-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Japanese Readers Vote For The Next "Poster Manga" for Shonen Jump
- Thread starter Imperial Bishop
- Start date
- Status
Imperial Bishop
Banned
Shortly after its first few volumes were published, so around 1998 or 1999. The early volumes sold immensely well for a new manga series at the time.
JustAnotherMike
Member
So that's why I haven't seen it in a while. Both WT and HxH authors being sick sucks.
What is the next "this is ridiculous" manga since both Bleach and Toriko are done?
magnificenz
Member
I love World Trigger. Its on hiatus now though. I love HunterXHunter. It is also on hiatus now. Currently loving Shokugeki. Black Clover plot is interesting, but the direction is a bit dull/cliche imo. Still read it tho.
I do follow/read Haikyu!! and My Hero Academia too. I would love Haikyu!! more if only I did not read Slam Dunk. I don't know why I keep comparing it. Maybe I miss Slam Dunk.
Boruto is just okey and nothing special. I guess I'll try reading the rest. I might like them. Currently reading Legendary Moonlight Sculptor light novel (I dont wanna wait for the manga).
I do follow/read Haikyu!! and My Hero Academia too. I would love Haikyu!! more if only I did not read Slam Dunk. I don't know why I keep comparing it. Maybe I miss Slam Dunk.
Boruto is just okey and nothing special. I guess I'll try reading the rest. I might like them. Currently reading Legendary Moonlight Sculptor light novel (I dont wanna wait for the manga).
Not quite on par with OP. About Naruto levels.
Poetic.Injustice
Member
So in truth they really have nothing.
I doubt Jump will ever have a big hit like One Piece or Naruto again.
The business model of having printed manga will become even more outdated in the future. Naver are way ahead of them in that department.
I doubt Jump will ever have a big hit like One Piece or Naruto again.
The business model of having printed manga will become even more outdated in the future. Naver are way ahead of them in that department.
Permanently A
Junior Member
What's Haikyuu about? Is it good?
Haven't watched too much sports anime but I enjoyed Ping Pong.
Haven't watched too much sports anime but I enjoyed Ping Pong.
Yeah, plus SnS is amazing! <3
HxH being second is hilarious.
I camein not knowing what to expect and got hooked even knowing just the basics of the sport. It's really really enjoyable. The popularity of it has warrant.
Please give me more chapters Togashi 
Only in the middle of the second season but in a way I really can't describe it cleverly mixes shonen themes/tropes with a volleyball anime.
I camein not knowing what to expect and got hooked even knowing just the basics of the sport. It's really really enjoyable. The popularity of it has warrant.
Maybe they could slowly release one page at a time on the cover.
Edit: Oh wait, my mistake, I almost forgot that it's WEEKLY. Too quick.
It's about volleyball.
It's also amazing. Great characters, action, humor and a surprising lack of usual manga/anime tropes. Anime has beautiful animation by Production I.G.
Bounceounce
Member
One Piece was getting number one rankings since the first chapter.
http://onepiecepodcast.com/2015/04/...rankings-part-1-romance-dawn-to-arlong-park/g
One Piece is a monster, but something as big as Naruto will probably happen at some point.
Paracelsus
Member
No it will not, that's why they resurrected DragonBall.
To bad Togashi pace kills any chance on ever catching up.
Bounceounce
Member
Nope, the manga industry/the way we consume media has changed too much.
And even with the changes in the industry it was a total anomaly for Jump to have three of the biggest series of all time in their magazine (not that Bleach was ever as big as One Piece, nowhere near as big, it wasn't even as big as Naruto, but it's reach worldwide and for the period that it was doing very well in Japan prior to the series going downhill allows for it to be grouped into that Big 3 category), which is something they'll never replicate to that degree.
I'm sure that would've happened anyways.
Wasn't a post child series despite it's sales. During that era it was still all about Dragonball.
Askherserenity
Member
Why isn't Promised Neverland on there? Is it too different for most Jump readers?
My Hero Academia looks poised to become a Naruto sized hit before long. World Trigger was pushing Bleach numbers before the hiatus and IIRC Black Clover does alright. The problem for Shueisha is that it doesn't have another One Piece waiting in the wings. Passing up on Attack on Titan must really sting, having that and OP in the same magazine would give all their other titles WAY more exposure.
ChasingComets
Member
Too new/no anime. This poll really reflect the current moment, where Haikyuu just had a great anime season and a good manga run.
