I went out with a girl like that...well actually she wasn't like that at the time, but she transformed into "giggly goth" over one summer. Then the next summer she was full blown depressed goth.
And bjork brings up a good point. How can so many people that dress the same sit there and claim to be "different". I see so many people with mohawks that it isn't even shocking, so doesn't that like defeat the point. This one goth girl told me she dressed that way to set herself apart...but there were other people that were trying the same thing, thus making it pointless.
Wear your American Eagle with pride, boys.