Support NeoGAF

[cireza]

Hello everyone,

With the various releases from Capcom (Fighting Collection, Marvel vs Capcom, Fighting Collection 2), I was wondering what controller you were using to play these games ?

I am not looking for an arcade stick, but an actual home console controller. My reference would be the Sega Saturn controller, or the 6 buttons MegaDrive controller. They have an amazing d-pad.
Having shoulder buttons is also a necessity, to bind LP+MP+HP and LK+MK+HK on L and R respectively. And I mean L and R : one on each side.

I can play most of the the games from these collection on Saturn and Dreamcast, but being able to play them on Series X would be more convenient.

As an added note, I did try the 8bitdo m30 controller, however the shoulder buttons layout is just bad on Xbox. Maybe it is possible to make this work by reassigning buttons in the controller options ?

Any recommendations ? Thanks.

 

[IFireflyl]

Do the six buttons have to be on the front? The 8bitdo Ultimate 2 has two buttons on the back that can be mapped.

https://www.amazon.com/Ultimate-Bluetooth-Controller-Charging-Gaming-Console/dp/B0F194QFT2

 

[cireza]

Do the six buttons have to be on the front?

Yeah, this is what makes it difficult and reduces the options...

 

[CrimsonTide]

Yeah, this is what makes it difficult and reduces the options...

Just pickup a 6 button genesis pad. I would GUESS they make those that can be paired via bluetooth by now eh?

 

[cireza]

Just pickup a 6 button genesis pad. I would GUESS they make those that can be paired via bluetooth by now eh?

On Xbox ? It seems that Xbox is super annoying actually with this, and you need to have wired controller or something ? This is why there aren't many options out there, and most of them are wired.

Controller compatibility is definitely something on which they should improve... a lot.

 

[IFireflyl]

Check these out from Hori:

Fighting Commander OCTA for PlayStation®5, PlayStation®4, and Windows 11/10

stores.horiusa.com

Fighting Commander OCTA Designed for Xbox Series X | S ・ Xbox One

stores.horiusa.com

Also, PDP has this modular controller:

Amazon.com

 

[CrimsonTide]

On Xbox ? It seems that Xbox is super annoying actually with this, and you need to have wired controller or something ? This is why there aren't many options out there, and most of them are wired.

Controller compatibility is definitely something on which they should improve... a lot.

This wont do? https://www.amazon.com/Retro-Bit-Of...0&sprefix=sega+genesis+6+,aps,393&sr=8-5&th=1

 

[CrimsonTide]

Check these out from Hori:

Fighting Commander OCTA for PlayStation®5, PlayStation®4, and Windows 11/10

stores.horiusa.com

Fighting Commander OCTA Designed for Xbox Series X | S ・ Xbox One

stores.horiusa.com

Also, Victrix has this modular controller:

Amazon.com

man those don't look good to play on. The way the buttons look is a no go

 

[cireza]

This wont do? https://www.amazon.com/Retro-Bit-Official-Controller-8-Button-Raspberry/dp/B07P37ZGTF/ref=sr_1_5?crid=2504V0K78QPD1&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.hILJI4ECe-lZOg1VcxTUPpWowhiYF-AnPxIjdX4TFRF1CdJjdS2Kd5ctCU7wdbTgsU3cjYFU4XopN9QcSfqAhQYIAYVxEN7-z1n-TPxMo6bSoLWVVpCFqWh_uZZ3C5QIJUxr-J99LU58DKNLCqT-g-IO8c_AgIKJCNA-ewQcLQOQjGjEfgaFZWisoc8O5gYekS0nsm_vu1k2LhAAW0KvwR1Kc3QtNC-dVjSZp9jdi0E.PEYQsnM2sXLBk6Tf6_Rw5ybpFY25TSSCksH2Ef99NXY&dib_tag=se&keywords=sega+genesis+6+button+controller+usb&qid=1747419370&sprefix=sega+genesis+6+,aps,393&sr=8-5&th=1

I think that it won't work on Xbox no :/

That's the issue. Xbox is never listed on these controller

I see that there is this one here :
https://stores.horiusa.com/fighting-commander-octa-designed-for-xbox-series-x-s-xbox-one/

Any indeed on how the d-pad feels on this one ?

