Syphon Filter
Member
Anyone notice that British singers dont sound British when singing but sound American? And then they sound British when talking normal. How come?
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
How come british singers dont sound british when singing?
- Thread starter Syphon Filter
- Start date
March Climber
Member
Long answer:
Short answer:
Notice how much more 'british' the production sounds on these:
It explains why one would keep a british accent when singing on them.
Short answer:
And the song/genre.
Notice how much more 'british' the production sounds on these:
It explains why one would keep a british accent when singing on them.
PuppetMaster
Member
Its just the nature of music. People try to reproduce the sounds of songs and singers they were influenced by.
I also discovered recently this trend for some newer singers to vocally imitate the sounds created by autotune. What was originally a tool used to correct pitch in poor singing, is now is now an actual "style" of sound that people reproduce vocally.
I also discovered recently this trend for some newer singers to vocally imitate the sounds created by autotune. What was originally a tool used to correct pitch in poor singing, is now is now an actual "style" of sound that people reproduce vocally.
Brigandier
Member
\m/ (v.v) \m/
One of the best bands ever!!
FunkMiller
Member
Dunno. Barney sounds pretty British to me:
diffusionx
Gold Member
They need to get a separate loicense to sing British and some don’t get it
bitbydeath
Member
To be fair the US also lose their fascination with the letter R when they sing too.
Deep down we’re all just Aussies!
Deep down we’re all just Aussies!
willothedog
Member
they do 
jufonuk
not tag worthy
March Climber
Member
Adds to my point
The ceasars are Swedish.
Pegasus Actual
Member
Works both ways a bit.
I think it was Conan but maybe it was Leno (I used to watch that late night block back in the 90s pretty religiously as a kid) had a joke which was something like "At first I didn't like Green Day because I thought they were British, now I don't like them because I realized they're trying to sound British". Stuck out because it seemed obvious to me that they must be British at the time.
The Killers are another one that sounded super British to me but are from Vegas or some shit. No wonder Mistah Broightsoide is so big at the ol' rainy Glastonburies or whatever the hell they got going on over there.
Nowadays I can pick out "Americans influenced by Brits" and vice-versa a lot better.
I think it was Conan but maybe it was Leno (I used to watch that late night block back in the 90s pretty religiously as a kid) had a joke which was something like "At first I didn't like Green Day because I thought they were British, now I don't like them because I realized they're trying to sound British". Stuck out because it seemed obvious to me that they must be British at the time.
The Killers are another one that sounded super British to me but are from Vegas or some shit. No wonder Mistah Broightsoide is so big at the ol' rainy Glastonburies or whatever the hell they got going on over there.
Nowadays I can pick out "Americans influenced by Brits" and vice-versa a lot better.
Tams
Member
All these liocences are a right pain in the arse.
There's my driver's loicence, then my TV loicence, my singing in a British accent loicence, my loitering on a street corner loicence, my butter knife loicence...
Soodanim
Member
I’ve never thought that about Green Day (any examples?), but Killers has shocked me. Granted I only know Mr Brightside, but I always assumed they were English. Seemed obvious
kevboard
Member
many do sound British. the main thing you'll hear is the non-rhoticity whenever a word ends in "er" and when an r is proceeded by a vowel and followed by a consonant.
how very apropos.
"so much foa the golden futuah"
"angah in my haaht"
notice how he sings in a non-rhotic accent. the R at "er" endings and when proceeded by a vowel and followed by a consonant.
but the rest of "american" or "british" accents mostly comes down to intonation and speech rhythm. when you sing both of that goes out the window. when I sing English I don't have a german accent, when I talk English I absolutely do... it's all about the rhythm and intonation change that makes it sound so similar.
but when I sing English, I also do it in a non-rhotic "accent" so to speak, as the German R at the end of words is very similar to the stereotypical one in England.
One of the best bands ever!!
how very apropos.
"so much foa the golden futuah"
"angah in my haaht"
notice how he sings in a non-rhotic accent. the R at "er" endings and when proceeded by a vowel and followed by a consonant.
but the rest of "american" or "british" accents mostly comes down to intonation and speech rhythm. when you sing both of that goes out the window. when I sing English I don't have a german accent, when I talk English I absolutely do... it's all about the rhythm and intonation change that makes it sound so similar.
but when I sing English, I also do it in a non-rhotic "accent" so to speak, as the German R at the end of words is very similar to the stereotypical one in England.
Last edited:
ÆMNE22A!C
NO PAIN TRANCE CONTINUE
Can't say I've noticed.
Then again that's obvious if one doesn't have a broad spectrum regarding music.
I like your observation, nice thought.
03:03
Last edited:
Digital-Aftertaste
Member
I'd say David Bowie's later songs have a British accent. Let's Dance, Ashes to Ashes, Black Star, etc.
Nitty_Grimes
Made a crappy phPBB forum once ... once.
Are you on about modern day where its all fucking auto-tune and nobody can actually sing or?
Last edited:
Pegasus Actual
Member
It was when Dookie blew up. So really anything off that album. Listening to it now I can pick up that there really are a lot of American vowel sounds in there but he's also singing in a way that emulates earlier British punk rock influences. But that's how it sounded to my 13-year-old American self. And apparently at least one late night comedian.