Regardless, I don't think Neverland can ever quite reach poster status. I really like it, but I feel like the popularity will cap at a much lower point than either Haikyuu or MHA.
Newtype-001
Member
Should be HeroAca or Haikyuu.
personally HeroAca.
HxH can be a choice when togashi actually comes back consistently releasing chapters.
personally HeroAca.
HxH can be a choice when togashi actually comes back consistently releasing chapters.
i should check out promised neverland some time
surprised to see saiki kusuo no psynan that high, it is pretty good though, i think once gintama's gone that's going to take its place as jump's main comedy
world trigger is very underrated imo, hope the author gets well and continues soon
hinomaru zumou is also underrated, kimetsu no yaiba as well
surprised to see saiki kusuo no psynan that high, it is pretty good though, i think once gintama's gone that's going to take its place as jump's main comedy
world trigger is very underrated imo, hope the author gets well and continues soon
hinomaru zumou is also underrated, kimetsu no yaiba as well
Thats good to tknow, thanks
Too bad there is nothing at the link, would have liked to read it
Imperial Bishop
Banned
While Dragon Ball Super is definitely adding a lot of coin to Shueisha's pockets, the manga doesn't run in Weekly Shonen Jump.
Haikyuu is almost close to Naruto-levels of volume sales.
http://onepiecepodcast.com/2015/04/...-rankings-part-1-romance-dawn-to-arlong-park/
This link works.
NHarmonic.
Member
I'm hooked on it though, i wish at least he had that consistency on the releases.
Permanently A
Junior Member
HxH being second is hilarious.
Only in the middle of the second season but in a way I really can't describe it cleverly mixes shonen themes/tropes with a volleyball anime.Please give me more chapters Togashi
I camein not knowing what to expect and got hooked even knowing just the basics of the sport. It's really really enjoyable. The popularity of it has warrant.
That first ep was so cheesy damn. I'm sort of curious what direction it'll go since his
antagonist became his teammat
Permanently A
Junior Member
HxH being second is hilarious.
Only in the middle of the second season but in a way I really can't describe it cleverly mixes shonen themes/tropes with a volleyball anime.Please give me more chapters Togashi
I camein not knowing what to expect and got hooked even knowing just the basics of the sport. It's really really enjoyable. The popularity of it has warrant.
Tsukki is such an instigator goddamn. I'm enjoying it so far, thanks for the recommendations.
MrSaturn99
Member
One Piece will be the "face" so long as it exists, but out of that list MHA is probably the closest. Those two and Gintama are probably the best three series running in Jump today.
I really do wonder how this new era of Jump is going to turn out. There's still some great stuff in there but with the number of big name series that ended in recent years (with Gintama soon to join their ranks) I can't help but feel a little wary.
Also, this thread reminded me I should really get around to reading Haikyuu.
I really do wonder how this new era of Jump is going to turn out. There's still some great stuff in there but with the number of big name series that ended in recent years (with Gintama soon to join their ranks) I can't help but feel a little wary.
Also, this thread reminded me I should really get around to reading Haikyuu.
Robot Carnival
Member
I'm glad to see World Trigger on that list. it's a really underrated piece.
MaximumSpider
Banned
I should catch up to Haikyuu.
LegendofDragoonLives
Member
Isn't Haikyuu already a hit? Totally deserved btw, amazing series <3
that's not even on shounen jump though
anyway i think original tokyo ghoul is better, re seems a bit convoluted or something i dunno :/
SoulUnison
Banned
Boruto screwed itself right out of the gate on Page 1 by doing a massive timeskip/In Media Res.
Like, if that's where the series is going... I'm good, thanks, and the small details of it that are actually interesting like Boruto apparently being a swordsman, having weird tattoos and eventually getting someone's Byakugan are completely spoiled now.
Imperial Bishop
Banned
From what I've heard, it's mediocre at best and doesn't do anything interesting or exciting.
Principate
Saint Titanfall
Black Clover is a cynical shounen. I'm fairly certain the author is aware it's mediocre so the second the manga starts to drag a war randomly breaks out with tons of flash batles or a big evil dude shows. There's no build up, it's just a conveyor belt of popular shounen tropes.
Glad Hinomaru Zumou made the list, in spite of it's low sales it's a very well paced and high quality manga so deserving of it's continued serialization.
- Status