 

[CrimsonTide]

I think that it won't work on Xbox no :/

That's the issue. Xbox is never listed on these controller

For that price, I would damn near try it lol Seems WILD it would not work frankly

 

[CrimsonTide]

I think that it won't work on Xbox no :/

That's the issue. Xbox is never listed on these controller

I see that there is this one here :
https://stores.horiusa.com/fighting-commander-octa-designed-for-xbox-series-x-s-xbox-one/

Any indeed on how the d-pad feels on this one ?

Never used those IFireflyl has?

 

[John Bilbo]

I use Haute board. Works with PCs and every console (for some consoles you need an adapter though).

Edit: Well every console I've used. Those include Switch, PS3, PS4 and PS5.

 

[cireza]

Indeed the Hori Fighting Commander seems to be an option.

Edit : found some feedback about the dpad and it doesn't seem great.

 

[CrimsonTide]

I use Haute board. Works with PCs and every console (for some consoles you need an adapter though).

holy shitballs, that looks wild lol

 

[John Bilbo]

holy shitballs, that looks wild lol

It is basically a keyboard but works as a controller.

 

[CrimsonTide]

Indeed the Hori Fighting Commander seems to be an option.

Edit : found some feedback about the dpad and it doesn't seem great.

That M30 looks cool, but ya said you tried it already?

 

[GrayDock]

I think that it won't work on Xbox no :/

That's the issue. Xbox is never listed on these controller

I see that there is this one here :
https://stores.horiusa.com/fighting-commander-octa-designed-for-xbox-series-x-s-xbox-one/

Any indeed on how the d-pad feels on this one ?

I had the PS5 one and I liked the dpad, not Saturn level, but better than the dualsense one. But I didn't like the micro switch buttons. Opted for a brook fgc adapter and a 8bitdo m30, but it needs to be wired.

 

[CrimsonTide]

I had the PS5 one and I liked the dpad, not Saturn level, but better than the dualsense one. But I didn't like the micro switch buttons. Opted for a brook fgc adapter and a 8bitdo m30, but it needs to be wired.

Yeah the M30 looks dope to me

 

[IFireflyl]

Never used those IFireflyl has?

Indeed the Hori Fighting Commander seems to be an option.

Edit : found some feedback about the dpad and it doesn't seem great.

I haven't used the controller. I was just searching around for controllers that would fit the needed criteria. The PDP controller is more expensive, but seems like more people like the D-pad. It looks like you don't have a ton of options for an Xbox.

 

[cireza]

That M30 looks cool, but ya said you tried it already?

Yeah, the configuration is weird. You get both R buttons as face buttons, and both L buttons as the right triggers. And both stick clicks as left triggers. Super weird.

I will look if it is possible to exchange a stick click with a button in the Xbox controller settings, but I doubt it.

 

[IFireflyl]

Yeah, the configuration is weird. You get both R buttons as face buttons, and both L buttons as the right triggers. And both stick clicks as left triggers. Super weird.

I will look if it is possible to exchange a stick click with a button in the Xbox controller settings, but I doubt it.

