocking Dementor
-Stupefy (seems like a neutral prankster sort of role, or a scum-based silencing tool)
-poisoner (scum)
Talking points:
Umbridge
Neutral
Lone_Prodigy / Roleblocks:
a) nobody else was distracted by Dementors
L_P has a passive block ability and is scum
b) somebody else was stopped by Dementors and did not target L_P
There is 100% a scum roleblocker in the game, but it tells us nothing about L_P.
LoC
according to Crab we can not be sure about LoC's alignment, which makes Crab's sudden claim slightly... stupid? Than again I can't deny Hyper got catched partly because of this, sidenote: LoC never voted for Hyper.
Very important: He said he'll be dead today, if he's alive we have to question him.
Crab
Between you and me: Why? Why did you do this bs? Blarg, TheG, Miracle and Rynam out in the open and you care to reveal your power for one single (not even confirmed by yourself) townie? You revealed myself, because out of the 5 claimed PRs you are the one to die this night? How? What? Why? Do you truly believe I can become scum and your job is to get me lynched?
Crab
Between you and me: Why? Why did you do this bs? Blarg, TheG, Miracle and Rynam out in the open and you care to reveal your power for one single (not even confirmed by yourself) townie? You revealed myself, because out of the 5 claimed PRs you are the one to die this night? How? What? Why? Do you truly believe I can become scum and your job is to get me lynched?
Two reasons: firstly, my role mechanics. I didn't want to die and have whatever is going on with you happening without town's knowledge. I still don't trust you. Secondly, on reflection I think that actually I'm relatively safe from the mafia as long as you're alive. Until town decides what they want to do with us, there's no point in killing me - it just confirms my story about you, and I'm certain they must want something from you for some reason, given my role. I'm not certain that you can become scum, but I do think you are of use to the mafia and that you are lying about much of your role claim.
Or rather a cowlick with a goal of having all remaining players be marked at the end of the game. Instead of just a set number of successful marks.
Crab what exactly do you investigate and how does it clear LoC from any suspicion?
Gorlak has a good point about L_P. If Blarg was switched with L_P, then I'd say he's a strong lynch candidate.
Until then, this seems like the best course of action to me. Lynch Gorlak...he is certainly hiding things about his role, and killing him will make it clear whether or not Crab is lying. If Crab doesn't die, we lynch him tomorrow. Worst case scenario: we kill a neutral today. Best case scenario: we kill a neutral today and scum tomorrow. One and done.
Vote: Gorlak
Don't you understand? The worst case is killing two non scum people today. How does that help you achieving your win condition?
Look at Sorian's cowlicker role, he had to lick everyone alive too. Don't blame me for putting such a tough win condition for this role into this game.
Don't you understand? The worst case is killing two non scum people today. How does that help you achieving your win condition?