I asked my best friend (ChatGPT) if that was a configuration issue on your end, and he (it) confirmed that the 8BitDo M30 has a weird configuration due to how it handles button mapping. I also asked him (it) to compare the 8BitDo M30 to the PDP Victrix Pro BFG, and this was his (its) response:

The 8BitDo M30 and the PDP Victrix Pro BFG (with modular 6-button layout) are both capable fight pads for games like Street Fighter—but they're fundamentally different beasts in terms of design philosophy, precision, and target audience.
Here's a breakdown of how they compare, especially regarding D-pad feel, button layout, customization, and fighting game viability:

---

1. Button Layout & Ergonomics

Feature	8BitDo M30	Victrix Pro BFG (6-button module)
Face Buttons	6 face buttons in 2x3 Saturn/Genesis style	6 face buttons (aligned in a slight curve)
Shoulders/Triggers	L & R shoulder buttons, mapped weirdly	Proper shoulders and triggers, fully mappable
Ergonomics	Lightweight, retro controller	Heavier, modern ergonomics, textured grips

Winner: Victrix – More modern, flexible ergonomics and true 6-button support with no remapping jank.

---

2. D-Pad Quality & Feel

Feature	8BitDo M30	Victrix Pro BFG
D-Pad Style	Saturn-style rolling D-pad	Swappable disc or plus D-pad (modular)
Feel	Soft and smooth for quarter-circle motions	Clicky and tactile, responsive
Precision	Very good for 2D fighters	Tournament-grade; used by pros

M30's D-pad is great for rolling inputs, but soft.
Victrix's D-pad is tighter, clickier, and favored by players needing fast directional precision (e.g., for parries, counters, etc.).
Winner: Victrix – More precise and configurable; optimized for modern fighters.

---

3. Customizability

Feature	8BitDo M30	Victrix Pro BFG
Modular Buttons	No	Yes – swappable stick/D-pad/button modules
Button Remapping	Limited to OS/Steam tools	On-controller or app-based remapping
Back Buttons	No	Yes – with profiles

Winner: Victrix – Fully modular with pro features like back buttons and remapping.

---

4. Build Quality & Price

Feature	8BitDo M30	Victrix Pro BFG
Build Quality	Solid, but plastic and light	Premium – aluminum, rubber grips, pro-grade parts
Price	~$30–40 USD	~$179–200 USD

Winner: M30 for budget, but Victrix dominates on materials and durability.

---

Final Verdict (Fighting Game Focus – Xbox Series X|S)

Category	Winner	Why
Best D-pad	Victrix BFG	Modular, more tactile, better suited for fast-paced games
6-Button Layout	Victrix BFG	Fully supported, logical layout with extra utility
Best Value	8BitDo M30	Budget-friendly and great for classic 2D fighters
Modern Game Support	Victrix BFG	Handles SF6, Tekken 8, MK1 with ease
Overall Winner	Victrix BFG	Pro-level features, superior hardware, future-proof

---

TL;DR:

• 
  
• Get the 8BitDo M30 if you're a retro fan playing on a budget, especially for classic 2D fighters.
• 
  
• Get the Victrix Pro BFG if you want the best D-pad and 6-button setup on Xbox with pro-tier performance and modern fighting game support.

If you're serious about competitive play on Xbox, Victrix is the better investment.

Would you like help sourcing the Victrix with the 6-button module or looking into alternatives like Hit Box-style controllers?

 

[GrayDock]

Yeah, the configuration is weird. You get both R buttons as face buttons, and both L buttons as the right triggers. And both stick clicks as left triggers. Super weird.

I will look if it is possible to exchange a stick click with a button in the Xbox controller settings, but I doubt it.

My M30 is Saturn like, with a,b,c,x,y,z on the front and L and R as shoulder buttons and I can map them as you wanted on the PS5 with the brook adapter. Have you tried with the brook adapter?

 

[Kacho]

I have the Hori Fighting Commander controllers for my Xbox. Works good for Street Fighter. I bought that thing years ago. Not sure if they make them anymore.

 

[CrimsonTide]

I feel like Microsoft could release a simple software update to "unlock" whatever it's controller input restrictions are. Damn shame

Sounds like Hori might be the best route for you in this case.

 

[RoboFu]

if all you want is A DPAD and six face buttons..

https://www.amazon.com/8Bitdo-Bluetooth-Gamepad-Nintendo-Android-Genesis/dp/B07MSN1NPC/ref=sr_1_13?crid=1TZA8MA80AVE3&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.KJQbAcqwWUeSUpTHpCjrm9d6flGUET3RDNZXk_ph7jl_yGv0INyOgbutRuEAa_75taU8CHW7RZEfSAUU-oug6eHMQjPc4-u8SZCymcY0VPqJpXiy4oOVnoKrYLeQgsoVvS4ftYAmjfXvyhqW8FVGUMIdyBX5jFt-qWqd2zn0KcWf66RgDWM5u_qdxL2UJ_PhR6-U2Wm0LcZBC0bWOdbgfZ6Ylg5-WVXy9Gjy2msPFYI.PfBLzf3GFON1Vy3Doscat_DXQwTgJnt0I9P_KbbvbF0&dib_tag=se&keywords=sega+saturn+controller&qid=1747421590&sprefix=sega+saturn+controlle%2Caps%2C161&sr=8-13

if you need thumbsticks for what ever maybe this...

https://www.amazon.com/Retro-Bit-Saturn%C2%AE-Wireless-Controller-Genesis-PC/dp/B0CL93KJ6P/ref=sr_1_3?crid=1TZA8MA80AVE3&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.KJQbAcqwWUeSUpTHpCjrm9d6flGUET3RDNZXk_ph7jl_yGv0INyOgbutRuEAa_75taU8CHW7RZEfSAUU-oug6eHMQjPc4-u8SZCymcY0VPqJpXiy4oOVnoKrYLeQgsoVvS4ftYAmjfXvyhqW8FVGUMIdyBX5jFt-qWqd2zn0KcWf66RgDWM5u_qdxL2UJ_PhR6-U2Wm0LcZBC0bWOdbgfZ6Ylg5-WVXy9Gjy2msPFYI.PfBLzf3GFON1Vy3Doscat_DXQwTgJnt0I9P_KbbvbF0&dib_tag=se&keywords=sega+saturn+controller&qid=1747421590&sprefix=sega+saturn+controlle%2Caps%2C161&sr=8-3

 

[CrimsonTide]

if all you want is A DPAD and six face buttons..

https://www.amazon.com/8Bitdo-Bluetooth-Gamepad-Nintendo-Android-Genesis/dp/B07MSN1NPC/ref=sr_1_13?crid=1TZA8MA80AVE3&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.KJQbAcqwWUeSUpTHpCjrm9d6flGUET3RDNZXk_ph7jl_yGv0INyOgbutRuEAa_75taU8CHW7RZEfSAUU-oug6eHMQjPc4-u8SZCymcY0VPqJpXiy4oOVnoKrYLeQgsoVvS4ftYAmjfXvyhqW8FVGUMIdyBX5jFt-qWqd2zn0KcWf66RgDWM5u_qdxL2UJ_PhR6-U2Wm0LcZBC0bWOdbgfZ6Ylg5-WVXy9Gjy2msPFYI.PfBLzf3GFON1Vy3Doscat_DXQwTgJnt0I9P_KbbvbF0&dib_tag=se&keywords=sega+saturn+controller&qid=1747421590&sprefix=sega+saturn+controlle%2Caps%2C161&sr=8-13

if you need thumbsticks for what ever maybe this...

https://www.amazon.com/Retro-Bit-Saturn%C2%AE-Wireless-Controller-Genesis-PC/dp/B0CL93KJ6P/ref=sr_1_3?crid=1TZA8MA80AVE3&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.KJQbAcqwWUeSUpTHpCjrm9d6flGUET3RDNZXk_ph7jl_yGv0INyOgbutRuEAa_75taU8CHW7RZEfSAUU-oug6eHMQjPc4-u8SZCymcY0VPqJpXiy4oOVnoKrYLeQgsoVvS4ftYAmjfXvyhqW8FVGUMIdyBX5jFt-qWqd2zn0KcWf66RgDWM5u_qdxL2UJ_PhR6-U2Wm0LcZBC0bWOdbgfZ6Ylg5-WVXy9Gjy2msPFYI.PfBLzf3GFON1Vy3Doscat_DXQwTgJnt0I9P_KbbvbF0&dib_tag=se&keywords=sega+saturn+controller&qid=1747421590&sprefix=sega+saturn+controlle%2Caps%2C161&sr=8-3

You kinda missed this thread

Apparently Xbox wont allow that badass Saturn controller to work, lease the OP does not think so

And he tried the M30 and was not for him

 

[Dacvak]

Check these out from Hori:

Fighting Commander OCTA for PlayStation®5, PlayStation®4, and Windows 11/10

stores.horiusa.com

Fighting Commander OCTA Designed for Xbox Series X | S ・ Xbox One

stores.horiusa.com

Also, PDP has this modular controller:

Amazon.com

Seconding the hori controllers. I don't have this specific model, but I have an older version of their 6 face button fighting pad and it's flawless.

 

[cireza]

Have you tried with the brook adapter?

Nope, never used. Does it work on Xbox ? I will investigate.

RoboFu : thanks bro, but these won't work natively on Xbox.

 

[cireza]

And he tried the M30 and was not for him

m30 was pretty good, but the issue was with the weird triggers layout

I have checked in the Xbox controller options though, and it is indeed possible to remap the stick buttons. So I might find a solution here.

 

[CrimsonTide]

m30 was pretty good, but the issue was with the weird triggers layout

I have checked in the Xbox controller options though, and it is indeed possible to remap the stick buttons. So I might find a solution here.

Ahhh.... might work after all

Also, Hori as you know is king of fighting controllers, so that is also a good option.

 

[CrimsonTide]

Think I will pickup a $20 saturn pad for my steam deck after all this lol

Be good for retro gaming

 

[ulao]

Hello everyone,

With the various releases from Capcom (Fighting Collection, Marvel vs Capcom, Fighting Collection 2), I was wondering what controller you were using to play these games ?

I am not looking for an arcade stick, but an actual home console controller. My reference would be the Sega Saturn controller, or the 6 buttons MegaDrive controller. They have an amazing d-pad.
Having shoulder buttons is also a necessity, to bind LP+MP+HP and LK+MK+HK on L and R respectively. And I mean L and R : one on each side.

I can play most of the the games from these collection on Saturn and Dreamcast, but being able to play them on Series X would be more convenient.

As an added note, I did try the 8bitdo m30 controller, however the shoulder buttons layout is just bad on Xbox. Maybe it is possible to make this work by reassigning buttons in the controller options ?

Any recommendations ? Thanks.

What xbox?

If OG, then I'd just go with the Bliss-Box adapter. You can use any controller on it with that.

 

[thegame983]

I bought this. really like it and cheap

https://www.aliexpress.com/item/100....order_list.order_list_main.15.3a9c1802hL3qy8

 

[CrimsonTide]

What xbox?

If OG, then I'd just go with the Bliss-Box adapter. You can use any controller on it with that.

OP using a Series X

 

[RaZoR No1]

Anyway to use the adaptive controller and mid it to your liking?

 

[cireza]

I bought this. really like it and cheap

Thanks, didn't know about it.

Anyway to use the adaptive controller and mid it to your liking?

The setup would be a bit too complicated for my liking, but thanks for the suggestion.

Overall I will look into the Hori Fighting Commander, the controller posted by thegame983 and maybe the m30 again. Appreciate all the advice.
I will share my pick in the future and some feedback !

 

[Crayon]

All I can say is beware cheap hori stuff. Their expensive stuff is nice enough, but they also make junk.

 

[RaZoR No1]

And what about the Turtle Beach Stealth Pivot Xbox version?
Can even be used as an normal one, just rotate the buttons